...
Show More
If I were still a teenage boy, I'd give it 5 stars, but at 75 I want more depth, although Heinlein wrote this in 1956 with an 18-year-old lead. Here's an example of the teenage mindset: "Nobody objected to a kiss or two if somebody wanted to check on the taste."
Here's some quotes illustrating ideas broached.
1. Mind-reading , instantaneous action-at-a-distance
2. punched cards. Personal computers not envisioned
3. I don’t believe all this complicated universe got here by accident
4. [N]o man can tell another man and that is where his duty lies.
Some attitude quotes that may repulse you.
1. ... a bureaucrat standing behind every productive worker dreaming up more rules and restrictions
2. ...root cause of war is always population pressure Heinlein titled a chapter, Lebenstraum. Echoes of Hitler's verbalized motives, though not his real motives imo, which were an individual psychopathy that drove him to assert his influence over everything and to do it by force when necessary.
3. The only thing wrong with that boy is that his parents should have walloped him , instead of telling him how bright he was
4. Unc[le] pointed out gently that she had better have her husband’s consent. and women please go over there by the pantry so that I can pick the men who will go. Classic, ancient paternalism
A few examples of skilled craftmanship:
1. The first person narrator makes some comments then says Answer me that pulling the reader smoothly into the storyline.
2. Doctor Devereaux said to write it all Nice foreshadowing (p 3) of a doctor who is not ntroduced until much later (p 52)
3. A long time later I told Van about it Interesting flash forward
4. too heavy for humanity’s fallen arches. humorous comparison, though not done with parallel options which would have made the attitude ludicrous rather than intelligently flippant.
5. Heinlein's uses words to dust over the tracks of facts and leave the reader, me, wondering just what the facts are. That suited the sci fi novel which couldn't maintain rigid logic through its what-if-twins-could-read-the-other-twin's-mind-instantaneously premise.
As my lengthy review indicates, I found the novel stimulating and rewarding.
Here's some quotes illustrating ideas broached.
1. Mind-reading , instantaneous action-at-a-distance
2. punched cards. Personal computers not envisioned
3. I don’t believe all this complicated universe got here by accident
4. [N]o man can tell another man and that is where his duty lies.
Some attitude quotes that may repulse you.
1. ... a bureaucrat standing behind every productive worker dreaming up more rules and restrictions
2. ...root cause of war is always population pressure Heinlein titled a chapter, Lebenstraum. Echoes of Hitler's verbalized motives, though not his real motives imo, which were an individual psychopathy that drove him to assert his influence over everything and to do it by force when necessary.
3. The only thing wrong with that boy is that his parents should have walloped him , instead of telling him how bright he was
4. Unc[le] pointed out gently that she had better have her husband’s consent. and women please go over there by the pantry so that I can pick the men who will go. Classic, ancient paternalism
A few examples of skilled craftmanship:
1. The first person narrator makes some comments then says Answer me that pulling the reader smoothly into the storyline.
2. Doctor Devereaux said to write it all Nice foreshadowing (p 3) of a doctor who is not ntroduced until much later (p 52)
3. A long time later I told Van about it Interesting flash forward
4. too heavy for humanity’s fallen arches. humorous comparison, though not done with parallel options which would have made the attitude ludicrous rather than intelligently flippant.
5. Heinlein's uses words to dust over the tracks of facts and leave the reader, me, wondering just what the facts are. That suited the sci fi novel which couldn't maintain rigid logic through its what-if-twins-could-read-the-other-twin's-mind-instantaneously premise.
As my lengthy review indicates, I found the novel stimulating and rewarding.