Very disappointing. I was expecting a history of the Zapatista movement through the eyes of El Sup. Instead, I read disjointed and scattered essays, polemics, and letters by the leader. A few were interesting, but I feel that most simply repeated the same points over and over. I need to find another book that details the history of the revolution and the movement.

Pek çok edebi eserden daha iyidir.

A comprehensive (and weighty) anthology of the writings of Subcommandante Marcos, spokesman for the Zapatistas. By far the most entertaining of his writings our the stories and conversations he has about neoliberalism with the beetle known as Durito, who often claims to be a Quixtodian knight.

....the future lies in cooperative development...based on cooperative principles....hope the g20 (mexico is a member)...realise this at their upcoming pow wow..

Subcomandante Insurgente Marcos (or Galeano, as he is known now) always seems to have a surprise up his sleeve when it comes to writing about the Zapatista movement of the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN). I read his other selected writings in Our Word Is Our Weapon and loved them, and when I discovered this compilation in my local library I knew I couldn't pass it up. Parts of it were interesting and parts of it were drivel, if I'm being completely honest. It was broad, sweeping coverage of the beliefs and stories behind the EZLN, but as with OWIOW, I felt it was too heavily consisting of stories and legends rather than histories and philosophies of the movement.

The more I read and learn about the Zapatistas the more interested in them I become, and I hoped to learn more about the history of the uprising and its planning and where it will go from here. There was a great deal more information about that in this book than there was in any previous writings of Marcos that I've read, but not nearly enough. I want an account of January 1, 1994. I want to know about the preparation of that fateful day; I want to know more about the uprising operations; I want to know more about the immediate aftermath and the people's viewpoints and opinions following that day. Ya Basta! did contain more information on that subject than any other book I've read on it, but it still wasn't close to enough.

Marcos is infinitely quotable, that's for sure, and there are plenty of inspiring things in the book to make you think about political movements and especially those that ignite rebellion nation-wide as the Zapatistas have done in Mexico. By far my favorite part of the book was the very end, all of the declarations from the Lacandon Jungle that the EZLN issued over the course of their uprising. There it was so interesting to read the motivations for their military action and planned resistance in the future. Reading about the EZLN always makes me angry about the conditions they have been given by the Mexican government, but it also fills me with hope and inspiration knowing that there can be a future to push for, a world in which all worlds can fit.

This wasn't the book I was looking for on the Zapatistas. The intros are great and informative, especially by the editor Vovodnik. It's also nice that it has all the Declarations from the Lacandon Jungle at the end. But the 600 pages in the middle, Marcos' writings, are not spectacular. There's a lot of literary stuff involving beetles, the moon, and ancient gods. The critiques of neoliberalism and the Mexican government are good, and sprinkled all over, but this book is not a historical or factual documentation of the Zapatista Uprising.

Para todos todo

This book was marketed in an interesting way. This is far less about the Zapatista movement as it is a comprehensive history of the writings, thoughts, and overall cultural beliefs held by subcommandante Marcos; poems, essays, etc... A good coffee table book for the radical in your family.