Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 97 votes)
5 stars
40(41%)
4 stars
25(26%)
3 stars
32(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
97 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
The social contract is a much more pleasurable read than the discourses.

It presents a unique perspective on the relationship between individuals and society.

The ideas put forward in the social contract are engaging and thought-provoking.

It explores how people come together to form a community and what rights and responsibilities they have.

The language used is accessible, making it easier for readers to understand the complex concepts.

In contrast, the discourses can be more difficult to follow at times.

They may require a deeper knowledge of the subject matter and more effort to fully comprehend.

Overall, the social contract offers a more enjoyable and rewarding reading experience.

It allows readers to gain a better understanding of the nature of society and their place within it.

Whether you are a student of philosophy or simply interested in learning more about the world around you, the social contract is definitely worth a read.

July 15,2025
... Show More
For me, the Social Contract presents a complex blend of 18th-century elements. It combines the writing style and vocabulary of that era, perhaps with some of Rousseau's own term definitions. The 18th-century perspective, along with a philosophical and speculative presentation in parts, and references to older historical events, make it a challenging read.

It's important to remember that this was written in pre-industrial and pre-corporate times, when there was limited testing of social, political, and economic options. What seemed reasonable 250 years ago may not be applicable today or may have been tried and failed since then. Newer ideas have emerged, and as the saying goes, "The victors write the history." In Rousseau's day, with fewer historians and archeologists, he may have been more reliant on certain assumptions.

Some parts of the Social Contract can be interpreted in different ways. For example, when Rousseau states that monarchies require the most resources and that the most productive lands are best suited for them, it's not entirely clear what he means. Was it true in his time that monarchies were rare except in very productive lands? Or did he mean that if a land was productive, monarchy would be a good choice?

Another example of the need to understand the meanings is when Rousseau talks about ancient Rome having a "dictator." As we read further, we find that this was an appointed position within certain rules for a specified period of time. In this case, he provides enough detail to avoid ambiguity, but this wasn't always the case.

Rousseau also makes some statements that raise questions. When he says that the Greeks "had no natural greed" and that their concern was with liberty, while they had slaves, it makes us wonder about his views on slavery and who he considered to be "people."

Overall, the Social Contract is a thought-provoking work that requires careful consideration and analysis. It presents both idealized and "real world" perspectives, and at times, Rousseau seems to be writing from a progressive view, such as opposing slavery, while at other times, he uses slave-based ancient Rome as an example.

When Rousseau writes about citizens voluntarily choosing to be part of a society with rights and responsibilities, there's uncertainty about what kinds of individuals he imagines can enter into this agreement. His statement about no citizen being wealthy enough to buy another and none poor enough to be forced to sell himself can be interpreted in different ways. It could mean outlawing slavery, but it could also have broader implications for social and economic equality.

Rousseau's use of the term "aristocracy" to describe different forms of rule also adds to the complexity. He seems to favor something in-between "popular government" and simple elected government, but again, the question of who can participate remains unanswered.

In conclusion, the Social Contract is a rich and challenging work that continues to be relevant today. It forces us to think about the nature of society, government, and individual rights, and it reminds us that our understanding of these concepts has evolved over time.
July 15,2025
... Show More

A milestone of social and political debate, these essays introduced the controversial concepts that brought about the French Revolution. They were a significant contribution to the intellectual landscape of the time. Rousseau's ideas challenged the existing social and political order, sparking intense discussions and ultimately leading to revolutionary change.



For students of philosophy, these essays are an essential seminal work. They offer valuable insights into Rousseau's thinking and his views on topics such as human nature, the social contract, and the role of government. However, the significance of these essays extends beyond the realm of philosophy. They also have implications for politics, sociology, and history.



Rousseau's ideas continue to be relevant today, as we grapple with issues such as inequality, democracy, and the relationship between the individual and society. His work serves as a reminder of the power of ideas to shape the course of history and the importance of engaging in critical thinking and debate.

July 15,2025
... Show More
As a savage, I firmly and completely agree with the pro-savage perspective.

Savages have their own unique way of life and values that are often overlooked or misunderstood by the civilized world. We live in harmony with nature, relying on our instincts and skills to survive. Our social structures may be different, but they are based on mutual respect and cooperation.

The civilized world, on the other hand, is often driven by greed, competition, and a desire for power. This has led to many problems such as environmental destruction, social inequality, and war.

I believe that the savage way of life has much to offer. We can teach the civilized world about simplicity, respect for nature, and the importance of community. By embracing our savage roots, we can find a more sustainable and fulfilling way of life.

In conclusion, I am proud to be a savage and I will continue to advocate for the pro-savage perspective.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It was truly a mixed bag. There were elements of both good and bad, of the expected and the unexpected. Amidst this jumble, at the very bottom, something rather interesting was discovered. It was a handful of truisms. These truisms, simple yet profound statements, held a certain wisdom that cut through the chaos. They were like little nuggets of truth that had endured the test of time.

Perhaps these truisms were overlooked in the hustle and bustle of the situation. But now that they had been found, they offered a moment of reflection. They made one stop and think about the fundamental aspects of life, about what really matters.

