...
Show More
When I discovered that climber and filmmaker David Breashears had written a memoir, I leapt on it immediately. I love reading books about the outdoors, hiking, and climbing, and I knew he was the creator of the IMAX Everest film and also that he and his crew acted heroically to save lives during the tragedy of 1996. After reading Into Thin Air and Ed Viesturs’ No Shortcuts this was a natural book for me to follow up on.
David Breashears’ perspective is unique because not only is he deeply introspective and analytical about the philosophy of climbing, but he is an experienced outdoor filmmaker. The man has climbed Everest while lugging several pounds of film and camera equipment, and somehow this film survived not only extreme temperatures, but countless yak rides and trips through airline conveyor belts. His stories are incredible.
His view of how things went during 1996 was in contrast to Krakauer’s and the differences were stark. Breashears portrays Fisher and Hall as somewhat arrogant and shortsighted, where Krakauer seemed to lay the blame squarely with Pittman and Boukreev. Breashears portrays Pittman as an experienced mountaineer who knew what she was doing, but Krakauer claimed she was practically carried up and down the mountain. It is amazing how different perspectives can be during such a traumatizing event. Krakauer wrote the foreword and despite their differing accounts of some of the details, both climbers and authors hold one-another in high esteem.
Overall Breashears treats all of his subject matter with utter honesty, acknowledges his own shortcomings, and has a great respect for both mountains and the people who climb them.
David Breashears’ perspective is unique because not only is he deeply introspective and analytical about the philosophy of climbing, but he is an experienced outdoor filmmaker. The man has climbed Everest while lugging several pounds of film and camera equipment, and somehow this film survived not only extreme temperatures, but countless yak rides and trips through airline conveyor belts. His stories are incredible.
His view of how things went during 1996 was in contrast to Krakauer’s and the differences were stark. Breashears portrays Fisher and Hall as somewhat arrogant and shortsighted, where Krakauer seemed to lay the blame squarely with Pittman and Boukreev. Breashears portrays Pittman as an experienced mountaineer who knew what she was doing, but Krakauer claimed she was practically carried up and down the mountain. It is amazing how different perspectives can be during such a traumatizing event. Krakauer wrote the foreword and despite their differing accounts of some of the details, both climbers and authors hold one-another in high esteem.
Overall Breashears treats all of his subject matter with utter honesty, acknowledges his own shortcomings, and has a great respect for both mountains and the people who climb them.