Rewritten and expanded:
This memoir is simultaneously heartbreaking and hopeful, delving deep into how literature has the power to shape our lives. On the surface, the plot may seem fairy simple. The author, burdened with a family life that is far from perfect, stumbles upon Shakespeare and has a lifelong passion for his works ignited. However, this book is much more than that. It is a profound examination of the significance of hope, love, and words in each and every one of our lives. The author's journey through the world of Shakespeare is filled with both joy and sorrow, as they discover new meanings and interpretations within the plays. It is a story that will resonate with anyone who has ever found solace or inspiration in literature. I, for one, found it profoundly moving. But I also understand that it's not going to be for everyone. Some may find the subject matter too niche or the writing style too dense. However, for those who are willing to take the time to explore this memoir, it has the potential to be a life-changing experience.
While I truly appreciated the way Smith embellished this memoir with a plethora of extensive quotes from Shakespeare, and it is indeed difficult to find fault with his well-lived life, in the final analysis, it simply didn't strike me as something that merited a full-blown memoir.
And, to be completely honest, I didn't have the impression that the writing managed to rise to the occasion to the extent that it potentially could have.
There were moments when the use of Shakespearean quotes added a certain charm and depth, but perhaps the overall narrative lacked that extra spark or uniqueness to truly justify a comprehensive memoir.
It felt as though there was more potential within the story that wasn't fully realized through the writing.
Nevertheless, Smith's life experiences are undoubtedly interesting, and it's possible that with a different approach to the writing or a more focused exploration of certain aspects, the memoir could have been more engaging and impactful.
Hamlet's Dresser is yet another memoir that delves into the profound impact Shakespeare had on someone's life. Fortunately, I didn't have to abandon this one mid-read.
Bob Smith, a troubled child, was deeply affected by his unstable mother, absent father, and mentally retarded sister. He turned to the words of Shakespeare for comfort and found solace within them. His life was tumultuous until he embraced his calling as a Shakespeare scholar. With this memoir, he attempts to heal the wounds of his past.
Unlike Ghostlight, which had a slow and linear narrative that got bogged down in the details of his early childhood trauma, Hamlet's Dresser jumps around in time. It moves from his childhood to adulthood and various points in between. While this keeps the story from becoming stagnant, it can sometimes feel a bit random. Smith will finish telling a story and then suddenly plop you back in the middle of it a page or so later, which can be disorienting if you're concerned about chronology.
One aspect I thoroughly enjoyed was his entry points to Shakespeare. He would often share a personal story and then conclude it with a quote from Shakespeare. When juxtaposed, these elements would illuminate each other, allowing you to sense the universal nature of the personal tale while also realizing that Shakespeare truly understood the human experience.
He also did an excellent job of portraying the effects of growing up in a Catholic family in the 1960s. The thoughtless things adults and parents say can leave lasting dents and scratches, and even burdens that last a lifetime. At a young age, when the world is still a mystery, we soak up information like a sponge, and something said in jest can echo in our minds for years.
Reviewing memoirs is a challenging task for me. It's not like fiction or a work of art that can be objectively analyzed. It's a person's life, laid bare and told from their perspective.
Nevertheless, I felt that he spent an excessive amount of time on his sister and mother. His sister became a heavy burden, and although he loved her, he was constantly haunted by her presence, often comparing her to the mad Ophelia. His mother, who would likely be diagnosed as manic depressive or bipolar today, used him as a crutch rather than a son. Several stories illustrate this dynamic, but they persist for half the book. Even with the jumping around, you don't reach the point where he starts working for a theater and becomes the titular Hamlet's dresser until about three-fourths of the way through.
However, this is an outstanding book for exploring the impact that high art can have on personal stories, not just Bob Smith's but those of the people he loves. Nevertheless, the pain in his story can often leave you feeling exhausted and affected by his depression.