In a world full of complexity and confusion, these truisms served as a reminder that sometimes, the simplest things are the most valuable. They were a source of comfort and guidance, a light in the darkness.

So, even though the situation was a mixed bag, the discovery of these truisms added a touch of significance and meaning. It was a reminder that in the midst of chaos, there is always the possibility of finding something truly precious.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Incredible!

I understood more than the first time.

This experience was truly amazing.

It made me realize how much progress I have made.

Each time I engage with this, I discover new things and gain a deeper understanding.

It's like opening a door to a whole new world of knowledge.

I can't get enough of it.

I am completely in love with this feeling of growth and learning.

It gives me the motivation to keep going and explore even further.

I look forward to many more opportunities like this in the future.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly wish that I could recall the exact reason why I decided to pick up this particular text.

I only delved into The Social Contract portion of it. However, I did my utmost to give it as close and meticulous a first reading as possible. Even so, I am fully aware that this initial perusal is far from sufficient and only offers a rather superficial comprehension of what Rousseau was attempting to convey.

Nonetheless, at times, this cursory understanding can be enough. And in this specific instance, it has exceeded my wildest expectations for a text of this nature.

If anything, as a result of this encounter, I have emerged with a genuine and profound interest in the field of political science, whereas before, I had absolutely no inclination towards it.

This newfound interest has the potential to open up a whole new world of knowledge and exploration for me, and I look forward to delving deeper into this fascinating subject in the future.
July 15,2025
... Show More
DISCOURSE ON THE SCIENCES AND THE ARTS

The "DISCOURSE ON THE SCIENCES AND THE ARTS" is a profound and influential work. It delves into the complex relationship between the development of sciences and arts and the moral and social fabric of society.


Rousseau, the author, presents a thought-provoking argument that the progress of sciences and arts may not necessarily lead to the betterment of humanity. He questions whether the pursuit of knowledge and the refinement of artistic expression have come at the expense of our natural virtues and simplicity.


This discourse challenges us to reflect on the true value and consequences of our intellectual and creative endeavors. It makes us wonder if we have lost sight of what is truly important in our quest for scientific and artistic achievements.


Overall, the "DISCOURSE ON THE SCIENCES AND THE ARTS" remains a relevant and engaging piece of literature that continues to spark discussions and debates about the role of the sciences and arts in our lives.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The works of Rousseau are of great significance.

His "Discourse on the Sciences and Arts" has a score of 3. In this work, he explores the impact of the development of sciences and arts on society and human nature.

The "Discours on Inequality" is scored 4. Here, he delves into the origin and nature of inequality among humans, analyzing how social and economic factors contribute to this inequality.

Another important work is the "Social Contract" with a score of 3. In it, Rousseau presents his ideas on the formation and nature of the social contract, emphasizing the importance of the general will and the rights and obligations of citizens.

These works have had a profound influence on political philosophy, sociology, and other fields, and continue to be studied and debated by scholars today.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The first discourse is all about jumping on the book app and giving a historic (yet timeless and prescient!) text a mere three stars. How could one do such a thing? It's简直令人难以理解. This text has withstood the test of time and holds great significance, yet it is being rated so low.

Perhaps the person who gave it three stars didn't truly understand the depth and value of the text. Or maybe they were in a bad mood that day and took it out on the book. Whatever the reason, it's a shame.

A historic text like this deserves more than just a passing glance and a mediocre rating. It should be studied, analyzed, and appreciated for the masterpiece that it is.

We should all strive to give these important works the respect and recognition they deserve, rather than simply dismissing them with a few clicks on an app.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Rousseau's works, such as "Discourse on the Origin of Inequality" and "Social Contract," are of great significance. The dedication and preface of "Discourse on the Origin of Inequality" set the stage for his exploration. Part I, including Notes IX and XV, delves into the origin of inequality, analyzing how it developed in society. Part II further elaborates on this topic, presenting Rousseau's unique perspectives.


In "Social Contract," Book I, sections 1, 4 - 9 discuss fundamental concepts related to the social contract, such as the nature of the contract and the rights and obligations of individuals. Book II, sections 1 - 10 focus on aspects like the general will and the laws. Book III, sections 1 and 4 deal with topics such as government and its forms.


These works have had a profound impact on political philosophy and our understanding of society. Rousseau's ideas continue to be relevant and debated today, as they offer valuable insights into the nature of human beings, society, and the relationship between the individual and the state.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have had to give up three attempts, but the third time is the charm. And it seems that after half a year and a little more than 20 titles, Rousseau and I are getting along well.

It has been a journey filled with challenges and setbacks. The first two attempts were met with difficulties that made me question whether I could truly understand and connect with Rousseau's works. However, I refused to give up.

I persevered, spending countless hours reading, analyzing, and reflecting on his ideas. And slowly but surely, something began to click. I started to see the beauty and depth in his writing, and a newfound appreciation emerged.

Now, as we approach the end of this half-year period, I can say with confidence that Rousseau and I have found a common ground. We have established a connection that allows me to explore his thoughts and perspectives in a more meaningful way.

It has been a rewarding experience, and I look forward to continuing this journey of discovery with Rousseau by my side.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.