...
Show More
I began this book with great excitement. Her early years were truly captivating, and the author's writing style was quite engaging. I was thoroughly enjoying it until Spoto started delving into the movies she was in. That's when he really started to irk me. For the most part, Spoto's writing is well-executed. However, he seems to muddle the line between being a biographer and a film critic. A biographer should focus on the facts. They should tell us which films she was in, what occurred during filming, what the public's reaction was to the film, and other such concrete details. A film critic can offer their opinion of the films, but since they present themselves as critics, we understand that it's just their perspective. So, for instance, when Spoto started talking about "Sabrina" and how challenging Humphrey Bogart was to work with, that was acceptable. But when he stated as a fact that Bogart was "miscast," that didn't sit well with me. He provided no quotes from critics who shared that view, nor anything from those involved in the production who thought he wasn't suitable for the role. It was just his opinion that Bogart was "miscast" (yes, they had initially wanted Cary Grant, but that doesn't mean Bogart didn't perform well in the film). And yes, I disagree with his assessment that Bogart was miscast, but the point is that it's not the biographer's job to also be a film critic. I was willing to overlook it the first time, but it happened again with several other films. According to Spoto, "The Nun's Story," which I haven't seen but plan to, is nearly one of the best movies ever. "Green Mansions," which I actually liked, is terrible (yet there are no quotes from critics to back this up). Marni Nixon as the singing voice in "My Fair Lady" was a complete disaster, and the audience immediately felt a disconnect between the singing and Audrey every time a song started (while the studio's handling of the dubbing situation was indeed糟糕, the movie itself is not). By the time he got to "My Fair Lady," I was quite annoyed with Spoto. Nevertheless, I finished the book because I wanted to learn about her work with UNICEF. That part was interesting. So, I enjoyed the beginning and the end, as well as some interesting tidbits in the middle. I wish I had chosen a different biography, but at least this one was a bargain.