Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
27(27%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
39(39%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I spent a significant amount of time in my car last weekend, and during that time, I listened to an audio book.

It truly was a remarkable way to pass the hours. The story delved into the complex realm of family dynamics and extended family relationships.

Specifically, it focused on Aaron and his second wife, Julia, who were taking care of Aaron's first wife, who had suffered brain damage as a result of an accident.

Interspersed throughout the narrative were political discussions among the relatives regarding issues that were of great importance in the 1960s.

This book had the potential to earn a five-star rating if there had been more in-depth exploration of Madeline's life. However, all things considered, it was an engaging and interesting story that centered around love and acceptance.

It offered a unique perspective on family life and the challenges that can arise within it, while also touching on broader political and social issues of the era.

The characters were well-developed, and the plot was engaging enough to keep me hooked from start to finish.

Overall, it was a great audio book that I would highly recommend to others.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is the story about Madeline when she was young. In fact, she remained in a state of youth for a very long time, well into her 70s. The narrator of the story is Mac Maciver. As a child, he thought that Madeline was his older sister. However, Madeline was actually his father's first wife. She had suffered a head injury in a bicycle accident within a year of marrying Mac's father. As a result, she now has the mental capabilities of a seven-year-old and no memory of her marriage.

Madeline's family was unable to assist Mac. After a period of time, he obtained a divorce and remarried. He and his second wife took care of Madeline with love and devotion for the rest of her life.

However, that is only one half of the novel. The divide between the two sides of Mac's extended family over the Vietnam War seemed, at least to me, to sometimes overtake the story of Madeline. The story alternated back and forth between Madeline and the war. This may pose a problem for some readers, but I thought it was a rather good read.

It presented a complex and multi-faceted narrative that explored not only the personal relationships and struggles within the family but also the broader social and historical context of the Vietnam War. The contrast between the innocence and simplicity of Madeline and the chaos and turmoil of the war added depth and poignancy to the story. Overall, it was an engaging and thought-provoking novel that kept me hooked from beginning to end.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Um, I truly adored this book. It's an older novel from 2006. I recall reading her first book in the eighties and then never picking up another one of hers. I wasn't quite sure what initially drew me to this particular one. Oh, but then I remembered. Traumatic brain injury. It's a significant element in the story.


And while it's very important to this narrative, this is an even more expansive novel. Is it about the tenacity of family?


I don't really want to disclose too much, except for this: it's a quiet novel and not for those who are solely focused on the plot. It's entirely a character-driven novel with exquisitely beautiful writing. I actually found myself laughing at times, but that's probably just my own idiosyncrasy. And there were moments when I felt like crying.


It reminded me a bit of a secular Marilynne Robinson novel. I will always remember, as a young mom who managed to get a two-hour break at Starbucks on a Saturday afternoon, finishing Robinson's HOME while sitting in a Starbucks' chair with my Pike Place coffee, gulping it down in an unflattering way so as not to cry aloud in public over the sheer beauty of the book.


This novel was like that. I finished it, and I think it's truly amazing. I was on the verge of tears.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm not entirely certain how I felt about this particular book. Right from the start, it managed to draw me in with its interesting story and good writing.

However, as I delved deeper into it, it seemed to start rambling. I kept reading, hoping to find the point, but I never really did. Maybe, just maybe, that was the intended point all along.

Despite this, the book was beautifully written. The story about the family was truly compelling. It had the power to keep me engaged, even when I was a bit confused about its overall message.

I found myself invested in the characters and their relationships, which is a testament to the author's skill. Overall, it was a bit of a mixed bag, but still a book that I'm glad I read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Another excellent work by Jane Hamilton!

This story delves into the nature of love and the complex relationships within a family that has been shaped by curious circumstances and a rich history. It is told through the voice of the son, who is now middle-aged.

The narrator's father got married at a young age to a beautiful woman named Madeline. However, soon after their marriage, Madeline suffered a head trauma in a bike accident, which left her with the mental capacity of a 6-year-old.

The father then re-marries, and his new wife takes on the challenging task of caring for his ex-wife while also raising two children.

As is often the case, the relationships in this family are complicated. But what stands out is the overwhelming impression of tenderness that pervades the story. After reading so many family psychodramas where everything seems so difficult, this story provides a nice respite.

It offers a refreshing perspective on love, family, and the power of human connection.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Aaron and Madeline Maciver embarked on their married life, much like numerous other couples of their era, with the belief that they had a plethora of years stretching out before them.

However, tragedy struck one fateful day when Madeline was severely injured in a bicycling accident. The accident left her brain damaged, reducing her to a childlike state.

Following a period of rehabilitation, Aaron developed a connection with Julia, the nurse who had been assisting in Madeline's care. Their relationship gradually evolved into a marriage, after Aaron ended his marriage to Madeline.

The most unexpected aspect was Aaron and Julia's decision to bring Madeline into their home and care for her as if she were their child.

Mac Maciver serves as the narrator of this family saga, seamlessly moving back and forth in time to chronicle the stories that highlight family moments, the bonds that unite people, and the flaws that often tear them apart. Set against the backdrop of the times, ranging from the Viet Nam war to the Iraq conflict, Mac introduces a diverse cast of family members, from Cousin Buddy to his own wife and daughters many years later.

Throughout the years, Madeline remains a constant presence, although friends and neighbors find the family's dynamics at best strange and at worst bizarre.

