Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
24(24%)
4 stars
37(37%)
3 stars
39(39%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I started doing half of this task through audio. However, as I went along, I found myself completely losing interest and not giving a rat's ass about anyone or anything related to it.

I just couldn't seem to focus or bring myself to care anymore. Maybe it was the monotony of the audio or perhaps I was just in a bad mood.

Whatever the reason, I've reached a point where I'm done. I'm outta here and I don't really care what happens next.

I guess sometimes you just have those moments where you can't be bothered and you need to walk away. And that's exactly what I'm doing now.
July 15,2025
... Show More
From the blurb on the back of my edition:


"For sheer imagination and comedy, for sustained narrative power and its miraculous reproduction of the rhythm of Southern small-town speech - often amounting to outright poetry - the story represents Miss Welty at her magical best." San Francisco Chronicle


I might have some minor objections to the idea of it being her magical "best", but there is no denying the magic and mesmerizing quality of her writing. It does take some time to adjust to the outdated concepts of race presented in the story. However, it should be remembered that this was set in 1923, a time when such views were prevalent.


This was a short and enjoyable read, filled with unforgettable and indelible characters.


Why I'm reading this: This is the August pick for the GR group On the Southern Literary Trail, which is one of my favorite groups to read with and engage in discussions about books! It offers a great opportunity to explore the rich and unique world of Southern literature and gain new perspectives from fellow readers.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Oh, my.

This book was truly an amazing, folksy, and funny adventure with Ms. Welty. It offers a unique glimpse into a particular time and place.

However, it's important to note that it is set in the former Confederacy in the 1920s and was written in the 1950s.

As such, one must be cautious of the blatant racism and the use of the "n-word" within its pages.

Despite this, if you have a penchant for stories about eccentric families in small towns, this book might still hold some appeal.

After all, we have our fair share of such families in the Yankee states as well.

It's a complex work that requires careful consideration and an understanding of the historical context in which it was written.

Overall, it's a book that can both entertain and educate, but one must approach it with an open mind and a critical eye.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this little gem as a part of the July 2013 group reads in the group On the Southern Literary Trail.

In most of the rural South, even in the present day, there are certain unspoken rules regarding which families' potato salads are "safe" to eat and which ones are to be avoided at all costs. These "laws to live by" have less to do with flavor or pathogens and more to do with family lines that should not cross. Children learn these lessons from the time they can fix their own plates at covered dish dinners, whether it's to welcome the new preacher or to lighten a family's load directly after a loved one is lowered into the ground. "It's fine to sample Alma's cooking, but you need to avoid Lucille's beans....I hear they aren't much count".

It's in that spirit that Welty tackles this quick-witted little tale of a most peculiar man who is loved by everyone but fails to connect with not one but TWO spouses. The second marriage follows much too soon after the first to be accepted by most at the time this was published. I am sure there are far deeper satirical themes in play, but for now I enjoyed the story on the surface level.

Daniel Potter is good-hearted, giving, and fun, yet these character traits only earn him heartache in his most personal relationships. He's the least stingy person, yet misfortune follows him like a curse. The book is narrated by his persnickety niece, Edna Earl, who is a quasi sister/mother figure and values her opinion on all things Uncle Daniel far more than I suspect he values it.

There are overtones of race, greed, gender, sexual desire, and family dynamic, but all told in a way that keeps you laughing. It's "As I Lay Dying" minus the parts that make you cringe or lead to weeks of dreams. It's most enjoyable. In a few days, I will Google to see what all I missed.
July 15,2025
... Show More

This is not a helpful review. It's a rant about my personal life. And really only able to be understood by my friends.


So, this was my Junior IB Summer Assigned Reading.


For those of you who are not International Baccalaureate Students, let me introduce you. IB is consuming. It's a love-hate relationship. You let it define who you are. It takes precedence. You get to know it like a friend. You bond with your peers in a communal commiseration. These people are now your family because you've done this together.


Coming home after a good day at school can be the most exhilarating high, while coming home after a bad day can make you feel pointless. IB is your validator. I am an IB student in the worst way possible. I eat, sleep, and breathe the work, grades, tests, late nights, stress, and success.


