...
Show More
Some mixed feelings on this one, so let's get the cons out of the way first;
At times the plot felt a little predictable and run-of-the-mill, often feeling like the writer had leaned too heavily on certain tropes of expected horror plot beats to procure the narrative.
Overall this certainly didn't ruin my experience, but these are criticisms worth mentioning that I felt did detract from the atmosphere at times.
Now for the bits I enjoyed;
First of all, there are some instances of animal mutilation which are gory and recorded in vivid detail, and while for some that may be stomach-churning, I found the descriptions horrifying in the right way. My experience with the voodoo and cultic practises was similarly one of morbid fascination and whilst it is entirely valid for some readers to be upset by these, I personally found them nothing by beneficial to the story.
Throughout the narrative, John Saul maintains an air of dread and whilst I feel it took its time to get going, I do feel this greatly helped to build tension and an atmosphere of just... evil. All of this combined with well-worded prose and I found myself engulfed by the tale. As a fellow writer, I have a great deal of appreciation for Saul's craft as a wordsmith.
Overall, the positives significantly outweigh the negatives, but despite that the flaws can be distracting at times. Perhaps deserving of a little more than four stars, but I can only input integer numbers of stars so... four it is!
At times the plot felt a little predictable and run-of-the-mill, often feeling like the writer had leaned too heavily on certain tropes of expected horror plot beats to procure the narrative.
Overall this certainly didn't ruin my experience, but these are criticisms worth mentioning that I felt did detract from the atmosphere at times.
Now for the bits I enjoyed;
First of all, there are some instances of animal mutilation which are gory and recorded in vivid detail, and while for some that may be stomach-churning, I found the descriptions horrifying in the right way. My experience with the voodoo and cultic practises was similarly one of morbid fascination and whilst it is entirely valid for some readers to be upset by these, I personally found them nothing by beneficial to the story.
Throughout the narrative, John Saul maintains an air of dread and whilst I feel it took its time to get going, I do feel this greatly helped to build tension and an atmosphere of just... evil. All of this combined with well-worded prose and I found myself engulfed by the tale. As a fellow writer, I have a great deal of appreciation for Saul's craft as a wordsmith.
Overall, the positives significantly outweigh the negatives, but despite that the flaws can be distracting at times. Perhaps deserving of a little more than four stars, but I can only input integer numbers of stars so... four it is!