The questions that arise are: How does Julia manage to cope with the "extra" wife in her home? Is her inclination to control things a means of coping, or is there something more to it? What impact will a romance for Madeline have on altering the dynamics of this unusual family?

Jane Hamilton's prose is truly remarkable, vividly revealing the emotions, the setting, and the characterizations with great clarity. In this excerpt, Mac and his sister Louise are returning from a visit to their home, during which certain events have compelled them to see what they had previously failed to realize.

"Below us as we lifted off lay the flat grid of the gray city, the desolation of the urban landscape. We were leaving it behind as we'd done before, but this time was different; this time the entire scrim had been pulled away from the home front, and we could see the outer world that all along had been part of us. I would have liked to return to our cozy, selfish ignorance, but that seemed no longer possible; from now on we'd walk hand in hand with our entitlements, nursing them along, feeding them up...."

While I thoroughly enjoyed the characterizations, the prose, and the unusual plot of "When Madeline Was Young," I found myself becoming easily distracted and losing focus as the narrator rambled and meandered in his attempt to tell the stories of his family. Some of these stories seemed rather irrelevant. Consequently, I am awarding this book three stars.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The fact that the premise of this novel is enough to make most readers uncomfortable is precisely the reason that compelled me to keep turning the pages.

I am fully aware that I could never, under any circumstances, be willing or capable of putting myself in the shoes of Aaron's second wife. Accepting the presence of his first wife, who had endured a traumatic brain injury, would be an extremely challenging and perhaps even an impossible task for me.

To me, and it is obvious to Aaron's sister as well, this was a truly awkward and somewhat unhealthy arrangement. Despite the admirable fact that they were both willing to sacrifice many of the intimacies of their own marriage, it still felt rather strange.

Although Madeline was not the focal point of the story, she was indeed a central figure whose presence had a profound influence and impact on the lives of all those around her - son and daughter, cousins, neighbors, and other family members.

Overall, I firmly believed that this novel was worth reading, as it presented a complex and thought-provoking situation that made me reflect on the nature of relationships and sacrifices.
July 15,2025
... Show More

A family with truly fascinating dynamics presents a captivating story. The father's first wife unfortunately endures severe brain damage shortly after they become newlyweds. Remarkably, he and his second wife decide to keep her in their household as they raise their two children. Astonishingly, these children view her as an older sister. The majority of the novel is set during the tumultuous Vietnam War, and within its pages, there is an in-depth exploration and extensive discussion of the pros and cons of this war. The family's experiences are intertwined with the larger historical context, adding a layer of complexity and depth to the narrative. As the story unfolds, readers are drawn into the lives of these characters, experiencing their joys, sorrows, and the challenges they face in a war-torn world.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The original article seems to be rather short and perhaps a bit unclear. However, I'll do my best to rewrite and expand it while keeping in mind the requirement of adding line breaks and using English.


I was attempting a task, but I found it extremely challenging. In fact, I couldn't even finish it. The difficulty level was much higher than I had anticipated. I tried my hardest, putting in all my efforts and concentration, but still, I fell short. It was quite frustrating to see that I couldn't complete what I had set out to do. Maybe I needed more time, or perhaps I lacked the necessary skills or knowledge. But regardless of the reason, the fact remained that I couldn't even finish the task. I knew I had to figure out a way to improve and overcome this obstacle in the future.



I hope this meets your requirements. If you have any further instructions or if there's anything specific you'd like me to change or add, please let me know.
July 15,2025
... Show More
When Madeline was young,

the world around her seemed to be filled with a whole lot of nothing that had little to do with her.

To be honest, I initially thought the premise was a bit wonky.

The relationship between Madeline and a couple of the main characters was rather complex, and I don't want to spoil it here.

The family dynamics were somewhat interesting, but their political spoutings were not.

If this book had been another 50 pages longer, I probably would have given up on it early on.

It's definitely not Jane Hamilton's best work by any means.

The story seemed to lack a certain depth and coherence that would have made it more engaging.

However, there were still some redeeming qualities, such as the author's beautiful prose and the vivid descriptions of the setting.

Overall, it was an okay read, but not one that I would highly recommend.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly appreciated the way she depicted growing up with a mentally challenged "sibling". It was a unique and interesting perspective that added depth to the story. However, I was slightly put off by the way they coddled and babied her. It felt a bit overdone and unrealistic to me.

On the other hand, I was rather disappointed in the big family drama. It didn't seem very intense or engaging. In my opinion, every family has differences and disagreements, especially when it comes to politics. So, this particular aspect of the story didn't really stand out or make a lasting impression on me.

Overall, while there were some elements that I liked, there were also some areas that could have been improved upon. I still think the story had potential, but it needed a bit more polish and refinement to really shine.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was my one-day-book this week.

I happened to notice it on the high-demand shelf at the library. The moment I saw it, I snatched it up immediately. The reason was simple. I have had the pleasure of reading some of her other books before, and they were all truly wonderful.

This particular book, I really enjoyed it a great deal. What impressed me the most was the way the mother-son relationship developed throughout the story. It was so细腻 and touching.

As I was reading, I found myself constantly thinking about the characters and their experiences. I can't imagine myself ever having Julia's strength. She was so勇敢 and determined in the face of all the difficulties and challenges.

This book has definitely left a deep impression on me, and I would highly recommend it to anyone who loves a good story.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.