Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
33(33%)
4 stars
37(37%)
3 stars
29(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
April 17,2025
... Show More
" - Ditosa idade e século ditoso aquele em que venham à luz as famosas façanhas minhas, dignas de serem inscritas em folhas de bronze, esculpidas em mármore e pintadas em tábuas, para memória no futuro."

Vencida a barreira da linguagem desusada e do tamanho pouco prático do tijolo, há ainda que lutar contra a lonjura do final sem perder a paciência. Das incontáveis aventuras vividas por Dom Quixote e Sancho Pança, já muitas me desapareceram da memória. O que fica é uma mensagem mais poderosa que é similar em todas elas e se prende com questões do quotidiano que perpassaram através do tempo, permanecendo actuais e comuns a toda a humanidade. É o que faz deste livro uma obra inesquecível e atemporal.
Às vezes é chato, outras cansativo, mas é (quase) sempre divertido, e fica connosco para lá do término da leitura.
April 17,2025
... Show More
I guess the goal of reviewing something like Don Quixote is to make you less frightened of it. It's intimidating, right? It's 940 pages long and it's from 500 years ago. But Grossman's translation is modern and easy to read, and the work itself is so much fun that it ends up not being difficult at all.

Much of Book I is concerned with the story of Cardenio, which Shakespeare apparently liked so much that he wrote a now-lost play about the guy. I loved that part, but for me, the pace slowed down a bit in the latter third of Book I. There are two more "novellas" inserted that have little or nothing to do with the plot; feel free to skip them. (They're discussed in the comments section below this review, if you're interested.)

Book II was published ten years after Book I, in 1615, and with it Cervantes pulls a typically Cervantes-esque trick: he imagines that Don Quixote is now a celebrity due to Book I's success. This changes the perspective considerably; whereas folks used to be mystified by Don Quixote, now they often recognize him, which generally results in them fucking with him. It invigorates the story; since Book II feels so different, I didn't get the feeling I often get with wicked long books where I kinda get bogged down around the 2/3 mark. In fact, I ended up liking Book II even better than Book I.

Quixote messes with your head. Cervantes pulls so many tricks out of his bag that you're never sure what's coming next. For a while I suspected that the footnotes had been written by Cervantes as well, and were all made up. I had to Wikipedia Martin de Riquer to make sure he was a real guy. That's how sneaky Cervantes is: he makes you think anything is possible.

I thought Don Quixote was tremendous. It's like nothing else in the world. I'm glad I read it. And I'll end with what might be the best quote of all time, and a brilliant thing to say to your wife:

"I want you to see me naked and performing one or two dozen mad acts, which will take me less than half an hour, because if you have seen them with your own eyes, you can safely swear to any others you might wish to add."

Right? Don Quixote kicks ass.

By the way, for another take on the story, here's Kafka:
Without making any boast of it Sancho Panza succeeded in the course of years, by devouring a great number of romances of chivalry and adventure in the evening and night hours, in so diverting from him his demon, whom he later called Don Quixote, that his demon thereupon set out in perfect freedom on the maddest exploits, which, however, for the lack of a preordained object, which should have been Sancho Panza himself, harmed nobody. A free man, Sancho Panza philosophically followed Don Quixote on his crusades, perhaps out of a sense of responsibility, and had of them a great and edifying entertainment to the end of his days.
(This is the entire text of his parable "The Truth about Sancho Panza"; it and others can be found here.)
April 17,2025
... Show More
علي الرغم إنها نسخة مختصرة ولكني أكتفي بما قرأت..
not my cup of tea..!
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.