...
Show More
I initially gave this three stars but as I wrote my review I moved it down - it's 2.5, really.
Taken in historical context I think the book is pretty interesting. It would have been an experience to read it at the time it was written. However, based on where Scifi/Fantasy is now and our current sociopolitical climate, it was just ok.
I believe I understand Bradbury’s overall message and goal for the book but in my opinion it was a bit overreaching. His attempt to encompass the entirety of human experience regarding Mars exploration and colonization was just too much. The stories tumble around like clothes in a dryer; each making a point or two but without a cohesive structure. The book was effective at points but not the achievement I had expected.
What disappointed me most about the novel was the very poor characterization of women. Of course, this must be considered in the cultural climate existing when the book was written, nonetheless, women could have received better treatment. Bradbury choose to include minorities in what he intended to be a favorable light – whether he is succeeded is debatable – why not women? We do see some sympathetic female characters in the stories Ylla, The Off Season and The Million-Year Picnic but Genevieve Selsor in The Silent Towns is just embarrassing.
Overall, I see the merit of the work due to its ideas and believe it was a step forward in speculative fiction in its time, but otherwise it was just ok. I will note that I did really enjoy Usher II. It made the book worth reading for me.
Taken in historical context I think the book is pretty interesting. It would have been an experience to read it at the time it was written. However, based on where Scifi/Fantasy is now and our current sociopolitical climate, it was just ok.
I believe I understand Bradbury’s overall message and goal for the book but in my opinion it was a bit overreaching. His attempt to encompass the entirety of human experience regarding Mars exploration and colonization was just too much. The stories tumble around like clothes in a dryer; each making a point or two but without a cohesive structure. The book was effective at points but not the achievement I had expected.
What disappointed me most about the novel was the very poor characterization of women. Of course, this must be considered in the cultural climate existing when the book was written, nonetheless, women could have received better treatment. Bradbury choose to include minorities in what he intended to be a favorable light – whether he is succeeded is debatable – why not women? We do see some sympathetic female characters in the stories Ylla, The Off Season and The Million-Year Picnic but Genevieve Selsor in The Silent Towns is just embarrassing.
Overall, I see the merit of the work due to its ideas and believe it was a step forward in speculative fiction in its time, but otherwise it was just ok. I will note that I did really enjoy Usher II. It made the book worth reading for me.