lovely.

Below is a review I wrote for ninetyandnine.com in 2003. I think it sums up my thoughts on Tolstoy quite nicely! - Kris





Tolstoy? Timeless!
What Men Live By
By Kris A. Newman
November 3, 2003

In an age where we are inundated with information, sometimes it’s hard to remember what the nitty-gritty of Christianity is all about—is it found in worship? Is it found in Bible memorization? Is it found in hearing the best preacher? Isn’t there someone who can tell us the simple rules that men ought to live by?

Actually, the simple lesson has been found. Count Leo Tolstoy wrote it many years ago in his novella and short story collection entitled What Men Live By and Other Tales.
It begins with What Men Live By, where we find an angel named Michael, disobedient to the plan of God, has fallen to earth and relies upon the mercy of a simple peasant family. Michael is assigned three lessons to learn—what dwells in man, what is not given to man, and what men live by. Unwittingly, the peasants and their neighbors teach him the answers.

Woven through this beautiful allegory of giving is a sense of common beauty. The beauty of family life and community breathe through every chapter. Tolstoy’s characters live simply, unburdened by the traps of possessions. They have one another. They have their work. They have God. What else could they need? They are not oblivious to the grand riches of the wealthy around them. Rather, they are satisfied with the richness of their relationships.

The first lesson is learned when the peasant looks beyond his own discomfort to share his coat and clothes with Michael as he suffered by the wayside. The peasant’s wife, likewise, has pity on Michael. They feed him, clothe him, and give him work. Their kindness teaches Michael that love is what dwells in man.

A year later, a verbose, obnoxious wealthy man demands that Michael make him a pair of boots from a specially tanned piece of hide. The rich man threatens that Michael will not be paid for the work unless the boots last for an entire year as if they were new. Michael, however, sees the death angel hovering near the rich man. He knows that God is about to take the man’s life. Carefully, he cuts and stitches the leather into a very fine pair of slippers. While the confused peasant is reprimanding Michael for wasting the gentleman’s materials, a messenger enters to tell them the gentleman perished before arriving home. They will need burial slippers instead. Thus, it was learned that it is not given to man to know what he needs. One must rely upon God for his needs to be met.

Several years pass before the final lesson is learned. Through the telling of a sad story with a rich ending, we learn that men live by love for another.

I John 4:20 tells us, “If a man say, I love God, and hateth his brother, he is a liar; for he that loveth not his brother whom he hath seen, how can he love God whom he hath not seen?” (I John 4:20). Tolstoy is clearly teaching this lesson in What Men Live By. This thought is exemplified by the last line of the story, “All men live not by the thought they spend on their own welfare, but because love exists in man.” When we learn to give, we discover a new depth in God and the relationship He has with us.

Continuing on this theme, Tolstoy moves on to “Three Questions,” the story of a king who seeks to find the answers to these questions—“What is the most important thing to do? Who is the most important person? When is the most important time?” The answers are found when the king becomes actively engaged in helping others. The busier the king is about giving, the happier and safer his life becomes.

“The Coffee House of Surat” explores thoughts of spiritual prejudice and misconception. A discussion of religiosity introduced by a bitter, deceived man causes a disruption in the coffee house. Finally, a student of Confucius quietly addresses the crowd. He likens God to the sun and man’s ideas of God to their ideas of the sun. He concludes that the more learned a man becomes about the subject of God, the more he realizes how big God is, how small man is; He points out that our relationship with God should draw us closer to one another and never cause us to become haughty.

Finally, the Devil presents himself to a man who is overcome with greed in “How Much Land Does a Man Need?” Driven to succeed, Pahom continues seeking after the elusive perfect piece of land. Finally, the title question is answered—six feet deep by six feet long. That’s all you have in the end.
It is common knowledge that the great Russian author was a wealthy landowner. How, then, could he write about peasant life, and why would he choose peasant life as his recurring subject in this book? (After all, he did write War and Peace.)

However, Tolstoy had a spiritual awakening of some sort in his later years. Realizing his need of people rather than riches, he denounced the money he made, freed his serfs, and worked among them as an equal. Thus, his teachings relating to Christianity flow from a forgiven heart.

Although rife with historical intricacies, the substance of Tolstoy’s teaching is timeless. Likewise, the opium drink in the coffee house was a common thing in Tolstoy’s day and certainly not allowable today. However, coffee houses still brew conversations and discussions as meeting places for bright minds.

Tolstoy is worth reading. Just don’t start with War and Peace. Start with his short story collections. You need go no further.

ninetyandnine.com
© 2003, Kris Newman

Great works containing The Cossacks, The Death of Ivan Ilych, and The Kreutzer Sonata.

I find Tolstoy unbearably boring, but he has two good stories in this collection: The Devil, and The Kreutzer Sonata. Death of Ivan Ilych is readable, Father Sergius isn't bad, but the rest are a waste of time. Funnily enough, his two best ones are clearly inspired by Dostoevsky's storytelling style.

Simply, without a doubt, some of the very best works of literature of all time. Hadji Murad, especially, is a novella that is a miniature epic in itself that does not receive the attention it deserves. Read it, read it, read it!

Gotta read the masters, man...Tolstoy does it all: life & death, love & lust, faith & hopelessness.

Francine Prose recommends this book and translation in her list of Books Must Read Now.

Love love love

I've been reading these stories on and off for a while now, and I finally finished the last one today. I would absolutely recommend them to anyone, and I think it's quite difficult not to appreciate (and really enjoy) Tolstoy's matter-of-fact style of writing. He was amazingly intuitive about the Chechnyan situation in Hadji Murad, and I have always enjoyed his take on kings and leaders. All of the stories are good and worth reading, but I think Master and Man was my favorite.

This edition is shit. The printing is terrible - I don't know how to describe bad printing but, like, the thing with the words didn't press down hard enough on the paper or whatever.

My introduction to Tolstoy. A very difficult volume to put down.

This week I attempted to read from Tolstoy and began with the first story in this book called "Family Happiness". Though I rated it "ok", it did have lots to think about. It showed quite the contrast between the joy of exciting romance and falling in love to the more long-lasting love that suffers long and is kind. I couldn't really decide if I liked it or not. It is the story of a girl--happy when young and in love, getting caught in the social traps of the world and the unhappiness that it brings, to finally decide that love doesn't have to be wild and exciting but can be love with constancy and enjoyment of the simple things in life. It is sad to see people waste their life and time in sin, but good to get it back by repenting.