Thinking back, my passion for literary historical fiction can be traced back to the remarkable works of Lois Lowry. In particular, Number the Stars, the winner of the 1990 Newbery Medal, left a profound impact on me. It was Lois Lowry's realistic, heart-wrenching, and painfully honest novels about actual historical events that ignited in me a burning desire to explore further the time periods she so vividly portrayed. I have an unwavering trust in Lois Lowry's storytelling abilities; her books are seamless blends of intense emotion and historical authenticity. I was filled with excitement when I picked up The Silent Boy, and it truly exceeded my expectations.

Looking back on her life in early 20th-century America, eighty-three-year-old Katy Thatcher has a significant story to share from her youth. This is a tale that has remained untold for most of her life, yet the people who were hurt long ago are no less important simply because of the passage of time. Katy knows that what happened all those years ago should have had a different outcome. In the early 1900s and 1910s, there was less understanding and sympathy for the disabled and the mentally impaired. Good intentions often went unnoticed, and could not save those who had already been judged harshly by society.

Young Katy is fortunate to grow up in a loving and financially secure family in the first quarter of the 20th century, mainly due to her father's job as a doctor. In fact, when Katy turns eight, the Thatchers take in a young working girl named Peggy, who becomes Katy's good friend. However, it is Peggy's older brother, Jacob, who catches Katy's particular interest. Jacob is known to be silent and "touched," but Katy sees the kindness in him as he treats the animals on the family farm and marvels at his impressive ability to mimic various sounds. Katy understands that Jacob is not the idiot that others often assume he is.

The times are changing around Katy, both within her family and in the world at large. She sometimes struggles to keep up with all the new information and expectations. Troubles begin to surface in Peggy's family when her older sister Nell creates problems with the son of the family she works for. The situation escalates, and the stress becomes unbearable when Katy's mother makes a shocking discovery. Jacob, in his attempt to do what he thinks is right, finds himself in a difficult situation. People are not always willing to look beyond their initial assumptions to understand the truth.

I believe that everyone has their unique quirks, and it is often easier to understand and accept our own than those of others. I cannot imagine what it is like to be mentally disabled like Jacob, but I think we all have experienced being marginalized or rejected because of our perceived flaws. As long as this thoughtless derision continues, there will always be remarkable individuals like Jacob who are not given the opportunity to shine. We, as a society, will be the ones to suffer for our lack of understanding.

Up until the last twenty-five pages or so, The Silent Boy reads like an average historical fiction novel, a simple and enjoyable period piece that offers insights into life in another era. However, the story's powerful conclusion, which I had been anticipating from a writer of Lois Lowry's caliber, suddenly appears and hits like a lead weight. It may leave us wondering about the true meaning and value of the story, but there is still hope to be found if we look closely. Even in the face of injustice, there is always the possibility of doing better and making a positive change.

As always, Lois Lowry has managed to write a compelling story that will stay with sensitive readers long after they finish the final page. The photographs at the beginning of each chapter, taken during the time period in which the story is set, add depth and authenticity to the narrative, allowing us to visualize the characters more vividly. Even readers who are not usually fans of historical fiction are likely to find something of value in this book and may discover a newfound interest in the genre, just as I did when I first read Lois Lowry's novels. I would rate The Silent Boy at least two and a half stars, and perhaps even a full three.

I have always had a deep affection for Lois Lowry whenever I am in the mood to explore her unique writing style. This particular book was no different, captivating me from the very beginning.

Many individuals have assigned a lower rating to this book, citing the fact that it is labeled as a young reader's book, which they believe it is not. I concur that it may not be suitable for all young readers. However, considering the other materials I was reading at the age of 10 or 11, I would have been able to handle it without any issues.

Some people have given it a low rating because they have interpreted the storyline near the ending in a different manner than I did. I do not wish to spoil the plot for anyone, but if you happen to read it and the "tragic turn" causes you distress, I encourage you to consider if there might be an alternative way of viewing it.

I was truly impressed by the portrayal of Jacob, his disability, and his relationship with Katy. It was both gentle and realistic, adding a layer of depth and authenticity to the story.

There were aspects of this book that I truly loved.

The narrator was engaging, the setting was vividly described, the photographs added an interesting dimension, and the portrayal of autism in a time when it wasn't well understood or even named was remarkable.

However, there were also things that took me by surprise.

The tragedies in the book made me question whether it was okay for my 10-year-old to read it without my guidance.

I don't doubt that he should read it, but rather that he read it on his own before I had a chance to read it myself.

Overall, I have a deep admiration for Lois Lowry's writing, and this book was no different.

I would only recommend this to kids if a trusted adult has either already talked to them about sex or is prepared to do so as part of the discussion about the book, as sex ends up being a part of one of the major tragedies in the story.

