Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 40 votes)
5 stars
10(25%)
4 stars
19(48%)
3 stars
11(28%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
40 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
I thoroughly enjoyed these stories even though most of them followed the same themes- idealism, dreams, longing for youth, the modern flapper as heroine, and the spoiled crashing world of riches. I particularly loved May Day, Winter Dreams, The Ice Palace and Head and Shoulders. May Day being the best from the collection, follows a unique and raw portrayal of the political tension at the end of world war I, intermingling various plots and characters to end in a shocking revelation. Each of the story is beautifully written and somehow reflecting on the superficiality of the world around him, Fitzgerald sympathises, condemns and ridicules the same world he desperately wanted to be a part of, which is why his stories are filled with sharp sardonic wit and poignancy.
April 17,2025
... Show More
The story about the bobbed haircut, loved it! Didn't read the rest though.
April 17,2025
... Show More
These are some stories that show us his early work and we see the beginnings of some of his fascinating characters.
April 17,2025
... Show More
This collection of short stories provides an excellent look into Fitzgerald's talents prior to the publication of Gatsby, which he's best known for. They range from the slightly fantastical Diamond As Big As the Ritz, to the defiant Bernice Bobs Her Hair.

Looking forward to reading more of his work!
April 17,2025
... Show More
"The Diamond as Big as a Ritz" and the pirate story were the most memorable stories. the others ones were forgettable. After reading the diamond story, i didn't want to read his other stories because i wanted this one to go on and on. It reminded me of a Roald Dahl's story because of the wonderful imagery and imagination. It's interesting to note that this story only sold for $400 while others which were not nearly as good sold for much more. the story's main theme is how much wealth corrupts - even to the point of murder.

I'm not very impressed by fitzgerald's characters. i know that it's harder to portray a three dimensional character in a short span of a story, but even his characters in his novels lack depth and vulnerability. His use of language is superb:

"The Montana sunset lay between two mountains like a gigantic bruise from which dark arteries spread themselves over a poisoned sky."

beautiful. just beautiful. reading Fitzgerald for me is like listening to a concert pianist play Chopin. i'd give anything to write like that.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I love the way Fitzgerald both develops and explores human connections and relationships. I appreciate that his best work seems to driven more by character development than by plot development. While he can sometimes be pretentious and while some language and societal aspects are antiquated, it is his philiosophy on life and how he interprets the opposite sex that are most fascinating.

Most of his female characters within the short stories are decidedly selfish and unlikeable. However, his talent is so great that the reader is still compelled to care for these women and have an honest desire to follow their stories to the conclusion.

While nothing will ever compare to The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald's other writings are just as illuminating and entertaining.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Fitzgerald is one of my favorite writers, but reading these short stories in succession felt more thematic than it should, which was disappointing for me. It's like Fitzgerald has only one perspective and can't think past it. Alas.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Variations on a theme. I need to stop reading Fitzgerald. Thoroughly depressing.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Best spent 14 dollars in 2020. Okay, one of the best spent 14 dollars in general.

The thing with Fitzgerald is that his writing takes me to another world, the aesthetic of his writing is something I admire a lot; all the work he puts into the form, polishing it until we get perfection. He is one of those writers that use a careful selection of words that in a small amount of space(pages) tells a lot and lingers in your mind.

➔Some themes, motifs, and characters you will find in these stories:

The Flapper✔

Conflicting feelings about religion(Catholicism)✔

Tragic love✔

Irony✔

Hope and longing for what is gone✔

South vs North ✔

n  Benedictionn

n  “Well, he and I were talking about sweetness a few weeks ago. Oh, I don’t know — I said that a man named Howard — that a man I knew was sweet, and he didn’t agree with me, and we began talking about what sweetness in a man was: He kept telling me I meant a sort of soppy softness, but I knew I didn’t — yet I didn’t know exactly how to put it. I see now. I meant just the opposite. I suppose real sweetness is a sort of hardness — and strength.”n


*******

n  
“I used to build dreams about you. A man has to have something living to cling to.”
n


One of the stories I liked the least in this collection. It’s a story about a 19-year-old Lois, visiting her brother who she hasn’t seen for 17 years, ever since he has gone training to be a priest. They discuss religion and what it takes to be a good priest, and how people aren’t religious anymore. The story left me neutral after reading, since it leaves a lot of the things unsaid.

2,5/5

n  Head and Shouldersn

n  
"But life hadn’t come that way. Life took hold of people and forced them into flying rings. He laughed to think of that rap at his door, the diaphanous shadow in Hume, Marcia’s threatened kiss.

“And it’s still me,” he said aloud in wonder as he lay awake in the darkness. “I’m the man who sat in Berkeley with temerity to wonder if that rap would have had actual existence had my ear not been there to hear it. I’m still that man. I could be electrocuted for the crimes he committed.
“Poor gauzy souls trying to express ourselves in something tangible. Marcia with her written book; I with my unwritten ones. Trying to choose our mediums and then taking what we get — and being glad.”
n


The delicious irony in this one. I loved it. Definitely a story that stays with the reader, it gets even more tragi-comic when you tie the characters to Fitzgerald and Zelda.

