Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 109 votes)
5 stars
30(28%)
4 stars
33(30%)
3 stars
46(42%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
109 reviews
March 26,2025
... Show More
The view of the desert soothed him.

Quite a heady experience, and not one to be entered lightly.

Don’t even consider reading this if you haven’t read the novels preceding it. However, if you are invested in the Dune Universe and you have read the original Dune Trilogy (Dune / Dune Messiah / Children of Dune) this can be a very rewarding, albeit challenging, read.

Presented as part future historical text, part memoir and part mythos, God Emperor of Dune is somewhat unlike any of the Dune novels that came before. Taking place more than 3000 years after the events of Children of Dune , but still revolving around Leto II (yes, he is that old by now), this book continues the Dune / Herbert tradition of subverting events that came before. And then some.

While some of what transpires here was hinted at in the previous novel, it is still a somewhat uneasy turn of events. The book doesn’t make it entirely clear who you should be rooting for, either. It’s all grey area, and it takes a long time for character motives to become clearer. Half the people in the story don’t seem to know what the hell is going on either, which does make for a truly remarkable reading experience (intended or otherwise).

There are fewer characters this time round, with just about everything revolving around the God Emperor and his actions. The only additional characters are the (befuddled) few with whom the emperor has surrounded himself.

The narrative is interspersed with quotes from the history of the Dune universe, as well as diary entries, notably those of the God Emperor himself. As such, the flow of the novel takes some getting used to. It is heavy on philosophical meandering and, to a lesser extent, political maneuvering. The story takes the long view, and concerns itself with the future of the human race on an intergalactic scale as dictated by the “Golden Path” that Leto is following via his (by now very formidable) prescience. As such, there is very little in the sense of immediate gratification. In fact, compared to this, the original Dune is a pretty straightforward adventure yarn. This, by the way, is not a criticism; I love the original Dune.

I suppose it would be easy to dislike this book, based on how strange it truly is. And you wouldn’t know how strange unless you read it. It is perhaps worth noting that Herbert had some aid in the form of magic mushrooms when writing some of his Dune stories (by his own admission). Perhaps God Emperor of Dune is case in point. All in all, a mind-bending affair.

…they saw only the great emptiness, an eerie place especially in moonlight – dunes at a distance, a distance which seemed not to change as the traveller moved – nothing anywhere except the seemingly eternal wind, a few rocks and, when they looked upward, stars without mercy.
This was the desert of the desert.


In the end, though, it is telling that I wasn’t indifferent to the fates of the main character(s). There are some memorable scenes (and one fairly moving one) toward the close of the novel that puts everything in perspective. The story had, after all, managed to get under my skin, and in the end, everything makes a tragic sort of sense. Such is the nature of the Dune novels.

The truth is, they don’t make them like this anymore, and any return to Dune is likely going to be a rewarding experience.

The Worm comes!
March 26,2025
... Show More
In many ways - this is better science fiction than the original trilogy, because it attempts to be truly experimental. The alien nature of Leto II, Paul Muad Dib's son who fuses with the Sandworms is fertile ground for discovery. Unfortunately, much of the action is repetitive conversations between the same small cast of characters over a 500ish page novel. Herbert's strengths in Dune came from a web of possible desires driving a diverse set of characters. God Emperor of Dune smothers itself in reflection on the nature of a change that is never truly described. Rather, Herbert follows the lovecraft trope of the unthinkable being...unthinkable - allowing Leto II to be heroic because of a Golden Path that likely was more of a drawing board idea than fully fleshed out plot.

Some of the later Dune books have great snippets of imagination about telepathy and deep memory. There are interesting concepts of deep time, and mythbuilding that are still here - but they are affected by a 3000 year old protagonist who is bored of the very ideas that are most interesting.

Duncan Idaho is a poor audience surrogate - he's unlikeable, and through most of the first book the most forgettable of the retinue, overall mixed experience.
April 20,2025
... Show More
Uno de los mejores libros de la saga. Te enganchará desde sus primeras páginas, no puede faltar en tu colección.
April 20,2025
... Show More
Un clásico de la literatura que no puede faltar. La edición es muy buena
April 20,2025
... Show More
Recibi el producto sin ningun incoveniente, pero tiene muchisimos errores de ortografia y traduccion.
April 20,2025
... Show More
Creo que la historia se torna muy lenta e inverosímil.  La narrativa ya no es como en los primeros libros y me perdí un pofo. No lo disfrute tanto la verdad
April 20,2025
... Show More
Análisis complejo de la estructuras del imperio de Leto II miles de años después de Hijos de Dune. Y la historia sigue cautivando.
April 20,2025
... Show More
No me gusta el traductor pero si la obra pues el traductor no conoce la gramática española, sólo la muuyy vulgar
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.