...
Show More
Critics of this book complain he doesn't tell the whole story, yeah, well, that's exactly his point. You're supposed to already know the standard public school text book version of history and he is writing to supplement that understanding with points of view you might not have been exposed to.
The most interesting parts for me were regarding the lead-up to the "War of Northern Aggression" and the Reconstruction period. I've never before heard a compelling argument that had the North let the South secede slavery would still likely have ended in the south within a few years. No massive war and 600k casualties required. The book also throws the reconstruction era "radical Republicans" in a very negative light that I've never heard about before except in "Gone with the Wind."
I admire his focus on logical interpretations of the U.S. Constitution as it is actually written, and not the made-up version as misunderstood by modern courts and liberals.
IMO it would have been better to end the book a few decades earlier and avoid the recent-history political commentary regarding Clinton and recent history that is still somewhat unsettled in the official narrative.
The most interesting parts for me were regarding the lead-up to the "War of Northern Aggression" and the Reconstruction period. I've never before heard a compelling argument that had the North let the South secede slavery would still likely have ended in the south within a few years. No massive war and 600k casualties required. The book also throws the reconstruction era "radical Republicans" in a very negative light that I've never heard about before except in "Gone with the Wind."
I admire his focus on logical interpretations of the U.S. Constitution as it is actually written, and not the made-up version as misunderstood by modern courts and liberals.
IMO it would have been better to end the book a few decades earlier and avoid the recent-history political commentary regarding Clinton and recent history that is still somewhat unsettled in the official narrative.