Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 20 votes)
5 stars
9(45%)
4 stars
4(20%)
3 stars
7(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
20 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
An extremely well-crafted cookbook with interesting recipes. As a baker, I particularly loved the dessert section. A few great drink recipes are also included. My only complaint is that it did not include a recipe for Hainanese Chicken Rice, a Singaporean staple that I have been missing since I moved away.
April 17,2025
... Show More
"If you want to know what Indonesia tastes like, all you have to do is drive around [Jakarta] and eat." - Karma Alwi

What a wonderful book this is - full of recipes and detailed information about ingredients essential to cooking dishes from the Spice Islands.
A comprehensive look at the foods of these countries could fill a ten-volume set. Here, I can only present a collage of some of the dishes, people, and places I've grown to love from my visits. [...] I've also purposefully omitted certain difficult-to-make dishes, such as roti canai, one of my favorite Malaysian street foods, an Indian-style bread that requires a tricky, multistep sequence of letting dough rise and then kneading it to achieve the correct croissant-like texture. Instead, I've focused primarily on classic, easy-to-make home dishes, the heart and soul food of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore.
[introduction, p.28]

And what a collage it is!! I confess we were disappointed that a recipe for roti canai is not included, but there are zillions of other really wonderful sounding dishes included in this large and comprehensive single volume.

There is a very good section about ingredients, including excellent photographs and tips (with a list of Asian names they may be called) on where and/or how to find the things that aren't necessarily in most supermarkets. One of the intriguing fruits listed in Chapter 3, "At the Market: Ingredients", is asam gelugor, a "sour-tasting, apple-sized, yellow fruit, native to Malaysia [that is] rarely eaten raw. Instead it is thinly sliced — skin, core, seeds, and all — thn left to dry in the sun". Apparently the dried fruit is added to savoury dishes as flavouring.

But what really caught our attention were James Oseland's beautifully written opening sections to each chapter.
We turned off the main road onto a smaller, bumpier one that wound its way toward Karma's home. A few minutes later we reached a one-story cement house tucked away in a grove of old eucalyptus trees. We parked in the driveway and walked to the front porch. The rain had stopped. The chirping of crickets filled the air. Karma sat on the porch in half darkness, his head buried in a small paperback book. [...] Tanya sat down in a nearby chair and indicated, with a subtle arching of her eyebrows, that I should do the same. Karma continued to read his book. [...] After a few more minutes of silence, Karma cleared his throat.
      "Indonesia is a riddle that will never be solved," he whispered in English.
[...] He lit a clove cigarette. Its fragrant smoke curled around his head like a halo.
[7. Street Foods" Satays, Salads, and Snacks, p.139]
~ ~ ~ ~
When Rohati and I reached the outskirts of the market, the reason that she liked to arrive early was instantly clear. Even at seven o'clock, the place was already jam-packed with customers. After making our way through a maze of crates and untethered goats, we entered the main hall and climbed the stairs to the second flour. From this vantage point, the huge market extended like a vast tapestry. It was the most radiant display of vegetables that I'd ever seen. Mounds of chiles four feet high lay next to equally high piles of water spinach. Hundreds of vendors called out their offerings in an overlapping singsong that rose above the hall in what sound like a single chant. [...] [T]he display looked like a still life painted by a Dutch master. Baskets of spices spilled over onto bunches of kaffir lime leaves and fresh turmeric rhizomes just pulled from the ground.
[9. Vegetables, p.202]
~ ~ ~ ~
She proceeded to dip her hands into canisters and show me seemingly random amounts of spices: two handfuls of cumin seeds, three times as many coriander seeds, a satchel's worth of fresh turmeric, and so on. Like all the region's great cooks, Renny measured by agak-agak (instinct), not set amounts.
[11. Poultry, p.268]


There were a few things that gave us pause:

a.) the instruction on p.182 to discard meaty chicken pieces that have been used to make stock, or to reserve them "for another use". Why not suggest the other uses rather than condone throwing good food away?
b.) to keep cooked rice dishes warm by covering with aluminum foil rather than a plate, overturned bowl, or loosely fitting lid.
c.) the presence of so much sugar in both sweet and savoury dishes

immediately book-marked:
• crisp-fried shallots, p.84
• crisp jicama and pinapple salad Rojak, p.159
• lemongrass-scented coconut rice Nasi Uduk, p.176 (with the cautionary note: "Don't try to halve this recipe — that would result in the aromatics sitting on top of the rice rather than being submerged in it, yielding a poorly flavored dish".
• spiced Nyonya rice Nasi Kemuli, p.180
• virtually all of the vegetable dishes, p. 205-231
    ○ braised cabbage with dried shrimp Pow Choy Ha Mai, p.212
    ○ green beans with coconut milk Sambal Goreng Buncis, p.216 "a touchstone in Indonesian cuisine, as common as macaroni and cheese in the United States"
• chicken rendang with cinnamon and star anise Rendang Ayam, p. 278
• Mien's garlic fried chicken Ayam Goreng, p.283
• Nyonya-style spiced fried chicken Inche Kabin, p.285
April 17,2025
... Show More
Nothing particularly wrong with it, but 90% of these recipes I've already found for free online. And there are very few pictures, so it isn't that interesting to look at, either. The anecdotes were pretty interesting, though.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Very dense and packed with information. A master's thesis on Indonesian cooking techniques.
April 17,2025
... Show More
A delectable collection of regional recipes from Indonesia, Malaysia and area. Notes on culture, procurement, cooking etc. very enjoyable.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Three stars for now. You really need lots of specialty ingredients to pull these off. Buy and free kaffir lime leaves when you find them!
April 17,2025
... Show More
Excellent cookbook with alot of innovative dishes and would love to spend some serious time cooking out of it, but need to wait until kids who don't eat this are not home
April 17,2025
... Show More
All the recipes we've tried so far have been fantastic. And I love the author's clear descriptions (complete with gorgeous color photos) of ingredients that would otherwise be unfamiliar to many western cooks. This is also clearly a very personal project for him -- his descriptions of memories of various events, friends, and meals in the region are well written and evocative. For anyone with an interest in Indonesian and Malaysian food, this is a must-own.
April 17,2025
... Show More
This is another winning ethnic cookbook I've featured on my blog. Everything I've made has been fantastic!
April 17,2025
... Show More
The first time, I was pretty skeptical. "What the heck does this American guy know about my Indonesian cuisine?" However, I was totally wrong, this book followed a path to be authentic. For my western friends who want to learn Indonesian cuisine, I recommended this book to them.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.