You believe in the IB program with all your heart. You believe in its benefits, rigor, and ability to prepare and teach FreeThinkers and HardWorkers.


The students in IB are like a proud mother and her young child. We brag with wallet photos, bumper stickers, and photos on the wall.


You know there are other ways to get a decent education, but you'll always have the biased view that your "kid" (IB) is the best. IB is just a notch above the rest. You wholeheartedly believe that IB is different and spectacular.


And so, because you take this opinion to heart, you let it consume you. You give in to its perils, downsides, and cons. Because it's all or nothing, and you're all in.


We are International Baccalaureate Students.


After that long intro, I come back to the point that this book was an IB chosen assigned book. I can't give an accurate rating or review because it's wrapped in orals, essays, tests, grades, and stress. I will only remember this book as that emotional segue back into it all. And that's all. /rantdone.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Edna Earle Ponder, the narrator of this story, manages the Beulah Hotel. It's a rather unexpected career for someone as xenophobic as she is. However, she didn't actually choose the hotel. Her Uncle Daniel bestowed it upon her. Uncle Daniel has two straightforward goals in his mind. Firstly, he desires to be the center of attention. Secondly, he aims to get people to like him, which he attempts to achieve by giving things away. Edna Earle, on her part, adheres to certain principles. She believes that everyone and everything has a place determined by tradition and inheritance. She thinks that one can and should be able to anticipate their behavior in this way. Also, she holds the view that you can't trust those who neither know nor respect your traditions. Her life's mission (despite occasional stray thoughts of getting married herself) is to protect and indulge Uncle Daniel.


The plot extracts comic value from the complications that this mission is bound to bring. This is especially true when Uncle Daniel decides to marry. Naturally, Edna Earle frequently has to handle people who don't behave as she believes they should. Despite the presence of comedy, the novel concludes on a surprisingly downbeat note. Edna Earle's hopes of marriage are dashed. The Ponder family is shrinking both in terms of offspring and influence. The town of Clay is also declining, now that a new highway has strangers speeding through it at high speed. And Uncle Daniel's giving habits ultimately end up causing a rift between him and others rather than fostering friendships, leaving him lonely.


Readers might not feel sorry to witness the disappearance of the Ponder way of life. Nevertheless, the ambiguously dark implications here set Eudora Welty apart from numerous "southern cozy" writers whom she was a major inspiration for. (For example, I've criticized some of them in reviews of Fanny Flagg.)

July 15,2025
... Show More
I discovered this novella about Southern eccentrics to be truly charming and engaging.

The story, which was narrated by Edna Earle, the owner of the Beulah Hotel, was filled with some unexpected twists.

Edna Earle was known as the smartest woman in town and was also the niece of Uncle Daniel, the oddest and yet most generous man in their small Mississippi town.

The audio version of the novella was read by Sally Darling, whose narration added an extra layer of charm and authenticity to the story.

Overall, it was a delightful read that kept me hooked from beginning to end and provided a fascinating glimpse into the lives and personalities of the unique characters that inhabited this Southern town.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The story, narrated in the voice of his niece, centers around Uncle Daniel Ponder. He is a kind and open-hearted man from a good family. His sole delight in life is sharing stories with people, whether they are friends or strangers, and bestowing gifts upon them. These gifts range from a house, an orchard, a trip to Memphis, a ham, to just about anything one can conceive.

As he resides in a small town, the people keep an eye on Uncle Daniel, ensuring he comes to no harm. He gets married once, but the marriage fails. Then, he marries Bonnie Dee Peacock, a young girl who can hardly read or write. However, one thing leads to another, and suddenly Uncle Daniel finds himself living in town while his young bride has taken over the entire mansion for herself.

Eudora Welty masterfully captures the voice of the niece, and through it, the world of Clay County in the 1940s. In this era, idiosyncrasies are both expected and tolerated, and twists of fate result in unimagined consequences. The folks come together to love their own. This is a quick yet enjoyable read that encapsulates an entire world, crafted by one of the great writers of the last century.
July 15,2025
... Show More
After reading the first two paragraphs, I couldn't help but think, "This isn't a novel. This character, Edna Earle Ponder, should be on a stage." As it turns out, others had the same thought shortly after it was published. The actress who portrayed Edna Earle even won a Tony.

