Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
29(29%)
4 stars
37(37%)
3 stars
33(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 25,2025
... Show More
n  “It’s easy to be a good Christian, Olav, as long as God makes no more demands upon you than inviting you to church to listen to beautiful songs and asking you to obey Him while He pats you with His fatherly hand. But a man’s faith can be tested on the day when God does not want the same thing he wants. Let me tell you what Bishop Torfinn said the other day when we were speaking of your case. ‘May God grant,’ he said, ‘that the boy learns to understand over time that for a man who insists on doing what he wants to do, there will soon come a day when he sees he has done what he never intended to do.’”n

Sigrid Undset received the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1928 — mostly in consideration of her Kristin Lavransdatter series which centres on the life of a headstrong woman in Medieval Norway — and now in a new English translation, her series about Olav Audunssøn (which centres on a headstrong young man in Medieval Norway and released previously as The Master of Hestviken in 1927) is evidently being rereleased, beginning with this first volume: Olav Audunssøn: I. Vows. I haven’t read Undset before and I find myself impressed by her ability to bring such a foreign time and place to breathing life without resorting to digressions on culture and customs and artefacts; everything we need to learn is organically inserted into the plot and dialogue, and it was all simply fascinating to me. The plot itself is pretty melodramatic — with murders, betrayals, seduction, and exile — but it works well to put Undset’s characters into extreme situations in order to explore Norway’s evolving religious and legal codes. This was a pleasure to read and I look forward to finding more by Undset. (Note: I read an ARC through NetGalley and passages quoted may not be in their final forms.)

n  That was how things stood for Olav Audunssøn, that was his fate; he would be with Ingunn forever. That was the only certainty in his life. He and Ingunn were inextricably bound to one another. He seldom thought of that evening when he and Ingunn were promised to each other, and it had been many years since anyone had mentioned the betrothal of the two children. Yet underlying everything he felt and thought, it was there like solid ground beneath his feet: the fact that he would always live with Ingunn. The boy had no kinsmen he might turn to. No doubt he knew that Hestviken was now his property, but with every passing year his images of the estate became less and less clear. They were like bits and pieces of a dream he recalled. If he imagined that one day he would return to live there, he found it comforting and right that he would take Ingunn with him. The two of them would face the unknown future together.n

When Olav Audunssøn was seven years old, his dying father implored his acquaintance Steinfinn Toressøn to take his boy in as his foster son, and in a gesture of drunken goodwill, Steinfinn agreed and also bound the boy in betrothal to his own six-year-old daughter, Ingunn. Olav and Ingunn were then raised together as brother and sister, but always aware that when they were grown, they would be wed. But when Ingunn’s parents both die while she is still underage, her father’s kinsmen refuse to acknowledge Olav’s claim to the girl, and begin seeking a more advantageous alliance. Olav — only fifteen himself at this point and uncertain of what inheritance awaits him in the south of the country — will take matters into his own hands, and always believing that he is following God’s law if not man’s, will tread an honourable path that nonetheless puts Ingunn under unbearable pressure.

Olav and Ingunn are both from Norway’s noble class, and the family they are raised in are rich landholders with crops and livestock, hired servants and thralls. The people follow ancient codes of honour — revenge can involve duels and murder, with bloodprices paid out to families and fines paid out to the Church — and while the Church is attempting to enforce a new common legal code, the noblemen themselves believe, “These new laws are as effective as a fart. The old laws work better for men of honor.” The question of whether Olav and Ingunn are legally bound is interpreted differently by the Church and the kinsmen, but appealing to the protection of the Church, Olav sets off on a very long quest while Ingunn finds sanctuary with other family members:

n  Shivering with cold, she realized that she was nothing more than a defenseless, abandoned, and fatherless child, neither maiden nor wife, and not a single friend did she have who would uphold her right. Olav had disappeared and no one knew where he was; the bishop was gone; Arnvid was far away, and she was unable to send word to him. There was no one to whom she could turn except her old paternal grandmother, who had now retreated into childhood, if her ruthless kinsmen should decide to take their revenge on her. A small, quivering, and trembling thing, she curled herself around the only scrap of determination within her weak and instinct-driven soul: she would steadfastly trust in Olav and remain faithful to him, even if, because of him, they should torture the very life out of her.n

Like I said, melodramatic stuff, but it serves to explore the crimes and consequences attributed to men (mostly involving murder), the crimes and consequences involving women (mostly involving chastity), how the rapidly changing fates of Norway’s monarchial class affected the lives of their noblemen in the sticks, and how the Catholic Church was attempting to enforce control over folks who defaulted to their own ancient codes of honour. At its heart, this is a love story, but it so completely explores the inner lives and outer realities of people from such a different time and place from me that I don’t think it could have been done half so well without the melodrama; it’s epic and I hope to eventually learn how the story ends.
April 25,2025
... Show More
A slow burn, but ultimately satisfying. Set in 13th-century Norway, the story involves Olav and Ingunn, a couple betrothed since childhood. Family politics interferes with their love and threatens to void the engagement, but they consummate it illicitly. That unfortunate point of no return initiates a decade-long period of uncertainty and shame interspersed with murder, infidelity and exile.

