Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 70 votes)
5 stars
26(37%)
4 stars
19(27%)
3 stars
25(36%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
70 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

A short collection of dense and thoughtful essays awaits you. These essays explore the realms of art, literature, and meaning. Their nature can be either depressing or inspirational, depending on your personal inclination. In fact, they might even be both simultaneously. This collection truly deserves, and perhaps even demands, multiple readings.


Some parts of it can be quite difficult, unapologetically ambiguous. It requires the reader to engage wholeheartedly and exert genuine mental effort. But don't be daunted, for this is a good exercise for the brain. As you persevere and delve deeper, you will find that it is rewarding and satisfying in its own unique way. It challenges your perspectives, broadens your understanding, and enriches your intellectual and emotional landscape.


So, pick up this collection and embark on a journey of discovery. Let the words wash over you, and allow yourself to be transformed by the power of these profound essays.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This book is truly abundant with profound ideas that have the power to make one pause and engage in deep contemplation. For instance, the thought-provoking question, "Even if we could depend on our senses, could we trust our brains?" lingers in the mind, inviting further exploration.

It is the kind of book that you can take with you to the peaceful shores of the beach or the majestic heights of the mountains. Find a quiet spot, relax, and open its pages.

Read it at a leisurely pace, allowing each word and concept to sink in. Let your mind wander and think deeply about the ideas presented. Savor every moment of this intellectual journey, and discover the treasures that this book has to offer you.

It is not just a book; it is an invitation to expand your mind and gain a new perspective on the world around us.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Dillard offers incisive comments on the devices and conventions utilized in the postmodern fiction of writers such as John Fowles and Philip Roth.

Her book, however, is not a typical work of criticism or theory. Instead, it delves into the function of fiction within contemporary individual experience.

Consequently, she refrains from analyzing the narrative techniques and characters in the recent novels she examines. Instead, she focuses on what we, as readers, should bring to these books and what they offer us in return.

It is truly more of a personal essay regarding the act of reading contemporary fiction rather than an academic interpretation of the novels' meaning.

Dillard employs very little jargon, which is one of the reasons why Living by Fiction is not a difficult book to peruse.

Her accessible writing style allows readers to engage with her ideas and reflections on the role of fiction in our lives.

Overall, Dillard's work provides a unique perspective on contemporary fiction and encourages readers to approach these novels with a new mindset.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A reread.

It's truly an interesting experience. I'm not entirely certain how much I truly understood 12 years ago when I first picked it up.

Back then, perhaps my perspective was limited, my knowledge not as profound.

But now, as I turn the pages once more, it's as if a new world is unfolding before my eyes.

I notice details that escaped me before, and I gain a deeper appreciation for the author's words and the story they are telling.

It makes me wonder how much our understanding can change over time, how our life experiences shape the way we perceive literature.

This reread has become a journey of self-discovery and a reminder of the power of books to touch our hearts and minds.

It makes me excited to see what else I might uncover as I continue to explore this wonderful piece of work.

Who knows what new insights and emotions it will bring?

Only time will tell, but for now, I'm content to沉浸 in the story and let it take me on its own unique adventure.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Dillard truly showcases an outstanding command of language and a remarkable facility with words in this work. Her acoustic keenness is truly a rare gem.

However, readers might have one qualm. The book lacks a definite organization, or rather, she chooses to use rather slippery demarcations regarding her subject. Even as she starts to outline these delineations, she deftly moves in and out of these lines. Yet, these stray remarks are thoroughly enjoyable.

Another astonishing fact is the display of Dillard's extensive knowledge, which expands into philosophy, metaphysics, the diverse sub-strata of sciences, and of course, her in-depth understanding of literary history and theory, along with a steady stream of amusing facts.

Ultimately, this book is for lovers of fiction and especially aspiring writers. However, if asked to give a summary, one might walk away with a somewhat foggy recollection of what they have just read (I myself am experiencing this problem). Bits of the book unexpectedly bubble up in your consciousness, as if grafted to neurons in a way only accessible by association or the purest forms of daydreaming/intellectual wandering.

The book is an engrossing page-turner. I read it in a sort of fugue state over a two-day period, without any interference from my usual book rotation tendencies. Afterward, I refrained from taking it to my local used book store, anticipating one day to extract a piercingly cogent quote from it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I purchased this book on a sudden impulse at an extremely interesting used book store called Winding Way Books, which is located in Lancaster PA. If you ever happen to be in that area, do check it out. My all-time favorite genre, at least for the moment, is books about books. They are simply delicious, aren't they? Annie Dillard is an exquisitely beautiful, amazing, and fantabulous writer. So just imagine, Annie Dillard wrote a book about books! Of course, I had to get it.

But here's where I came to the realization that Annie Dillard is an Actual Academic who engages in Actual Academic Things, such as writing books that critique literary critique. Sadly, I have no academic background, and as a result, approximately 95% of this book went completely over my head. However, as sad as it is to admit, the book was short, and her use of adjectives was truly wonderful. I continued to read it solely for that reason. Seriously.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is sort of a tough slog until about two thirds of the way through when she really finds her stride.

Basically, there are two themes here. One is a defense of the viability of fiction in the 20th (now the 21st) century. In this age of rapid technological advancements and the dominance of digital media, the importance and relevance of fiction might seem to be fading. However, she argues that fiction still has the power to engage, inspire, and provide unique insights into the human condition.

