Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 96 votes)
5 stars
31(32%)
4 stars
37(39%)
3 stars
28(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
96 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Miss Eudora's book is truly a remarkable feat.

In just 24 hours within the pages of this book, she manages to pack in more experiences and stories than most people could ever hope to fit into an entire lifetime.

The narrative is framed by a family reunion and a homecoming, which serve as the backdrop for a plethora of tales. Some of these stories are brand new, while others are told year after year, as is the custom in many families.

We are introduced to a young bride who is engaged in a losing battle as she tries to pry her husband away from his large and boisterous family. Meanwhile, the husband himself is facing his own set of challenges as he engages in a series of losing battles with the town storekeeper.

And then there's the incident with the car in the tree, which adds an element of absurdity to the already rich tapestry of the story.

As you settle into Eudora's world, be prepared to be entertained and to find yourself laughing and smiling at the many absurdities of life. This book is highly recommended for anyone looking for a lighthearted and engaging read that will leave them with a smile on their face.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This took years for me to finish, but it was well worth the effort.

And there's truly nothing I could say about it that would surpass what Reynolds Price wrote to Eudora Welty when he first read it in 1970. He said, "that it's a very great book, that increasingly I read it with a kind of panic of suffocation in its beauty, richness, strangeness (but suffocated in pleasure, excitement, gratitude - a response to plenitude of a sort I've previously only felt in reply to music)."

The surest test of that, for me (of its bigness, durability), is that all through I kept asking, `What's it about? What's it about?' And ultimately responding: "it's about life, merely - all imaginable life." (Quotation from Suzanne Marrs' Eudora Welty: A Biography)

This work is not just a simple creation. It embodies the author's painstaking efforts and profound insights over the years. The description by Reynolds Price vividly captures the essence and魅力 of this book. Its beauty, richness, and strangeness are so captivating that it makes the reader feel a sense of panic and suffocation, yet it is a suffocation filled with pleasure, excitement, and gratitude.

The question "What's it about?" that keeps arising during the reading process reflects the complexity and depth of the book. And the answer "it's about life, merely - all imaginable life" reveals the broad scope and profound meaning that the author intends to convey. This book is like a mirror that reflects the various aspects of life, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding and appreciation of the world around them.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It's truly difficult to envision another writer, apart from Faulkner, who is as deeply engrossed in the past as Eudora Welty. Her exploration of the past isn't an isolated one; rather, it continuously enriches and imparts meaning to the present.

The novel commences in the present (the 1930s) at a family reunion in Mississippi to pay homage to 90-year-old Granny Vaughan. She is surrounded by children, grandchildren, and friends from the neighboring Banner community. However, one person is notably absent - grandson Jack Renfro, who has just been released from the state penitentiary at Parchment Farm. He had engaged in a dispute with a local storekeeper over stealing a safe. There are mitigating circumstances, and the details are elaborated in meandering stories by those present, all of whom believe Jack is innocent.

Jack was sentenced by Judge Moody, who arrives on the scene after a car wreck that leaves his vehicle precariously teetering on the edge of a nearby cliff. The entire novel unfolds over a span of just a few days, and the ongoing uncertainty regarding the automobile's fate, in a sense, represents the equally indeterminate future of this closely-knit community.

Jack eventually does make an appearance and is reunited with his wife, Gloria, and their baby girl. Gloria was the local teacher until she gave up teaching to marry Jack, and in a way, betrayed the legacy of her predecessor, Miss Julia, who worked tirelessly to bring enlightenment and learning to Banner Land. She passes away, and the novel concludes with her funeral and burial. Did she succeed in improving the community as she had hoped? The results are ambiguous, as are Gloria's efforts to inspire Jack to have a broader perspective on life beyond simply continuing the work on the family farm. Jack, despite his stubbornness, also possesses some good qualities that are firmly rooted in a strong sense of personal loyalty and generosity.

The "losing battles" mentioned in the title are numerous. Always lurking in the distant past is the Civil War and the impact it had on the self-esteem of southerners. In the more recent past are the people who pass away, a battle that all humans ultimately lose. Jack loses his battle with the legal system and ends up in prison. Teacher Julia's struggle to open the insular and closed minds of the people in Banner could potentially be regarded as a loss.

What makes Welty such an outstanding writer is her ability to perceive the paradoxes at play in life. Every descriptive detail in her work serves a purpose. The novel concludes at the graveside service for Miss Julia. While death is present in the cemetery, so too are natural life and abundance. Thousands of grasshoppers emerge, along with countless blooming flowers, and streams of owls (symbolizing wisdom?) soar up from an old cedar tree. This profusion of life, constantly emerging from death, is emblematic of the people.

