Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 96 votes)
5 stars
31(32%)
4 stars
37(39%)
3 stars
28(29%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
96 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Ostensibly, this book is set within a time frame of less than two days in a rural county of Northeast Mississippi during the Depression.

However, in reality, it unfolds within the memories, tales, lies, and reluctant truths of the extended Vaughn/Renfro family over the past few decades as they gather for a family reunion.

The story is further enriched by the farcical elements introduced by a group of misfits who are attempting to retrieve a car that is precariously hanging on a tree above a river cliff.

The combination of these elements results in a comic masterpiece that not only entertains but also delves deep into the complex dynamics of family relationships and the power of memory.

Readers are drawn into a world where the past and present collide, and where the characters must confront their own demons and come to terms with the truth.

Overall, this book is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a good laugh and a thought-provoking exploration of the human condition.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Well written but required quite a bit of concentration.

The author's use of language was truly masterful, yet it demanded a great deal of focus from the reader.

I found myself becoming tired with the constant use of similes.

While they added a certain charm and vividness to the text, their frequency began to wear on me after a while.

Nevertheless, I am glad I read the book.

It provided me with a unique literary experience and allowed me to appreciate the author's talent.

However, I will probably not read another long work by Ms. Welty.

The combination of the need for intense concentration and the overuse of similes has left me a bit hesitant to embark on another lengthy journey through her writing.

Perhaps I will explore some of her shorter works in the future to see if they offer a different reading experience.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A hard book to get into, largely because the first page or so contains some of Welty's worst writing. There is an over-reliance on similes and an overall forced feel.

The next 20 pages introduce the reader to so many characters so quickly that it's easy to get bogged down. However, after this rough start, the book gets quite good.

Even though not a whole lot happens, as the whole novel covers just a day (or two?) of a massive depression-era family reunion. It's not quite the masterpiece that Eudora Welty perhaps wanted it to be, but it's still required reading for fans of hers.

Its evocation of a festive, dusty, hot August day, tinged with sadness and strife, is truly unparalleled. The detailed descriptions of the setting and the complex relationships among the characters make this a memorable read.

Despite its flaws, the book has its own charm and offers valuable insights into the human condition during a difficult time in history.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Funny but seems disorganized and even manic at times. This description can apply to many situations or people. For example, a comedian on stage might be extremely funny, but their act could appear disorganized, with jokes and skits thrown together in a seemingly random way. At times, their energy level might even seem manic, as if they are on a wild ride of hilarity.


Similarly, a person in a social setting might be the life of the party, cracking jokes and making everyone laugh. However, their behavior could also seem a bit disorganized, with them flitting from one conversation to another and perhaps even getting a bit too carried away. Their manic energy might be contagious, but it could also be a bit overwhelming for some.


While being funny and having a bit of disorganization and mania can add to the excitement and entertainment value of a situation or person, it's important to also have some sense of balance and control. Otherwise, things could get out of hand and become more of a liability than an asset.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I can't remember it clearly, so I only give it 2 stars.

This might be due to a variety of reasons. Maybe the experience or information was not significant enough to leave a lasting impression. It could also be that I was preoccupied with other things at the time, causing my memory to be less than perfect.

However, just because I can't remember it doesn't mean it didn't have any value. There could still be aspects of it that were interesting or useful, even if they didn't stick in my mind.

In the future, I will try to be more focused and attentive when experiencing new things, in order to improve my memory and give a more accurate assessment.

Maybe with better concentration and a more active approach, I will be able to remember more details and give a higher rating next time.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Suddenly, the world of moonlight vanished;

hard lights like the clang of a shovel appeared on the ceiling of the porch and the passageway, piercing through the entire house and leaving them on an island on the black earth, in the middle of nowhere, with no one else to turn to but themselves.

The story told by Eudora is like that layer of dust and deterioration that shrouds the old family photographs. It is difficult to fully immerse oneself in those stories that, due to the complexity of society and culture, seem archaic and distant to us; cognitively or sensorially, we lack something. Nevertheless, there is something beautiful and masterful in Eudora's way of writing. Something simple that brings us closer and unites us. I will continue to read more, delving beneath that thick layer of dust, tearing until I find the reflection of myself.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I thought this book was just okay.

If we had the option to choose half stars, I would definitely give it a 2 1/2.