Now that I've read it after my son, we can have a meaningful conversation about it together.

For those who believe this book is too dark and depressing for middle grade students, I encourage them to consider what their children or students are exposed to on TV, social media, and in video games.

This book presents real life emotions, problems, and tragedies in an open and honest manner, allowing kids to gain an understanding of life in the past without being as graphically explicit as other mediums.

My mother says 'touched by the Lord,' and I think it's true.

Jacob Stoltz is a boy who, in modern times, might be labeled as "autistic" or "mentally challenged." However, he has a remarkable way with all kinds of animals. He spends his days roaming around, taking care of the animals on his family's farm. He is always vigilant, looking out for their well-being and doing his best to care for them. For instance, when a female dog died while giving birth, leaving only one puppy alive, Jacob saved it. He fed the puppy cow's milk every day using a rag so it could suckle. Also, when a lamb was rejected by its mother, Jacob found another mother for it to ensure its survival.

When Jacob's sister Peggy goes to work as a hired girl for the Thatchers, not much changes for him, except that now both of his older sisters are out of the house. Peggy works at the Thatchers', and Nellie works at the Bishops'. It comes as no surprise that the Bishops' oldest son Paul and Nellie have a flirty relationship, as shown throughout the book. When it is revealed that Nellie is pregnant with Paul's child and she doesn't want it, Jacob takes matters into his own hands. He does what he thinks is best and takes the baby to the Thatchers' home. The Thatchers recently had a baby of their own, and Jacob hopes to provide a better home for Nellie's unwanted child. However, the journey is too long, and the night is too cold and wet. The baby dies as a result of Jacob's heroic attempt to help a defenseless being. As a consequence, Jacob is forced into the Asylum.

Jacob's attempt to save Nellie's baby is a selfless and heroic act. His character has been shown to be kind, peaceful, loving, and immensely gentle. It is tragic that a life is lost despite his good intentions. Jacob only wanted to do for Nellie's child what he did for the unwanted lamb. He did nothing wrong, yet he is confined to the Asylum, where he will not be happy. He enjoys being in the open, sometimes walking eight miles to the Thatchers' residence and back. Being locked up in a building will not suit him. Perhaps in long-forgotten papers, one might find mention of him, proof that he existed, that he loved animals, and that he once tried to save an unnamed baby but failed.

Note: This is a work of fiction.

Hmmm...... Lois Lowry is truly one of my favorite authors. She has an extraordinary way with words that always manages to captivate me.

This book is no exception. The characters she creates are so life-like, each with their own distinct personalities.

The story centers around a young girl named Katy. She vividly tells the tale of her growing up in the early 1900's. She shares details about her many friends, especially how she befriends a boy named Little Jacob who is "touched in the head".

Little Jacob is different. He doesn't speak but instead communicates with animals. Her friendship with him is unique. They have developed their own special way of talking to each other and understanding what the other one is thinking.

However, one fateful night changes everything. This is a really good story that will surely make you reflect on your own friendships and the special bonds we form with others.

It makes you realize that friendships can come in all different shapes and sizes, and that sometimes the most unexpected friendships can be the most meaningful.

Lois Lowry has once again crafted a story that is both engaging and thought-provoking.

Library Audiobook: narrated by Karen Allen.

I'm quite sensitive to the voices in audiobooks. I usually either really like them or not at all. It's not unusual for me to return half a dozen audiobooks that I've attempted.

So, I'm going to start taking more responsibility and begin to remember the names of the audiobook narrators.

Karen Allen, the audiobook narrator, had a very distinct speaking voice compared to other female voices I've listened to, and it has nothing to do with an accent. She spoke softly, giving a very serene feeling, almost a meditative one. It worked extremely well for this story.

I was fully engaged and peaceful on my walks with Karen reading to me.

This is a 'looking back' story. Katy Thatcher is a grown woman remembering her childhood, with a special focus on Jacob, who is clearly autistic.

Lois Lowry does a wonderful job handling complex and tragic issues, capturing the qualities of autism and the insults and mocking from the kids in the community.

The end of this book is rather disturbing. I can't envision reading this book to young children. Mature middle school kids might be able to handle it, but I actually think adults would appreciate this book the most.

I was very drawn into this community. The strong characterization, voiced through the children's eyes, made it truly engaging.

Jacob had disabilities, but his humanity shone through brightly.

Predictable, but interesting enough. The ending was a bit over-dramatic with the narrator rationalizing through what must have happened. In case we're too dumb as an audience to get it, this felt rather forced. Also, the attempt at misdirection with the kittens just didn't really work for me. It seemed out of place and didn't add much to the overall story.

