I am rating book 3 highly for several reasons. Its plot is engaging and the pacing is nice, it has a great sense of drama, and it shows consistency and dogged imagination. Heaven only knows how many authors have attempted to write such a hefty novel and yet withered away and fell by the wayside, guilty of overambition. George R.R. Martin must have been supremely confident. He must have known about the most important details of his book before even starting to write them. But enough of the praise.
As it took me quite some time to read book 3, the initial part of the book has escaped my memory. My memory is not eidetic, after all. From what I can remember, I can barely state what the prologue was about. It couldn't be about Davos again. That's the problem. I don't remember, and the words have vanished from my mind. Maybe this is the reader's fault and not the book's, but what if this is true for many average readers? Does that validate my shortcomings? Enough of the questions.
I think a lot of stuff is beginning to be repeated in the plotting of A Storm of Swords. Although this medieval world must be going through a sort of Golden Age when it comes to the many ways of killing a person, there are not as many ways as in our real world. There are no bullets, no electrocution, no death by tampering with brakes. SPOILERS AHEAD... Joffrey was poisoned in the same way as Maester Cressen. Lysa was pushed from a height, and Robb died in base treachery, similar to his father (though that's a bit of a stretch). Apart from the deaths, there's the arc of Tyrion, imprisoned and championed by a knight. There's also fake Renly and fake Arya. Enough nitpicking. In fact, enough reviewing! I'll begin reading book 4 tomorrow. I just can't wait.