“All New People” is not a book that will appeal to every reader, yet it had a profound impact on me. Some might view the novel, which was published in 2016, as rather depressing. In the early stages, I abandoned any expectation of a traditional plot with a neatly tied-up ending. At times, I found myself asking, “Why am I reading this book? Where is it headed?” However, Lamott’s engaging prose, quirky sense of humor, and astute life lessons would draw me back in. Eventually, I surrendered and let the book consume me.
The story commences with the protagonist, Nanny Goodman, as an adult, visiting a hypnotist to confront her pain and anxiety. This marks the beginning of the reader’s cinematic journey back in time, starting with Nanny’s childhood. The novel concludes with a twenty-something Nanny still grappling with difficulties but somehow clinging to a glimmer of hope.
LaMott’s description of the Goodman family dining in a restaurant had me in stitches. At the neighboring table sat the White family, whose daughter the young Nanny idolized. “After dinner, my father bared his teeth so my mother could inspect for trapped food, and I remember blushing, wanting to die of shame. Mr. and Mrs. White had to avert their eyes from my chimpanzee parent, who would next be raking through each other’s hair with long shaggy fingers, rooting around for lice.” I also adored her portrayal of the family dogs: “The two dogs since had manifest all of my father’s compulsions, my mother’s depressions, Casey’s impending hormonal prostration, my migraines and my fears.”
The tumultuous sixties in Marin County, California (just north of San Francisco), serve as the cultural backdrop for this work. This social upheaval exacerbates Nanny’s struggles to understand the flawed individuals in her nuclear and extended family, as well as her challenges in feeling secure and safe.
Snippets of LaMott’s Christian faith seep through Nanny’s mother’s proclamations that God has a plan, even when it is not immediately apparent, regardless of how bad or chaotic things may be. I couldn’t help but wonder if the author used Nanny’s mother’s significant facial asymmetry to symbolize the mother’s mental health instability. By the end of the book, Nanny reveals to the reader that her mother looks beautiful.
LaMott leaves it to the reader to decipher the true meaning of it all. For me, this book was a winding tunnel into the vulnerability of the human spirit and its remarkable ability to cope, as seen through the recollections of Nanny Goodman. As I stated at the outset, this book is not for everyone and is definitely not a light beach read. However, it delves deep into numerous psychological and spiritual aspects. You may choose to pass if you’re not willing to engage in the work, but if you do, “All New People” has a wealth of substance to offer.
I found myself getting lost and just plowing through pages at least a few times while reading one of my favorite authors. It was a bit of a strange experience. That said, I think it was an okay story. It had its moments, but it also left me feeling a bit unsatisfied. I am not sure what I was expecting other than something more. I wanted a coming together of the various elements and characters in the story to pull it all together in some fashion. Maybe a big reveal or a resolution that tied everything up neatly. But either I missed it or it just didn't happen. And you know what? That's probably more like real life anyway. In real life, things don't always work out the way we want them to. There are loose ends and unanswered questions. So, while I may have been hoping for a more perfect story, I guess I can accept this one for what it is.