Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
29(29%)
4 stars
32(32%)
3 stars
39(39%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
I loved it! And I am definitely biased towards books about India and Indians. I loved it because the author loved India, indians and Indian-ness..

The author spends a good two years in India and falls in love - definitely not at first sight. It was a lot about her spiritual journey and how India welcomes all - from all faith and all religions and from all corners of the world... India embraces them and makes them her own. Hilarious at times - because the situations are so relatable.

The author had experiences to share from different faiths she encountered and her key takeaways. It felt good to know how someone feels about India, provided they come here with an open mind and an open heart.
April 17,2025
... Show More
While the author has some writing chops, she also has a big chip on her shoulder. Her ethnocentrism so colors her writing that this is not a very enjoyable read. Unvarnished and factual writing, but with such a sense of superiority of her culture. Only got through half; too many better-written books I can spend my time upon.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Holy Cow: An Indian Adventure by Sarah Macdonald
3.5 stars

'In India I’ve travelled a soul’s journey: from hedonism to sickness, from silence to song, from violence to peace and from learning to die to celebrating life.'

The above passage beautifully encapsulates this entertaining and thought-provoking travel memoir. I decided to read Holy Cow so I could kill two birds with one stone: to gain more knowledge about India before my upcoming trip, and to kick off the Australian Women Writers’ Challenge for 2013.

Holy Cow is Sarah Macdonald’s account of the two years she spent in India whilst her partner – a foreign correspondent – was based in Delhi. She wasn’t in the country long when a serious illness and identity crisis inspired her to learn more about Indian spirituality and culture, and to ultimately learn more about herself.

With a spirit of curiosity and adventure, the author (a journalist and radio commentator) embarked on a quest that took her all over the country. She enjoyed an audience with the Dalai Lama, bathed in the Ganges at the Hindu Kumbh Mela festival, celebrated Passover with a group of Israelis, visited a Parsi temple, joined a Catholic pilgrimage to Our Lady of Velangani, and found out more about the Islam and Sikh traditions. My favourite chapters were the ones in which she described her challenging ten-day Vipassana meditation retreat in the Himalayas, and her visit to the Kerala ashram of the ‘Hugging Saint’, Mata Amritanandamayi.

This could be an age thing, because I found Macdonald’s tone a bit too hip and flippant on occasion. But her powers of description are astounding. She captures the sights, sounds and scents of India with such vivid detail (almost too vivid at times), I felt like I was right there. Some reviewers have accused her of exaggeration – I guess I’ll find out when I get to India myself. But when I finished the book I came away feeling a lot of admiration for her resilience and humour, which stood her in good stead during her more difficult moments.

I highly recommend Holy Cow for people who enjoy memoirs that take them to exotic locations.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Macdonald writes beautifully. She has an amazing eye for details, which, when writing about a place as visually compelling as India, adds so much to the book. But she spends a lot of time visiting one religious site after another and interpreting the religions for us and it's a little like your son's sixth grade report on Hinduism. I would have loved her write more about Indian culture.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I just finished reading this... I mean not reading this ;) for my book club. I just couldn't get through it, come to think of it I don't think anyone in my book club said they finished it.

I was interested in the book during the first chapter when she was telling her feelings and experiences of being in India but soon the author went into a political and religious tirade and spent way too much time internalizing what it all meant. One chapter started to blend into another for me and I ended up feeling that I couldn't care less about what happened to her.

With a baby due in less than two months my reading time is seeming more and more precious on a daily basis. I just don't have time to waste it on reading a book I could care less about.

I would not recommend this book.
April 17,2025
... Show More
"India is Hotel California: you can check out anytime you like, but you can never leave..."

I came across Holy Cow! by chance, and saw that it managed to trigger the fragile sensibilities of many of the top reviewers here. So naturally, I had to read it to see what all the fuss was about.
I enjoyed the writing here for the most part, and found the outrage the book generated to be ridiculous. More below.

Author Sarah Macdonald is an Australian journalist, writer, radio presenter, and has been associated with several ABC radio programs, including Triple J and Radio National.

Sarah Macdonald:
n  n

As the book's title implies, it is a travelogue that covers the author's time living in and traveling around India. Macdonald writes with a decent, fairly engaging style, and this one shouldn't have trouble holding even the finicky reader's attention.

She drops this quote early on:
n  
"It’s now that I remember that India is like Wonderland. In this other universe everyone seems mad and everything is upside down, back to front and infuriatingly bizarre. I’m Alice: fuzzy with feelings about my previous trip down the rabbit hole, I’m now flying straight back through the looking glass to a place where women are blamed for sleazy men and planes are sprayed when they fly from a clean city to a dirty one. In this world we applaud a dreadful landing that’s as fast and steep as a take-off, we jump up and tackle fellow passengers in a scrum at the door while the plane is still moving, and the air hostess gets off first."
n

When I came across this book, I gave a cursory read of many of the top reviews here. Quite a lot of people were triggered by the subject matter here. It seems they were set off by the talk about Indians freely and openly defecating in the streets, clearing their throats and spitting, and the mass epidemic of sexual groping by Indian men.

