Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 98 votes)
5 stars
38(39%)
4 stars
31(32%)
3 stars
29(30%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
98 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a remarkable late 14th-century Middle English chivalric romance. It stands as one of the most renowned Arthurian tales, skillfully combining two captivating folk motifs: the beheading game and the exchange of winnings.


Written in stanzas of alliterative verse, each concluding with a rhyming bob and wheel, it draws inspiration from Welsh, Irish, and English stories, as well as the French chivalric tradition. This makes it an important exemplar of a chivalric romance, typically featuring a hero on a quest that tests his prowess.


On New Year's Day in Camelot, as King Arthur's court exchanges gifts and awaits the start of the feasting, the king expresses his desire to see or hear of an exciting adventure. Suddenly, a gigantic, entirely green figure rides into the hall on a green horse. He wears no armour but wields an axe in one hand and a holly bough in the other. Refusing to fight anyone present, deeming them too weak, he insists on a friendly Christmas game: someone must strike him once with his axe, with the condition that the Green Knight may return the blow in a year and a day. The splendid axe will belong to whoever accepts this deal.


When it seems no other knight dares to accept the challenge, Arthur himself is prepared to step forward. However, Sir Gawain, the youngest of Arthur's knights and his nephew, requests the honour instead. The giant bends and bares his neck, and Gawain neatly severs his head in one stroke. But astonishingly, the Green Knight neither falls nor falters. Instead, he reaches out, picks up his severed head, remounts, and holds it up to Queen Guinevere while its writhing lips remind Gawain that they must meet again at the Green Chapel. He then rides away. Gawain and Arthur admire the axe, hang it up as a trophy, and encourage Guinevere to view the whole matter lightly.


This story, with its rich tapestry of elements and its exploration of chivalry and honour, continues to captivate readers to this day. It offers a fascinating glimpse into the world of medieval romance and the ideals that knights held dear.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Second reading: This is a humorously subversive piece of Arthurian literature. As Gawain tries to conform to competing virtues like chastity and courtesy, the poet playfully mocks the chivalric tradition. Here, we have a highly self-aware author with a sharp understanding of cultural irony. The content is rich in religious syncretism and ideal for modern critiques. The language is vivid and lively.


First reading: This might be one of the most interesting poems I've had the pleasure of reading. The abundance and combination of religious and cultural themes are similar to the poetic richness and ideological depth of Shelley's Frankenstein. Both authors recognize the influence of past traditions on their current literary culture while presenting their work as超越 the past. In the same vein, the Gawain Poet pays homage to the ancients, explicitly referring to the role Homer and Virgil played in the founding of Britain and also modeling the protagonist's wanderings after those of the classics. Just as St. Augustine models his Confessions after the classical pilgrimage trope but also diverges from the pagans in the Christian sense, the Gawain poem follows suit. In other words, the Gawain poet, like St. Augustine, appropriates the classical journey motif and adapts it to his own culture.


Speaking of that culture, upon my initial reading, I didn't realize how strongly the Western spirit pervades this work. It's easy to be captivated by the paradoxically detailed and grand poetic style, comparable to the adventures in Tolkien's Hobbit and Lewis's Chronicles, and not notice the author's focus on transgression and forgiveness. I must admit, I loved the scenes of Jove and the cheer at the dinner feasts, similar to Beowulf and his comrades in the mead hall. However, Jackson says: "In the Middle Ages, every act of reading was a moral endeavor." This is true of this poem as well. As Gawain makes a seemingly divine contract with the Green Knight, he faces temptations of pride, lust, and the loss of his chivalric honor. But it turns out that the Green Knight shows him mercy, a mercy he doesn't deserve due to his deception and attempted violation of his fate.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I remembered the essentials of this from high school English. However, upon rereading it, I was truly struck by the beauty of the language and the structure of the poem. The longer lines are accentuated by what my edition calls the “bob and wheel,” which are the short lines at the end. It works so well.

For example, lines 107 - 124 vividly describe the feast of King Arthur and his Round Table knights.

With a flaring crack of trumpets, the feast began. The trumpets were all hung with bright banners, and the drums beat. Glorious bagpipes rumbled and shrilled their quick-step tunes, and hearts beat quick with the music. At the signal, rare and delicate dishes were served. There was venison in great slabs, and so many platters that there was almost no place to set them in front of the guests. The broths and stews were in overflowing abundance. All ate as they pleased and as much as they wanted, a dozen dishes apiece, and beer and wine flowed free.

I’m not overly concerned with any allegorical meaning. I simply enjoy the poem for the language, the setting, and the story. And what a cracking good story it is, too!
July 15,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is an exquisitely rich and beautiful work.

This captivating chivalric romance had me constantly on the edge of my seat, guessing and posing numerous questions.

It's precisely this element that I've always cherished in any piece of literature.

I can vividly recall many of its scenes, yet certain aspects remain somewhat blurred in my memory.

If my memory serves me right, I delved into more than one version of this work and found the diverse renderings truly fascinating.

Whose version did I have a greater preference for? Which copy was my absolute favorite?

Did I ever make an attempt to read it in its original form? Sadly, I can't quite remember.

What I do remember clearly is that I thoroughly enjoyed it and even went as far as writing papers on it.

Another classic that I undeniably need to reread before embarking on a more in-depth review.

I must unearth my old textbooks and handbooks, for I'm certain that I'll discover at least one copy of this enchanting chivalric romance within their pages.

July 15,2025
... Show More

It is especially surprising because despite knowing that it is a story written in the Middle Ages, it still functions quite well as a plot and story in general. The influence it had on Tolkien and all the epic fantasy that came after can be noted.