Gloria often finds herself irritated by what she deems the backwardness of Jack's family. At one point, Gloria has a vision of living alone with Jack, without anyone else to bother them. But this book is filled with people everywhere, on all sides. There is no escaping them, and perhaps there shouldn't be any hope of doing so. A sense of relatedness, of living in a community, of honoring the experiences of the past (the very purpose of the family reunion) - is that really such a bad thing?

Nearly a century after Welty's 1930s Banner, suicides have significantly increased in the United States. What is a suicide if not the ultimate expression of despair at being alone? America has advanced a great deal in terms of material prosperity since Welty's Banner Land, but it has also lost a great deal. In the end, the country's history is paradoxical - winning many things, yet also losing many. Welty's great strength lies in her ability to discover meaning and complexity in ordinary lives.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Abandondo. I lost the battle to read. It seems that no matter how hard I try, I just can't seem to overcome this challenge. Reading has always been a struggle for me, and I often find myself getting distracted or losing interest within minutes of starting a book.


I have tried various techniques to improve my reading skills, such as setting aside specific times for reading, finding books that interest me, and taking breaks when I feel overwhelmed. However, none of these methods have been very successful.


Maybe I just need to accept that reading is not my strong suit and focus on other areas where I excel. But still, a part of me feels disappointed and frustrated that I can't seem to master this fundamental skill. Abandonondo. I guess this is the end of my battle with reading for now.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Winning While Losing

Published in 1970, "Losing Battles" was the fourth of Eudora Welty's (1909 -- 2001) five novels and her first since 1954. Welty spent fifteen years working on and off again on this novel, with long intervals of inactivity to care for her mother and brothers.

Unlike her other novels, "Losing Battles" is lengthy. When her publisher demanded significant cuts and edits, Welty took her manuscript elsewhere and had the book published as she desired. The novel received great critical and popular acclaim upon publication.

The story is set in 1931, during the Depression, in the hills of northeast Mississippi near a town called Banner. The scene is a hardscrabble farm where a family reunion is held to celebrate the 90th birthday of the family matriarch, Elvira Jordan Vaughn or "Granny".

Within the year, Granny's husband had died and her children also are dead. Granny's six living grandchildren (one is deceased) and their spouses attend, as do five of Granny's great-grandchildren of her granddaughter Beulah and Beulah's husband, Ralph Renfro. Many other guests attend the reunion, some uninvited and by surprise.

The major character is Beulah and Ralph's oldest son Jack. Jack had been serving two years at the notorious Parchman prison and escaped one day ahead of his release to attend the reunion. He has a young wife, Gloria, who had been teaching school, and a two-year-old baby daughter, Lady May Renfro, whom Jack meets for the first time at the reunion and instantly adores.

The book consists of a series of short stories told by the family about themselves and others. The stories are detailed and recounted in dialogue, developing the many characters and their surroundings intimately. Welty presents these poor characters and their difficult lives unsentimentally but with love.

Many interrelated themes appear throughout the book rather than a developed plot. A major theme is Jack's return from Parchman and his attempt to establish himself. His wife Gloria, raised in an orphanage and of uncertain parentage, struggles with her feelings for Jack's family.

A good deal of the book concerns a character who does not appear, a long-time and rigorous schoolteacher, Julia Mortimer. County Judge Oscar Moody, who sentenced Jack to Parchman, and his wife Maud Eva also find their way unwillingly to the reunion.

The quotations from Maxwell and Welty in this review are from a collection of their correspondence, "What there is to Say we have Said" edited by Suzanne Marrs.

Overall, "Losing Battles" is full of Welty's sharp eye for detail, masterful storytelling, and comedy in the pathos of the everyday. With patience, reading this book will be a joy.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I found this to be an extremely tedious read.

To my great disappointment, this is regarded as one of her finest books. It was her debut published novel, yet by no means her first foray into writing.

The employment of the backwoods Mississippi dialect proved to be excessive for my taste, despite its authenticity in characterizing the individuals.

Reluctantly, I award this a meager two stars.

It seems that what might have been a captivating story was somewhat marred by the overuse of the dialect.

Perhaps for some, this unique linguistic style adds charm and depth, but for me, it detracted from the overall reading experience.

Nonetheless, it is important to note that the author's talent and potential are still evident, and I look forward to seeing how she evolves in her future works.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly had a strong desire to read it.

However, after making two attempts, I am now deciding to give up.