In essence, this story is about how sin and its consequences seep into life, poisoning it in unexpected ways, even when we pursue atonement and redemption. Long and plodding, in the midst of it I wasn't sure if I would continue the series--but once I reached the end I grabbed the next one, The Snake Pit.
April 25,2025
... Show More
I'd give this five stars if it was a better translation. Unlike Tina Nunnally's recent translation of Kristin Lavransdatter, this one by Charles Chater from 1928 was a bit archaic (words like "meseems" and "I trow" kind of bug me.) Nevertheless, it was still an intense and moving story--and it's only Part I.

It's set in the late 1200s in Norway, and is the story of Olav and Ingunn's struggle to validate their betrothal. Again I'm struck by the intriguing mix of pagan traditions, Christianity, and a culture where laws are new and manslaughter common--especially as retribution for any wrong done to a family. And the characters are well-developed--both Olav and Ingunn have the best intentions, but are flawed and make mistakes. Olav struggles as an orphan to make his way in the world while Ingunn can do nothing but wait for him. The role of women is also interesting--their virtue and chastity are valued only because of the honor they would bring to a man, and Ingunn has no identity outside of being someone's daughter, wife, or kinswoman. And murder is more acceptable than a woman caught in adultery. Ingunn is treated harshly for her choices, but Olav's ending decision makes me excited to read the next volume.
April 25,2025
... Show More
At a drunken revel, a very young Olav Audunsson is betrothed to Ingunn, the child of his father's comrade-in-arms, Steinfinn. When his father dies, Olav is taken in by Steinfinn and raised as a member of his family. Nobody pays particular attention to the betrothal, thinking it was just a drunken jest. However, as Olav and Ingunn mature, they develop deep feelings for one another, and eventually take matters into their own hands. This sows the seeds for a tragedy of star-crossed love.

Undset evokes a medieval Norway that feels real and immersive, without inundating the reader with the fruits of research, as some authors do clumsily. The countryside, morals, politics, and customs of the people and the time are made clear. As her characters mature and her plot develops, she sows the seeds for a vast historical epic, of which Vows is just the first of four parts.

I don't think I'll be along for the ride, though. I found it hard to empathise with the impetuous Olav, who seemed to have an unerring capacity to damage his own future. To me, Ingunn and Arnvid were the characters that I was most drawn to, because they seemed to be succumbing to the grinding pressure of fate, rather than the dumb actions of adolescent youth.
April 25,2025
... Show More
Part 1 of a tetralogy, with anew translation from Tiina Nunally (who also did the fabulous translation of Kristin Lavransdatter).

In many ways this book is similar to KL--it too takes place in Medieval Norway. The main characters are landowners and those in the church. But Olav is an orphan raised as a foster son, betrothed to his foster sister by their fathers before his father's death.

This volume shows their happy childhoods, and then the whirlwind of familial manipulation, misunderstanding, benign neglect, greed, and rampant misogyny that was all part of upper class Norwegian life. Olav and Ingunn are determined to marry--this volume details the trouble, suffering, difficulties, violence, negotiation, and waiting (so much waiting) that they go through to fulfill their betrothal.

I didn't find this volume quite as gripping as book 1 of KL, but that may be partly because OA is a man. I personally relate more to Ingunn, but she is a little insufferable.

Looking forward to part 2, though I have no idea when it will be out.
April 25,2025
... Show More
It is fantastic, but one step under Kristin. Darker too. TW if you're trying to conceive.
Prepare for the second tome to destroy Olav's character (as a woman, it broke me to read he wouldn't be a gorgeous character like Lavrans anymore - not that she is perfect, oh no!).
GET TIINAS TRANSLATION.
I really wanted to know what Ingunn suffered from, and what was the reason Arnvid was so... celibate friendly (rumors etc).
Will update.
April 25,2025
... Show More
1928. First vol. in The Master of Hestviken tetralogy. Well written, compelling to read. In 14th century Norway, life is hard as parents die young and children (for better of worse) are left to the care of others. A young couple in love are separated by relatives and then by circumstances. Will their love endure until they can be reunited?
April 25,2025
... Show More
Excellent start to The Master of Hestviken. Oh my goodness. There is such detail in the lives of those in this book, set in 13th century Norway. This first book follows Olav and Ingunn who were betrothed as children and raised as siblings. They both always knew they were destined to marry and were committed to each other from the start.

As in all lives, things do not always work out. Much angst and death and political intrigue and church intrigue. I loved it. I am waiting on the second book. I can't wait to see what happens next.

If you liked or loved "Kristin Lavransdatter," you will love this.
April 25,2025
... Show More
I received Olav Audunsson as part of a NetGalley giveaway.

In medieval Norway, Olav and Ingunn are promised to one another as children, their fathers old friends. They grow up side by side as foster siblings and become deeply fond of one another, but past rivalries and present circumstance tear them apart. Unable to marry one another, yet unable to marry anyone else, years of separation and tragedy elapse before fate brings them back together...but it remains to be seen whether the lovers will be irrevocably changed.

This started slow for me--I was stuck about 1/3 of the way through for a couple weeks as their childhoods and family dynamics were established. But after getting over that hump, I polished off the rest in about two days and I'm eager to read the other two volumes in the series. It was richly narrated and really immersed me in a vivid, violent I'm quite unfamiliar with. The love Olav and Ingunn have for one another is heartfelt and realistic, and I found myself wholly engaged in their story. A fascinating historical epic.
April 25,2025
... Show More
I think the story is worth another star, but the translation is a bit tedious.

#metoo in medieval Norway

As much as I love many things Viking, it was nice to read a story about the Old Norse that didn’t involve boats with dragon heads
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.