This old story has a certain charm and durability. Its narrative structure and the elements within it have withstood the test of time. It manages to engage readers even today, perhaps because of its simplicity and the fundamental themes it explores.

Tolkien, in particular, was clearly inspired by this work. His own epic fantasies, such as "The Lord of the Rings," bear the marks of the influence from this medieval story. The concepts of a heroic quest, a battle between good and evil, and a richly imagined world all have their roots in this earlier work.

Overall, this story from the Middle Ages continues to be relevant and influential, serving as a testament to the power of great storytelling and its ability to inspire generations of writers and readers alike.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This was a little hard to read at times. The text seemed to lack some coherence and flow, making it a bit of a struggle to fully understand the intended message. Additionally, there were moments when it felt a little boring. The content didn't always engage me in a way that held my attention throughout.

However, despite these drawbacks, overall I still liked this. There was something about it that appealed to me. Maybe it was the unique perspective or the underlying theme that I found interesting. It had its闪光点, even if they were a bit hidden at times.

I think with a little more polish and refinement, this could be an even better piece. Some areas could be expanded upon, and the language could be made more vivid and engaging. But as it stands, it still has its charm and I'm glad I took the time to read it.

July 15,2025
... Show More
A really great re-telling, presented in the charming form of a storybook.

As I was reading it to my kids, I did find myself skipping and heavily abridging a few pages. You see, I simply wasn't ready to read them the attempted seduction scenes! However, despite these omissions, overall we really, truly enjoyed it!

The illustrations within the book were absolutely fabulous as well. They added an extra layer of charm and visual appeal to the already engaging story.

My kids were completely captivated by the tale, and it was a joy to share this reading experience with them.

The author did an excellent job of presenting the story in a way that was accessible and interesting for children, while still maintaining the essence and excitement of the original.

I would highly recommend this storybook to other parents looking for a great read-aloud option for their kids.
July 15,2025
... Show More
You like tales of King Arthur, don't you? Well, perhaps, just like me, you made an attempt to read Morte D'Arthur and it didn't quite pan out as expected. But don't despair! There's an alternative for you.

This particular piece is only around 100 pages in length. What makes it truly interesting is that it is written in cool alliterative verse, which gives it a unique rhythm and flow. Moreover, the pacing is excellent. The text is concise and to the point, with nothing superfluous or unnecessary.

Gawain, one of the characters, is a decent sort of fellow, although perhaps a bit on the boring side. However, the Green Knight more than makes up for it with one of the most memorable entrances in all of literature.

As an added bonus, try to envision Don Quixote reading this book and then acting it out. Maybe have a glass or two of wine while you're at it. Before you know it, you'll have yourself an entertaining evening filled with knights, quests, and a whole lot of fun.

So, give this alternative take on the King Arthur legend a try. You might just be pleasantly surprised.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I actually can't believe how much I loved this!

From the very beginning, I was filled with anticipation. I had high hopes for this thing, whatever it was. And as it unfolded before my eyes, something truly magical happened. It was as if an invisible force had taken hold of me and completely enchanted me entirely.

Every little detail, every nuance, seemed to speak to my soul. I found myself completely immersed in it, unable to tear my attention away. It was like a beautiful dream that I never wanted to wake up from. The more I experienced it, the deeper my love grew. I was completely smitten, and I knew that this was something special that I would remember for a long time to come.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Dev Patel is a talented actor who has made a name for himself in the entertainment industry.

In "The Emerald Bicycle," he takes on a new and exciting role that showcases his acting skills.

The story follows his character's journey on a bareback mountain, facing various challenges and obstacles along the way.

Dev Patel brings his character to life with authenticity and depth, making the audience root for him from start to finish.

His performance in this film is sure to be a standout and will likely earn him more praise and recognition.

Overall, "The Emerald Bicycle" is a must-see movie for fans of Dev Patel and those who enjoy engaging and thought-provoking stories.

With his unique talent and charm, Dev Patel continues to make a mark in the world of cinema.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Sir Gawain is a noble and heroic knight, but behind him stands the Green Knight, a figure who is not only gayer but also more evil.

The Green Knight's flamboyant appearance and mysterious nature add an air of intrigue to the story. His actions seem to be driven by a malicious intent, as he challenges Sir Gawain to a dangerous game.

Sir Gawain, on the other hand, is determined to uphold his honor and face the Green Knight's challenge. However, as the story unfolds, it becomes clear that the Green Knight's true motives are far more sinister than initially thought.

The contrast between Sir Gawain's noble qualities and the Green Knight's evil nature creates a captivating dynamic. It makes the reader question the true nature of good and evil and how easily one can be influenced by the forces around them.

Overall, the relationship between Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a central element of the story, adding depth and complexity to the narrative.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Ahhh, this was truly amazing. It turns out that Gawain was the Green Knight all along - yes, that's a spoiler, but the book is 600 years old, so it's not like it's a secret anymore. The hunting scenes were extremely exciting, and that game with the axe was a real "oh shit" moment.

Interestingly enough, I'm not really a big fan of Arthuriana, but I wanted to read this one before the A24 movie comes out. Still, maybe Hollywood could take a break from making a King Arthur movie every five years and do one movie based on the chansons de geste. Seriously, if you liked this, go and find a copy of Raoul of Cambrai. I highly recommend the Michael Newth translation. You'll thank me later.

I also highly recommend the BBC In Our Time episode on The Green Knight, which features Simon Armitage, whose translation I read. The link is: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000.... It's a great resource for anyone interested in learning more about this fascinating story.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.