El miedo y la aceptación de la propia ignorancia eran la mejor medicina contra el estúpido orgullo.\\n \\n
THE BEST:\\n
THE GOOD:\\n
THE BAD:\\n
THE WORST:\\n
I really wish I had liked Sabriel more than I actually did. It had a decent idea, but as I kept reading, my mind continuously drifted off. I found myself thinking about events in my life or my plans for the next day because I was simply so bored. Merely saying a book is boring isn't a convincing or valid reason to conclude that it wasn't good. However, in this case, I struggled to stay engaged.
Have you ever read a book where endless things happen one after another, but you feel as if barely anything is occurring because the action is always so similar to the previous events and feels overused? That's exactly how I felt about Sabriel. The plot followed a rather repetitive pattern:
“Let this be my final lesson. Everyone and everything has a time to die.”\\n
Something bad happens
Sabriel defeats it
Something bad happens
Sabriel escapes
Something bad happens
Sabriel escapes
Something bad happens
Sabriel defeats it
Anyway, I thought the concept for the story was intriguing at first. The story is set in two fictional countries. To the south lies Ancelstierre, where technology and society are comparable to 20th-century England, and to the north lies the Old Kingdom, where magic and spirits wander the land.
In the Old Kingdom, there is always a sorcerer with the title Abhorsen who puts the dead (spirits) to rest. The dead are raised by Necromancers or black magicians who roam the Old Kingdom. Essentially, an Abhorsen is a Necromancer themselves, but they do the opposite. Sabriel is an Abhorsen who lives in Ancelstierre, while her father lives in the Old Kingdom. She sets out on a journey to the Old Kingdom after her father’s sudden disappearance.
However, quarter way through the book: Sabriel was a likable enough female character, so I have to give the male author some applause for writing a mildly believable female character. However, I felt no strong connection with Sabriel since her emotions were rarely expressed. Instead, there was a massive amount of description about many other things that caused me to yawn endlessly. Her love interest is—well, not interesting. He was flat and dull.
I feel as if I’m betraying the fantasy genre by not liking this as much as I probably should. I feel an obligation to like fantasy books that have original concepts, considering fantasy is one of my favorite genres. Oh well, I still praise the idea of the story very much, and I think that alone earns 3 stars, but I didn't find it to be an entertaining or engaging read for it to earn any more than that.
Reread on 6/18/24: Still as enjoyable as ever. I am reminded how terrible Tim Curry is at voices for young girls though his narration is otherwise fantastic.
Reread on 1/29/19. Well, relisten. I needed an audio book with a narrator I love to reset after a bad narrator from my previous audio book! Sabriel is narrated by Tim Curry and he is phenomenal. This listen really hit the spot, great story and great narration :). I wasn't originally intending to reread the whole trilogy but I think I will. Review from 2016 below.
----------------------------
Sabriel by Garth Nix is the first book in The Abhorson trilogy. The story opens fairly ominously with the death of a woman and child. The series of events that unfolds in the prologue grabs the attention and sets the stage nicely. We are introduced to two of the world's types of magic, given a little foreshadowing for what's to come and a slightly eerie tone is set. Once the story starts, we're gradually introduced to the world. Ancelstierre has a feeling of 1940's England while the Old Kingdom feels distinctly like medieval Europe where Free Magics and creatures that go bump in the night now reign. The two kingdoms are separated by a wall and crossing the border is like taking a portal to another world where even the weather is different. And, quite naturally, that wall is failing.
The characters we get to know are also excellent. Sabriel is a great fantasy heroine. She's a smart, clear headed, strong and a well balanced character. She looks at problems logically to make informed decisions and isn't afraid to take action. Touchstone starts off fairly annoying. It's obvious that he's more than just a guardsman and his servile attitude at first is grating. I'm glad the character out grows this habit as the story progresses. Nix had a lot of fun with Mogget. Mogget is the perfect magical entity in the form of a feline that both says and does things I can imagine a cat would.
The story is well paced. The action and suspense is superb. The final climax had me sitting on the edge of my seat the entire time. I love the eerie/creepy undertone that is carried throughout the book. It's exactly what you'd expect when dealing with the dead that don't want to stay dead. Nix has a refreshing take on necromantic magic that was quite fun to read. There is even an understated romance plot that is quite sweet and not at all like today's YA stories of instant love.
I listened to the audio book of this narrated by Tim Curry. I think I could listen to Tim Curry read from the dictionary! He is especially fun at narrating villains and magical creatures. That said, his depiction of a young girl's voice at the beginning of the story is so bad I laughed out loud. Overall, the audio book experience was enhanced by Curry's wonderful narration, despite that one small flaw.