...
Show More
Illustrator: Elivia Savadier
Publisher: Atheneum Books for Young Readers
Year: 2002
Interest Level: K-3
Reading Level: 2-3 for an English Spanish bilingual reader
I remember seeing this book when it first came out and I remember liking it a lot. I loved how the girl is proud to come from a multicultural home. Having that message in children's literature is important. I also think it's great to represent a child who comes from a mixed Latino and European background, because I do not see that often in children's books.
I decided to revisit the book for my multicultural children's lit class. Perhaps it's the difference of the beginning of my career in bilingual education and 10 years later, or perhaps it's reading this genre of books with a more critical eye, but when I read this book now, I am a little more concerned. I felt there was a little bit of a competition (though unintentional) between the European grandparents and the Mexican grandparents. For many of the events she did with her European (country never stated) grandparents, she did something similar on a bigger scale with her Mexican grandparents. On one hand, it puts the Mexican grandparents in a brighter light, which is less common for mainstream children's lit, but I don't understand why they could not do activities that were different. Watching a video of a circus and then seeing a circus in real life- what would compare? Then holding balloons and flying a homemade kite- what would compare? The girl in the story enjoys the time with both sets of grandparents, but I don't like how the Saturdays and domingos seem to be compared with each other.
I love the integration of English and Spanish in a way that the reader really needs to know both languages. There is not bilingual glossary. The Spanish is not thrown in here and there with a superficial "hola" or "gracias. I enjoy that. It validates children's ability to code switch in their homes without using "token" words for the sake of having them.
I think this book could definitely be used with younger grades that study "All About Me" and different kinds of families.
Publisher: Atheneum Books for Young Readers
Year: 2002
Interest Level: K-3
Reading Level: 2-3 for an English Spanish bilingual reader
I remember seeing this book when it first came out and I remember liking it a lot. I loved how the girl is proud to come from a multicultural home. Having that message in children's literature is important. I also think it's great to represent a child who comes from a mixed Latino and European background, because I do not see that often in children's books.
I decided to revisit the book for my multicultural children's lit class. Perhaps it's the difference of the beginning of my career in bilingual education and 10 years later, or perhaps it's reading this genre of books with a more critical eye, but when I read this book now, I am a little more concerned. I felt there was a little bit of a competition (though unintentional) between the European grandparents and the Mexican grandparents. For many of the events she did with her European (country never stated) grandparents, she did something similar on a bigger scale with her Mexican grandparents. On one hand, it puts the Mexican grandparents in a brighter light, which is less common for mainstream children's lit, but I don't understand why they could not do activities that were different. Watching a video of a circus and then seeing a circus in real life- what would compare? Then holding balloons and flying a homemade kite- what would compare? The girl in the story enjoys the time with both sets of grandparents, but I don't like how the Saturdays and domingos seem to be compared with each other.
I love the integration of English and Spanish in a way that the reader really needs to know both languages. There is not bilingual glossary. The Spanish is not thrown in here and there with a superficial "hola" or "gracias. I enjoy that. It validates children's ability to code switch in their homes without using "token" words for the sake of having them.
I think this book could definitely be used with younger grades that study "All About Me" and different kinds of families.