...
Show More
First published in 1980, "The Bourne Identity," by Robert Ludlum, is the first in a highly successful series of thrillers about a covert operations specialist named Jason Bourne. A hugely popular film starring Matt Damon, which was based on this novel and produced in part by the author, debuted in 2002, kicking off an updated, alternate version of this story.
Because the Matt Damon film and the novel are so drastically different, a lot of fans of the book truly hated the Bourne films. I'm someone who enjoys both. I watched the first three Damon films in the theater, thought they were okay, and enjoyed them a lot more when I rewatched them in 2020.
Then I read the novel, in January 2021, and while I thought the book's twisty storyline was far superior to the plot reveals in the film, reading the book doesn't take away from my enjoyment of the Damon film trilogy. I just appreciate the movies for different things.
The novel has a lot of problematic material that made me cringe. Aging women are really demonized in this story. Adulterous women receive more hate in this book than the story's primary antagonist, who is horrifyingly immoral and a nonstop murderer. Fat men and effeminate men are ruthlessly mocked. There is a strong current of racism in the text that is brutally common in action/adventure stories like this one. The Damon movie is incredibly racist as well, but in a different way than the book.
What author bell hooks labels "the white supremacist capitalist patriarchy" is fully on display in this thriller, but the book also has powerful counter-narratives that work against that messaging, too. Yes, there is a lot of material in the book and the movie that is problematic. But there is also a huge amount of feminist messaging and feminist narrative structure in the novel. The character of Marie, Bourne's love interest, is drastically different in the book than how she was portrayed in the Damon film. Marie is a powerhouse in the novel, every bit as much Bourne's equal, and her role in the story is part of what makes the book so explosively good.
I liked the way the novel ended, but I enjoy the Damon movie's ending a lot more. The climactic action scene was one place where the movie returns to its literary source material, and utilizes a lot of thematic and stylistic elements that make the final confrontation so rewarding in both stories.
The romance in the novel is so much stronger and more enjoyable in the book than the movie, but I like the final romantic scene in the Damon movie much more than the final scene in the book.
If all thrillers were as good as "The Bourne Identity," I would read a lot more of them. This is definitely an absorbing piece of fiction. Highly enjoyable, mysterious, and full of compelling characters.
Five stars. Recommended for thriller fans, and anyone who enjoyed the movies.
Because the Matt Damon film and the novel are so drastically different, a lot of fans of the book truly hated the Bourne films. I'm someone who enjoys both. I watched the first three Damon films in the theater, thought they were okay, and enjoyed them a lot more when I rewatched them in 2020.
Then I read the novel, in January 2021, and while I thought the book's twisty storyline was far superior to the plot reveals in the film, reading the book doesn't take away from my enjoyment of the Damon film trilogy. I just appreciate the movies for different things.
The novel has a lot of problematic material that made me cringe. Aging women are really demonized in this story. Adulterous women receive more hate in this book than the story's primary antagonist, who is horrifyingly immoral and a nonstop murderer. Fat men and effeminate men are ruthlessly mocked. There is a strong current of racism in the text that is brutally common in action/adventure stories like this one. The Damon movie is incredibly racist as well, but in a different way than the book.
What author bell hooks labels "the white supremacist capitalist patriarchy" is fully on display in this thriller, but the book also has powerful counter-narratives that work against that messaging, too. Yes, there is a lot of material in the book and the movie that is problematic. But there is also a huge amount of feminist messaging and feminist narrative structure in the novel. The character of Marie, Bourne's love interest, is drastically different in the book than how she was portrayed in the Damon film. Marie is a powerhouse in the novel, every bit as much Bourne's equal, and her role in the story is part of what makes the book so explosively good.
I liked the way the novel ended, but I enjoy the Damon movie's ending a lot more. The climactic action scene was one place where the movie returns to its literary source material, and utilizes a lot of thematic and stylistic elements that make the final confrontation so rewarding in both stories.
The romance in the novel is so much stronger and more enjoyable in the book than the movie, but I like the final romantic scene in the Damon movie much more than the final scene in the book.
If all thrillers were as good as "The Bourne Identity," I would read a lot more of them. This is definitely an absorbing piece of fiction. Highly enjoyable, mysterious, and full of compelling characters.
Five stars. Recommended for thriller fans, and anyone who enjoyed the movies.