What is it about the South that gives birth to these eccentric characters in literature? Or is literature simply mirroring the culture, where eccentrics are as plentiful as kudzu? In any event, the eccentrics are in full bloom here. There's Uncle Daniel, a bit simple but the kindest man you'll ever meet. Then there's Edna Earle, Daniel's niece, who owns the town's hotel and has a finger in almost everything, with something to say about everything. Bonnie Dea Peacock, Daniel's very young wife, is mature beyond her years and seems to be the polar opposite of Daniel. And my favorite, Daniel's cook, who neglects her cooking to go gallivanting around in the Studebaker.

The final scenes in the courtroom were both funny and farcical, but something about them just didn't sit well with me. Maybe it was the jarring transition between Edna Earle's monologue and the courtroom narrative. Or perhaps it was the difficulty in figuring out exactly what happened and why Welty made it so convoluted. I found myself scratching my head, trying to make sense of it all.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have an absolute passion for the fact that this book concludes with you, the reader, sitting down at the table with Edna and Uncle Daniel for dinner.

The entire book gave the impression of a gossipy afternoon spent with an aunt, gathered around the kitchen table, sipping lemonade while the cicadas chirped in the air.

So many aspects of Uncle Daniel brought to mind E. Rucker Blakeslee in Cold Sassy Tree. The writing style was comparable, although not as comical. I truly relished the illustrations by Joe Krush.

Some of my favorite quotes include:

"It's always taken a lot out of me, being smart." --Edna

"He loved happiness like I love tea."

"...in plenty of marriages there's three--three all your life. Because nearly everybody's got somebody."

"Don't be so small-town."

"but that day his hair wasn't much longer than the fuzz of a peach. Uncle Daniel still keeps it like that--he loves himself that way."

"I'm a great reader that never has time to read."

"It was hot as fluzions."

These quotes add depth and charm to the story, making it even more engaging and memorable.

The combination of the wonderful writing, relatable characters, and beautiful illustrations makes this book a must-read for anyone who enjoys a heartwarming and thought-provoking tale.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Ponder Heart by Eudora Welty is a captivating tale. Sometimes titled just Ponder, it introduces us to Uncle Daniel Ponder, a wealthy man in rural Mississippi in 1922. Thanks to his inheritance from his father, he lives a life surrounded by family and community.

This was a time without the distractions of television, computers, and the internet. The story is narrated by his niece, Edna Earle Ponder. Uncle Daniel Ponder had a penchant for talking and giving things away, including his money, which had a significant impact on his neighbors.

He was a kind-hearted man but a bit slow, requiring constant supervision from his family to prevent him from parting with all his wealth and possessions. His marriage to 17-year-old beauty Bonnie Dee Peacock was a tumultuous one, filled with running away, institutional commitment, and deception.

The first part of the story delves into the people and relationships, while the second part features a delightfully humorous court trial over the death (or was it murder?) of Ponder's beloved Bonnie Dee. I thoroughly enjoyed Welty's masterful use of language and Southern idioms, and especially her unique brand of humor.

It made the story come alive and kept me engaged from beginning to end.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Brilliant Southern small town dialog, all of which comes from the mouth of our narrator, Miss Edna Earle Ponder.

She is one of the two remaining Ponders in Clay, Mississippi around 1950. Could irony have ever been better presented? Miss Edna Earle tells the story of her Uncle Daniel Ponder and reveals what is happening in their little world.

The Ponder family represents the old South small town aristocracy, but by the time of this story, they are declining at a rapid pace.

Uncle Daniel is regarded as “simple.” He loves everyone and desires everyone to love him in return. It is obvious that he doesn't have the prejudices of the old South – he is too kind-hearted to notice them. Money means nothing to him; in fact, he can't be prevented from giving it away. Miss Edna Earle tenaciously holds on for the love of Uncle Daniel.

We hear everything from the narrator. She witnesses everything slipping away, including the status, the money, and the secure and rigid social conditions. Edna Earle surely recognizes white trash when she sees it. Well, bless their hearts.

The trial features the funniest courtroom scene ever devised. It is truly amazing.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.