Clearly a 5/5 for me.

n  The Ice palacen

n  
" You’ve a place in my heart no one else ever could have, but tied down here I’d get restless. I’d feel I was — wastin’ myself. There’s two sides to me, you see. There’s the sleepy old side you love an’ there’s a sort of energy — the feeling that makes me do wild things. That’s the part of me that may be useful somewhere, that’ll last when I’m not beautiful any more.”
n


Now this one. It resonated with my southern soul a lot. The difference between North and South is striking in any country it seems; This story also tied it down to the Flapper Sally Carrol Happer, which is one of his iconic flappers.

5/5 for relatability and South/North Polarisation.

n  Bernice bobs her hairn

n  “People over forty can seldom be permanently convinced of anything. At eighteen our convictions are hills from which we look; at forty-five they are caves in which we hide.”n


Social competition + pettiness = a fun story with a snappy ending and a message about how hypocritical society can be.

4,5/5.

n   The Offshore piraten

n  
“Courage—just that; courage as a rule of life, and something to cling to always. I began to build up this enormous faith in myself. I began to see that in all my idols in the past some manifestation of courage had unconsciously been the thing that attracted me. I began separating courage from the other things of life. All sorts of courage—the beaten, bloody prize-fighter coming up for more—I used to make men take me to prize-fights; the déclassé woman sailing through a nest of cats and looking at them as if they were mud under her feet; the liking what you like always; the utter disregard for other people's opinions—just to live as I liked always and to die in my own way…”
n


One of those stories that has elements that generally work together – a flapper sassy main female character, a kidnapping, a love story, and a twist at the end. Although not my favorite from the collection, the story is charming.

3/5.

n  May Dayn

n  
“Just that. I was always queer — little bit different from other boys. All right in college, but now it’s all wrong. Things have been snapping inside me for four months like little hooks on a dress, and it’s about to come off when a few more hooks go. I’m very gradually going loony.”
n
t

The lengthiest in the collection, this story used May day riots as a historical context and well.. I am not well educated in that part of American history, so it was tough for me to get through, will return to this one in the future for a reread when I have more info on the topic.

n  The Jelly Beann

This story left me indifferent, overall wasn’t a bad story but compared to the other stories from this collection it falls into the background.
2/5.

n  The Diamond as big as the Ritzn

n  
“Under the stars,” she repeated. “I never noticed the stars before. I always thought of them as great big diamonds that belonged to some one. Now they frighten me. They make me feel that it was all a dream, all my youth.”

“It was a dream,” said John quietly. “Everybody’s youth is a dream, a form of chemical madness.”
“How pleasant then to be insane!”
n


I loved everything about this. The fantastical elements were incorporated in such a good way into the story. I want to read Benjamin Button now, because damn.
4,5/5

n  Winter dreamsn

n  
"The dream was gone. Something had been taken from him. In a sort of panic he pushed the palms of his hands into his eyes and tried to bring up a picture of the waters lapping on SherryIsland and the moonlit veranda, and gingham on the golf-links and the dry sun and the gold color of her neck’s soft down. And her mouth damp to his kisses and her eyes plaintive with melancholy and her freshness like new fine linen in the morning. Why, these things were no longer in the world! They had existed and they existed no longer.

For the first time in years the tears were streaming down his face. But they were for himself now. He did not care about mouth and eyes and moving hands. He wanted to care, and he could not care. For he had gone away and he could never go back any more. The gates were closed, the sun was gone down, and there was no beauty but the gray beauty of steel that withstands all time. Even the grief he could have borne was left behind in the country of illusion, of youth, of the richness of life, where his winter dreams had flourished.

“Long ago,” he said, “long ago, there was something in me, but now that thing is gone. Now that thing is gone, that thing is gone. I cannot cry. I cannot care. That thing will come back no more.”
n


A mixture of Gatsby-esque main character and love story with elements of Fitzgerald’s own life and with his reoccurring theme of longing for what is gone – what’s there not to love?
5/5

n  Absolutionn

Another story that centers around religion, reminds me a lot of The sisters by James Joyce. However, I don’t connect with those types of stories a lot, so they leave me cold
3/5.

Overall, I am not disappointed by this collection, would recommend it to any Fitzgerald lover, off to find Tales of the Jazz Age, because apparently, this man can’t do bad.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fitzgerald has never let me down. Review to come.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I will quote James Gould Cozzens here on F. Scott Fitzgerald gift for writing:
" a talent for saying not merely the right, the apt, the vivid, or moving thing, but the thing which, having all those qualities, so far transcends your reasonable expectation that you see that it couldn't have been done merely by intelligence, or training, or hard trying, and must simply have been born in a sort of triumphant flash outside the ordinary process of thought".
April 17,2025
... Show More
Some really great stories here - The Diamond as Big as the Ritz, The Ice House, some not so great but overall a very enjoyable read
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.