Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 99 votes)
5 stars
31(31%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
37(37%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
99 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Isak Dinesen, a true master of the short story, has an uncanny ability to craft literary works that are like hard jewels.

Her stories are not only concise but also rich in depth and meaning. Each word is carefully chosen, as if she is polishing a precious gem to bring out its maximum sparkle and beauty.

Dinesen's narratives often explore themes such as love, loss, and the human condition, delving into the complex emotions and experiences that shape our lives.

Her writing style is both elegant and engaging, drawing readers in and keeping them captivated until the very end.

Whether it's a tale of a tragic romance or a humorous anecdote, Dinesen's short stories are always a delight to read, leaving a lasting impression on the reader's mind.

Truly, she is a master of her craft, and her works will continue to be cherished and studied for generations to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Intriguing and mysterious stories abound in this collection.

Some of them bear the mark of adventure set in the distant past. For instance, there is a story about a Sami woman who has a magical past as a seabird on the great oceans.

The other short stories seem more modern and realistic as they are set in the 19th century. However, the neo-romantic narrative style gives the impression of tales from bygone days. Many of the characters are confined by conventions that prevent them from pursuing happiness. Paradoxically, a French erotic dancer emerges as the most liberated and heroic figure in this book, as seen in the story "Heloïse" from the Franco-German War of 1870 - 71. The most touching story is about a young married couple who strive to raise an orphaned boy from Copenhagen's worst slum.

Blixen provides masterful descriptions of the Danish landscape in different seasons. Even without mountains, it is more diverse than one might typically envision. (I read the book in Danish).

Overall, these stories offer a captivating blend of the past and the present, with vivid characters and beautiful descriptions that transport the reader to another world.
July 15,2025
... Show More
As he continued walking and reached the outskirts of the place, he noticed a little girl in a blue frock. She was standing on the other side of a fence, looking at him. She was around thirteen or fourteen years old, as slender as an eel. Her face was round, clear, and freckled, and she had a pair of long plaits. The two of them simply looked at one another.


At times, he was convinced that his young girl would blush at a particularly conventional comment during the conversation. It was as if she was ashamed of the pretence and falsity of her surroundings. He rejoiced at this because he himself had suffered due to the sham of his own world. He then thought: This fresh and innocent girl has a fierce respect for the truth. She is horrified by our frivolous way of living. He longed to talk to her about the ideas that filled his own mind.


It was a strange aspect of their friendship that he would so often dream of her, even when he hadn't thought of her during the day. In his dreams, she frequently vanished and got lost. One might have expected that these dreams would eventually have filled him with a real fear of losing her. But it wasn't the case. On the contrary, and to his own detriment, they convinced him that even when she seemed to be gone, she would surely return when the day broke.


As he walked, the quiet garden gradually began its daily routine. A big snail, the kind his grandfather had brought back from France and which he remembered eating as a child in the house, was already, with dignity, dragging a silver trail down the avenue. The birds started to sing. In an old tree where he stopped, a number of them were bothering an owl. The rule of the night was over.


“But still I wonder,” he said after a long pause. “What is the meaning of it all? Why can't we give up painting and writing and let the public have peace? What good do we do them in the end? What good, ultimately, is art to man? Vanity, vanity, all is vanity.”
July 15,2025
... Show More
I am truly delighted to have made the discovery of Karen Blixen, also known by her nom-de-plume Isak Dinesen, through this remarkable collection of short stories.

Her prose is an absolute delight, being fecund and starkly beautiful. It has an incantatory quality that is simply perfect in complementing the various shades of magical realism that pervade these enchanting tales.

The stories on the surface may appear simple, often revolving around a single event that might not seem to have any obvious significance. However, beneath the unassuming exterior of these narratives lies a roiling intensity and emotional turbulence that leaves the reader deeply affected, yet unable to fully fathom the reason why.

Dinesen's portrayal of the characters' inner lives is passionate, bordering on hysterical at times, and has a distinct Dostoevskian quality that I find particularly enjoyable.

Furthermore, folkloric and gothic influences are evident throughout this collection, both in terms of style and theme. As a lover of these genres, I relished the dark, wintry atmosphere that she manages to conjure up so effectively here.

"The Sailor-Boy's Tale" and "Peter and Rosa" are among my favorite tales in this collection, but "Sorrow-Acre" is undoubtedly its masterpiece. I am certain that I will re-read the latter, as it feels almost impossible to fully digest in a single sitting.

I will most definitely seek out more of Dinesen's writing. I'm not usually one to be enamored of short-story collections, but a writer in this genre who can evoke such a high degree of enthusiasm in me seems more than worthy of further investigation.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I've just noticed the "hide entire review because of spoilers" check box under this text field. Have no fear. I bear no spoilers. I'm not even sure how you would spoil this book. I don't know what I could say to ruin any portion of it for a future reader, because in trying to explain the stories in this book to friends, I found myself apologizing for minutes of contextualizing and setup with basically zero payoff at the end of my ramblings.


The main hope I come out of this reading with is that I am just too stupid to get what she was going for with most of these stories. I can't rate it any lower than 3 stars, because the journeys she took me on were wonderful and vivid and funny and distressing. However, the upshot to all of it was basically that not much happened and there wasn't much to take away from any of it. It is of course also possible that she's just not a fan of wrapping things up.


I probably would have quit this book about 2/3 of the way through, but it was given to me as a gift by a bookshop owner for visiting his store and came recommended based on the reading habits I told him about. I wanted to see it through. I'm not glad that I did but I'm not upset either. But I guess I'm a touch more upset than glad. I think 2.4 stars is about where I'd land, but as I said before, 2 feels too low. Maybe I'm missing something crucial, something that would make me appreciate this book more. But for now, this is my honest assessment.
July 15,2025
... Show More
In all the brief lifetime of the Danish summer, there is no moment that is richer or more luscious than that particular week when the lime trees flower.