I was left a bit puzzled by this. So people are upset that the author talks about what she experienced when she was in India? Many people decried her as a "racist." It's interesting that their outrage did not extend to the people committing these offenses, but rather, towards the person recounting her story of experiencing this detestable behaviour. Cultural relativism 101.

Although I have not personally been to India, I am very close with several people that have either grown up and lived there, or have spent long periods of time there. When I recounted some of the author's experiences to them, they said that they also experienced these types of things, and more.

The author summarizes some of her frustration with the country in this quote:
n  
"...I begin to regurgitate my repressed memories of why I never wanted to come here again. It’s a vomit of hatred and a rambling rage against the bullshit, the pushing, the shoving, the rip-offs, the cruelty, the crowds, the pollution, the weather, the begging, the performance of pity, the pissing, the shitting, the snotting, the spitting and the farting..."
n

Before the naive reader gets their knickers in a twist, I'd like to drop a few unsettling quotes from the book, highlighting some of the more brutal aspects of Indian society/culture. I challenge anyone to read these, and not be horrified.
In this short quote, she tells the reader about the Indian practice of "dowry burning":
n  
"...in her place is a woman begging.
She hasn’t got a face.
Above her neck is a mass of melted flesh like burnt candle wax. Two pools of black stare out and stumps of burnt flesh wrapped in rags plead up at me. I retch in horror and run. This is my first glimpse of a dowry burning – where a woman is set alight in a ‘cooking accident’ because her husband or mother-in-law want more dowry money and attempt to kill to get it. If the bride dies, the husband can marry again and collect another dowry; if she lives, she can be shamed into leaving the house as damaged, useless goods. I want to scream with shock, fury and sadness but there’re too many people staring at me, following me and grabbing me. There’s just no room for rage."
n

One of the closest people in my life is Indian-born and raised - having moved to the West when they were 8 years old. They told me that India is "a place where life has no value." From what is presented in this book, as well as what I've heard first-hand, it seems that this is tragically often the case:
n  
"...Amid the manicured lawns of the embassy district cars slow down to avoid what appears to be a branch on the road. But it’s not a branch. It’s the twisted limbs of a beggar who’s been hit by a car; he is lying in the middle of the road crying and reaching out his hands for help. We pull over and Jonathan jumps out. But as he approaches the stricken man, a bus lurches to a halt; its driver gets out, grabs the beggar by his arm, drags him to the gutter and dumps him, his face and abdomen bleeding from the bitumen.
He’s dragged in anger, not in sympathy; human debris removed. The driver, his route now clear, jumps back on his bus and drives away.
India is the worst of humanity..."
n

Some of the other material covered here includes:
• The author at a meditation retreat
• Travels to Kashmir
• Sees the Dali Lama
• Zoroastrians; the Parsis
• Religions in India; Hinduism, Islam

******************

Holy Cow! was an interesting travelogue. I would recommend it to anyone interested.
3 stars.
April 17,2025
... Show More
Sort of a half and half travelogue and diary of spiritual quest. An Australian woman follows her heart to India, a place she had previously visited and not enjoyed. Her travel descriptions are vivid. Her spiritual quest seems shallow, with no real introspection into her life, more about what different belief systems could do for her. She lives through a lot in her 2 years there and her sharing is an interesting read.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I didn't enjoy this book at all. It might have enjoyed it if I could have concentrated on it but the style didn't grab me at all. She's experienced so many different religions, people and places that they've just merged into one indistinguishable experience. I'm only reading it to the end out of sheer bloody-minded determination.
April 17,2025
... Show More
What a great Indian adventure! Awesome ranting and very accurately told. The descriptive adjectives that the writer used to describe her experience at times made me lol - I envisioned her many dilemmas while traveling trough India. Awesome experience very well told!!
April 17,2025
... Show More
Very sad! Totally puts a wrong picture about India. She only criticizes the place on every page. Couldn't read past a few pages. I picked it up coz it said hilarious account of her stay in India. I dint find a single funny word. Atrocious.
Personally I do not approve of using a Hindu gods photo the way it has been.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I wish I could give this book zero stars. What a condescending, racist piece of garbage. Why write about going to India if you didn't even like it? I saw this book sold in stores everywhere in India and I wish they would take it off the shelves. Sarah MacDonald is a peddler of lies about this truly phenomenal country. Please don't read it.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.