The biggest problem with this book is that the narrator is writing from the vantage of being old and recollecting events. However, the language, naivete, and "mystery" are all treated as if it's happening from the perspective of a young child who doesn't understand things like sex, etc. This inconsistency just didn't work for me on that level. It made the story feel disjointed and unrealistic. And the denouement especially, in which the writer sort of wraps up what became of everyone (except any real details about herself oddly enough), felt just tacked on and unnecessary. It didn't add any real depth or closure to the story.

I don't know. I didn't hate reading this and it had a lot of potential. The concept was interesting and there were some good moments. But ultimately it just went flat for me. It didn't live up to its promise and left me feeling disappointed. Maybe with some revisions and a more consistent narrative voice, it could have been a better book. But as it stands, it's just an average read.

This tragic story serves as a powerful reminder that we all should remember to have empathy for others.

Empathy is crucial as it allows us to do our best to understand others and their unique worlds and experiences.

In a world where we often focus on our own lives and concerns, it is easy to forget the importance of putting ourselves in someone else's shoes.

However, this story shows us that by taking the time to truly understand others, we can make a significant difference in their lives.

It could be as simple as listening to someone's problems, offering a helping hand, or just showing kindness and compassion.

When we have empathy, we are able to build stronger relationships, resolve conflicts more effectively, and create a more harmonious and caring society.

Let us all strive to be more empathetic and make a positive impact on the lives of those around us.

I had never read this particular book before. However, I gave it to my 11-year-old son to read for school.

Surprisingly, it's the very first book that he has said to me, "You should read this. It's really good." In fact, he is so enthusiastic about it that he wants our entire family to read it. Naturally, we will!

I completed reading it this morning, and I have to admit that he is absolutely right - it's an extremely good book. Lowry, as she always is, is a remarkable author. Right from the start, she captivates you with her vivid descriptive language and realistic portrayal of emotions.

I did think that perhaps it might have been more suitable for my son to be a little older when he read it. But to my relief, he didn't seem at all bothered by the themes presented in the book at any point.

I am truly thrilled that this book has awakened a love of good literature in him. Just for that reason alone, I would give this book five stars.

[Guessing at the star rating / mining my old FB notes now that they are almost impossible to find]

Ever since I read Lois Lowry's The Giver a few years back, I've been longing to read more of her works. This particular one didn't have the same powerful impact on me. However, I firmly believe that her greatest strength lies in the simplicity with which her books are written and the openness they offer to interpretation. Intended to be a YA novel, it is up to the reader to decide how to absorb the information and where their own judgment lies. There is a pervading sense of sadness throughout, but perhaps that's just my personal perception. Maybe others are inspired to take action and strive for justice.

Lowry delivered a truly fabulous speech when she accepted the Newbery for The Giver. You can find it here: www.loislowry.com/pdf/Newbery_Award.pdf

It's a superficially decent period piece. Lois Lowry does paint a rather pretty picture of life in the early 20th-century American Midwest. However, it falls short in a significant way. There is an absence of anything that could be considered a meaningful discussion between its characters. It doesn't even give the impression that Lois Lowry was aiming for more.

The formula of the book is rather repetitive. Some bad adult-y thing occurs, and the protagonist, Katy, inquires about it from an adult. Usually, she is told to stop talking. Then, she engages in some naive, eight-year-old thinking about the matter. This cycle repeats.

I'm not placing the blame on Katy; rather, I'm faulting the adults. The weak point of this cycle is the lack of engagement from the adults. This, in turn, highlights a major flaw in the novel - a glaring lack of relationship development between the characters. They simply don't communicate with each other very often. Besides a few instances related to the eponymous Silent Boy, no adult, teen, or peer has a conversation with Katy about any of the issues she brings up throughout the novel.

Just as the protagonist is continuously told to stop talking by 20th-century adults in the novel, I had the distinct feeling that Lois Lowry was suppressing the reader's curiosity about this particular time period.

Katy Thatcher grows up in a small town with a big dream. She hopes to follow in her father's footsteps and become a doctor. One day, on a trip to pick up the "hired girl," Katy's life takes an unexpected turn. She meets Jacob, a boy with a mental illness. As the year unfolds, Katy encounters Jacob in various situations. Through these encounters, she starts to understand his actions and the reasons behind them.

Katy also has to grapple with some disturbing sexual images she comes across. These involve the neighbor boy and the neighbor's hired girl. When their relationship leads to pregnancy, everything goes downhill quickly, and Jacob becomes involved. But Katy is the only one who truly understands what has happened and why.

I initially thought the language of this book was suitable for a younger grade, maybe 5th to 7th. However, the content, which includes sexuality, death, and mental illness, along with the dark ending, makes it a book that should really only be read by mature 8th graders or high school students. It's a complex and thought-provoking story that deals with some heavy themes.