The heavenly scent ascends to the head and penetrates the heart. It seems to forge a connection between the fields of Denmark and those of Elysium.

It encompasses the essence of hay, the sweetness of honey, and the sacredness of holy incense. It is a blend of half fairy-land and half apothecary's locker.

The avenue undergoes a transformation into a mystic edifice, a dryad's cathedral. From the summit to the base, it is lavishly adorned, bedecked with multitudinous ornaments, and glistens golden in the sun.

However, behind the walls, the vaults are benignly cool and sombre, resembling ambrosial sanctuaries in a dazzling and burning world. And in here, the ground remains moist, adding to the enchanting and mysterious atmosphere.

This description of the lime tree flowers in the Danish summer creates a vivid and captivating image that lingers in the mind.
July 15,2025
... Show More
In the haunting Winter’s Tales, Dinesen carved out a distinctive niche in modern letters.

She wrote in a stately and distinctive English, translating her works back into her native tongue for their Danish publication.

Dinesen had the remarkable ability to create an atmosphere that skillfully blended the unwavering steadiness of the fairy tale with the intensified psychic sensitivities of Gothic themes.

The sense of apprehension that her style engenders is further enhanced by what could be described as the intrinsically foreign, and at times even otherworldly, nature of her settings.

Suffused with both the menacing darkness and the joyous promise of folktales, her stories are polished to a gem-like brilliance by this modern master’s unique finesse.

Her works stand as a testament to her extraordinary talent and her ability to transport readers into a world that is both familiar and yet completely different.

Dinesen’s Winter’s Tales continue to captivate audiences and leave a lasting impression on all who have the pleasure of experiencing her literary genius.
July 15,2025
... Show More
One of the toughest books in my life!

It was a real challenge to get through. The content was so complex and deep that it required a great deal of concentration and effort. I found myself constantly rereading paragraphs, trying to understand the author's intended meaning.

But despite the difficulties, I persevered. I knew that this book had the potential to teach me something valuable, and I was determined to uncover its secrets.

As I delved deeper into the pages, I began to see connections and patterns that I had missed before. The author's words started to make sense, and I felt a sense of accomplishment and growth.

In the end, I can say that this book was one of the most rewarding experiences of my life. It taught me the importance of perseverance and hard work, and it expanded my knowledge and understanding in ways that I never thought possible.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly had a great enjoyment from reading "Sorrow-Acre" and "The Young Man with the Carnation".

The latter story, in particular, I was already quite familiar with as I had heard the opera that was based on it.

The experience of reading these stories was so captivating that I firmly believe I will want to re-read them again one day.

These tales have a certain charm and depth that draw the reader in and keep them engaged from beginning to end.

The vivid descriptions and well-developed characters make them come alive in the imagination.

Whether it's the mystery and sadness in "Sorrow-Acre" or the romantic and tragic elements in "The Young Man with the Carnation", both stories have left a lasting impression on me.

I look forward to the day when I can once again immerse myself in these wonderful literary works and discover new details and interpretations.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Like many readers, I have a certain acquaintance with Dinesen mainly through "Out of Africa".

These stories possess a rather dark and dense quality. They are filled with elements of religion and depict aristocrats grappling with their so-called 1%er problems.

However, due to my own lack of cultural background, I found that I didn't truly "comprehend" most of them.

Perhaps this shortcoming lies more with me than with the author. Nevertheless, it ultimately led to a generally unrewarding reading experience for me.

I felt as if I was missing out on the deeper meanings and subtleties that these stories might have held.

It made me realize the importance of having a broader understanding of different cultures and historical contexts when approaching literature.

Despite this initial disappointment, I still hope to explore more of Dinesen's works in the future, perhaps with a more informed perspective.

Maybe then, I will be able to appreciate the true beauty and complexity of her writing.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Shorter tales than the Seven Gothic Tales, yet they are suffused with the same glittery dark mood.

These tales are truly unlike any other works I have ever come across. They possess a unique charm and allure that sets them apart.

I am so incredibly grateful that they exist.

The highlights among them include "Young Man with the Carnation", "Sorrow-Acre", "The Heroine", and "The Fish".

However, the most captivating of all is perhaps "Peter and Rosa", with its swooning, passionate narrative that draws the reader in and holds them spellbound.

Each of these tales has its own distinct flavor and atmosphere, making them a joy to read and explore.

They offer a glimpse into a world of mystery, darkness, and beauty, and I highly recommend them to anyone who enjoys a good story.

Whether you are a fan of Gothic literature or simply looking for something new and different, these tales are sure to satisfy.

So, pick them up and let yourself be transported to a world of wonder and imagination.
July 15,2025
... Show More

The prose within these pages is simply gorgeous, like a delicate tapestry of words that weaves a spellbinding narrative. The characters I encountered are singular, each with their own unique charm and allure. My absolute favorite story is The Dreaming Child, which had such a profound impact on me that it quite literally took my breath away.


I also had a great affection for The Pearls, Peter and Rosa, The Invincible Slave Owners, and The Sailor-Boy's Tale, in that very order. These stories were captivating, filled with vivid imagery and engaging plotlines that kept me turning the pages.


The next tier of my favorites includes The Young Man and the Carnation, A Consolatory Tale, and Sorrow Acre. While not as immediately striking as my top choices, they still had their own merits and managed to leave a lasting impression.


However, I must admit that the only stories I didn't find as memorable as the rest were The Fish and The Heroine. They didn't quite resonate with me in the same way as the others.


Overall, Dinsen/Blixen has a voice that is truly unlike any other. Her writing is masterful, and I cannot recommend this collection highly enough. It is a literary gem that is sure to delight readers of all ages.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.