I have made up my mind to try another book written by Eudora Welty. In fact, I haven't read any of her works so far.

During my exploration, I discovered that this particular book is regarded as one of the most difficult ones to read.

Maybe, at some point in the future, after reading several other books by Welty, I will gather enough courage and determination to give "Losing Battles" another try.

I believe that with more experience and a better understanding of her writing style, I might be able to appreciate and fully engage with this challenging piece of literature.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This woman writes wonderfully.

It's not a book that can be read in one go, but once you're in it, it's not easy to get out.

The characters are anthological, eccentric, and some situations are the most disparate.

All of this is not without humor and a hardness characteristic of the lives of the protagonists, but narrated with sensitivity and tenderness.

Defeats that turn into victories because that's how it has to be, that's who they are.

"It seems that what one can lose is endless and yet, despite everything, one still keeps living."

The story unfolds in a way that keeps the reader hooked from the beginning.

The author's writing style is engaging and draws you into the world of the characters.

You can feel their emotions and experiences as if you were right there with them.

The book explores themes of loss, perseverance, and the human spirit.

It shows that even in the face of difficulties, there is always hope and the possibility of finding victory.

Overall, it's a captivating read that will leave you thinking long after you've finished the last page.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Welty is truly a master when it comes to turning a phrase. Her writing is so rich and evocative that it has the power to transport readers into a whole new world.

Not only is her language beautiful, but her characters are also full and fascinating. Each one is unique, with their own distinct personalities, motives, and flaws.

She has a remarkable ability to bring them to life on the page, making them seem like real people that we could actually meet.

Whether it's the complex relationships between her characters or the vivid descriptions of the settings in which they live, Welty's work is always engaging and thought-provoking.

She is a writer who has left an indelible mark on the literary world, and her books will continue to be cherished by readers for generations to come.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Eudora Welty's masterful use of dialogue and storytelling truly breathed life into this family reunion.

It seemed that the most beloved family members were those with the wildest stories. Even though Jack, having returned "from the pen," wasn't seeking another tale to tell, his family eagerly encouraged him to get into more mischief. Welty effortlessly conveys the comforting yet confining nature of a tightly-knit community or family.

Jack's wife, Gloria, struggles to fit in. She deems herself "too good" for Jack's "ignorant" family and the town of Banner itself. However, she also stubbornly resists becoming a teacher, as her mentor, Miss Julia, desires. Jack's family is initially slow to embrace Gloria until they start to suspect a possible blood relation.

Moreover, this depression-era family saga explores themes of aging, reconciliation, forgiveness, and frugality. When the family members leave and Granny is left alone in her chair, interjecting with pleas like "stay" and "I never said I wanted you to go," one can sense her profound loneliness and neglect.

I wish to give "Losing Battles" a higher rating, but Welty's excessive use of similes and metaphors proved challenging to adapt to. I'm also somewhat perplexed about how Judge Moody's car ended up hanging from a cliff on Banner Top, and that part of the story felt a bit lackluster. Nevertheless, I adored the story's meandering pace and was completely captivated by the characters. Welty's portrayal of rural Mississippi is vivid and enchanting.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have a deep affection for Eudora Welty, and thus I truly desired to have a profound love for this particular novel. However, to my great disappointment, this book failed to meet my expectations.

The individual yarns or stories within the novel were indeed quite funny and demonstrated a remarkable level of masterful craftsmanship. The author's ability to create engaging and entertaining short segments was evident.

Nevertheless, when considering the plot of the novel as a whole, it unfortunately dragged. The overall narrative seemed to lack a certain momentum or drive that would have kept me more fully engaged from start to finish. It felt as if the story was meandering rather than progressing in a more purposeful and captivating manner.

Despite the enjoyable aspects of the individual yarns, the sluggishness of the overall plot prevented me from having the kind of unreserved love for this novel that I had hoped for.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I gave up after 25 pages.

It was quite evident to me that I wasn't going to have any liking for this particular novel. It committed the very act that irritates me the most in the realm of novels. It introduced an excessive number of people in an extremely rapid manner, without providing any sort of signposts or indications as to who was of significance and who wasn't.

Out of curiosity, I decided to look online and discovered that this wasn't just a personal gripe of mine. In fact, it turned out to be a rather common criticism leveled against this book. Apparently, it features a whopping 28 characters who all make their appearance at this family reunion right in the opening pages. And, as I can only imagine, they simply engage in discussions about their lives for a couple of days. It all sounds rather dull and uninteresting, to be honest. Yawn.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.