At the beginning, I really had a hard time getting into it. The conversation was rather complex and it was easy to get confused.

However, on the other hand, it was a very colorful cultural presentation.

The style of writing reminded me of "stream of consciousness", which was kind of like a long "run on" sentence.

Despite the initial difficulties, it did provide a good glimpse of the old rural South.

We could clearly see their unique mannerisms and the interesting vernacular they used.

Overall, it was an okay read, but not something that really blew me away.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Wow!

This is an extremely difficult book to read.

Although it does possess some rather funny aspects, it is kind of hard to follow the storyline.

I have already put it in the far back of the bookshelf.

For the time being, I have to give it a two-star rating.

The simple reason is that I just can't seem to finish it!

Maybe in the future, when I have more time and a better state of mind, I will try to pick it up again and see if I can understand it better.

But for now, it remains a challenging read that I have yet to conquer.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A Southern classic.

It is a remarkable work that spans over 200 pages, meticulously documenting a birthday party that not only commemorates a special occasion but also rehashes the rich and complex family history.

The narrative then seamlessly transitions back to the current times, revealing that, in many ways, not much has changed.

It is truly hard to match Welty's descriptive powers. She has an uncanny ability to portray the beauty and goodness that exists in the South with equal skill as she describes the pettiness and flaws.

Her words bring the characters and the settings to life, allowing the reader to fully immerse themselves in the story.

This work is当之无愧 a classic in southern literature, standing the test of time and captivating readers with its vivid portrayal of the South and its people.

It is a must-read for anyone interested in exploring the unique culture and history of the southern United States.

July 15,2025
... Show More
What a whirlwind!

I found this book slowed my reading, just to try to keep track of everything going on. It's truly crazy, considering the book only covers a day and the following morning. Ms. Welty didn't leave many moments for contemplative quiet. There's so much happening and so many details to take in. I wonder if that's why that one uncle left town - for some space with his thoughts. Maybe he needed to escape the chaos and busyness that was constantly surrounding him in the story.

Anyone who likes gossipy rambles shouldn't have any trouble getting into this. The book is filled with all kinds of interesting tidbits and stories that keep you engaged from start to finish. It's like eavesdropping on a group of friends sharing their latest news and rumors. And it's funny too! There are some really humorous moments that will make you laugh out loud. Overall, it's a great read that will keep you entertained and on the edge of your seat.
July 15,2025
... Show More

“Yep, that’s that Yazoo clay.” This is a Southerner’s simple explanation of the common destruction caused by the continual movement of Mississippi’s soil. If you weren’t from ‘these parts’ and didn't understand why a house leaned or a pool held no water, you might also have difficulty with Eudora Welty’s “Losing Battles”.


Eudora’s first novel, written very late after she had long established herself and her readers in that unique prose style of describing language, characters, and human nature in Southern relationships, is a work that took the author decades. It is the ‘Morgana’ theme gathered round a daylong family reunion, also the celebrating of Granny’s 90th birthday.


I look upon it as a beautiful benediction given by an author ‘comfortable in her writer’s skin’, speaking with a slightly fading voice of the images that gave birth to her many most popular pieces. However, I rate this work low because family strife is not a subject that thrills me, no matter the skill of the writer.


I do not suggest for a moment that only those enthralled followers of Eudora’s writings read this novel. I encourage all comers to read all of Eudora’s writings. However, understanding Yazoo clay will be easier than grasping the dialogue and observations in “Losing Battles”. Readers new to Miss Eudora would do best by reading her “Petrified Man” or “Why I Live at the P.O.” before embarking on this novel.

July 15,2025
... Show More

There is a train track, and on this very track, a Coca Cola truck met with a rather unfortunate incident. It was hit by the Nashville Rocket. The situation was quite a spectacle. No one seemed to have a particular affinity for her, perhaps due to the nature of this unexpected event. However, there is the famous Wodehouse who once said, "he gave me a look that would have split logs in the teak forests of Borneo." This quote seems almost relevant in this context, as if to emphasize the intensity of the moment or the impact that the event had. It's as if the force of the collision and the circumstances surrounding it could be compared to the powerful image described by Wodehouse. The scene on the train track after the incident was one of chaos and uncertainty, with the fate of the Coca Cola truck and its contents hanging in the balance.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.