The other theme is an effort to reconcile post-modernism with more contextual readings of fiction. Post-modernism has brought about a new way of looking at literature, challenging traditional notions of authorship, meaning, and interpretation. But she believes that it is possible to combine the ideas of post-modernism with a more in-depth understanding of the historical, cultural, and social context in which a work of fiction was created. By doing so, we can gain a more comprehensive and nuanced appreciation of the text.

Overall, her work offers a thought-provoking exploration of these two important themes, and provides valuable insights into the nature and future of fiction.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Wow.

An absolutely mandatory addition to any writer's repertoire is this amazing tool or concept. It can truly enhance the quality and depth of one's writing.

Whether it's a particular writing technique, a new software, or a source of inspiration, having this addition is crucial.

It allows writers to explore different styles, express their ideas more effectively, and engage their readers on a deeper level.

By incorporating this into their work, writers can take their writing to the next level and stand out in a competitive field.

So, if you're a writer looking to improve and expand your skills, don't hesitate to add this essential element to your repertoire.

You'll be amazed at the difference it can make.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Annie Dillard is a truly unique figure. She can be described as a folksy postmodernist, almost like your dear grandma sitting on the porch, yet surprisingly discussing Derrida.

She delves deep into some extremely profound questions regarding life and the intricate relationship between fiction and the world. With great skill, she navigates through these complex topics.

I found myself in an interesting position while reading her work. I had many points of contention with what she had to say, yet at the same time, I also agreed with a significant amount.

However, there is a rather long section in the middle of her writing that focuses on critics and writing styles. I have to admit that I found this part rather dull and uninteresting.

Nonetheless, there was one aspect that I really liked. She frequently makes comparisons between literature and painting. By doing so, she is able to effectively parse out the differences between the two art forms, which I found to be quite fascinating and thought-provoking.

Overall, Annie Dillard's work offers a rich and diverse exploration of various literary and philosophical ideas.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a truly remarkable 1980s book.

Depending on your personal connection with literary criticism and its history, you might or might not be aware that the 1980s witnessed a strange and dramatic transformation in this field.

The passing away of several important figures, the university's openness to the influence of critical theorists, and the emergence of identity studies departments all contributed to this change.

English, which had always seemed to lag behind, underwent attempts to legitimize and re-canonize itself.

This book seems to be right in the middle of all these developments.

It not only has an argument and a purpose, specifically to provide access to academic analysis of literary texts for those not formally trained in the field, such as book reviewers.

It is also a kind of artifact.

I am easily reminded of the comments in Elizabeth Hardwick's essays, as well as some recent Orwell works I have read but not yet reviewed, and now Annie Dillard's thoughts on the constant deluge of book reviews and criticism that are often meaningless, do little thinking, and ultimately aim to prop up an industry and justify one's own existence.

Annie Dillard spends some time addressing the state of criticism, not just in academic fields but also in intellectual ones, a distinction that is once again becoming highly relevant.

She provides some interesting tools and a substantial reading list.

What further makes this a very 1980s book is that she spends the majority of her time assuming that you will have or at least agree with the legitimacy of 18th and 19th-century novels, Modernist novels, and now need a way to approach what she decides to call Post-modernism (although she also considers metafiction and others) as a flawed catch-all.

So, if your goals or interests lie in this book capturing a moment in public intellectualism, providing a reading list in the context of a radical shift in the 1980s, or seeking additional tools specifically for post-modern literature, this is a very satisfying book.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Why Read Fiction - Episode 1: Imparting Something Missing from the World Outside

Fiction has always held a special allure for readers. It offers a unique escape from the mundane and allows us to explore new worlds, characters, and emotions. In this first episode of "Why Read Fiction," we will delve into the reasons why fiction is not only entertaining but also essential.

One of the main benefits of reading fiction is that it imparts something that may be missing from the world outside. Through the pages of a novel or a short story, we can experience empathy, compassion, and understanding for people and situations that we may never encounter in our own lives. Fiction allows us to step into the shoes of others and see the world from their perspective, which can broaden our horizons and make us more open-minded.

Another reason to read fiction is that it can enhance our creativity and imagination. When we read, our minds are free to wander and create vivid images and scenarios based on the words on the page. This can inspire us to think outside the box and come up with new ideas and solutions to problems.

In conclusion, reading fiction is not just a pastime but a valuable activity that can enrich our lives in many ways. It can impart empathy, compassion, and understanding, as well as enhance our creativity and imagination. So, the next time you pick up a book, remember that you are not just reading a story but embarking on a journey of self-discovery and growth.

July 15,2025
... Show More
When I first discovered this book, my initial thought was that it could potentially impart to me the knowledge on how to better fathom and cherish fiction.

At the outset, it appeared that a significant portion of this abstruse work was simply sailing right above my comprehension. In particular, it felt as if Ms. Dillard's elucidations would make a gentle, effortless touchdown, only to abruptly rocket back up into the sky, leaving in their wake a haze of charming, mysterious prose and unfamiliar allusions.

Nonetheless, as I have delved deeper, I am now discerning tiny wisps of thought emerging from this lyrical meditation. These are gradually coalescing into fragments of a novel understanding regarding what fiction, art, and even reality itself truly entail. It is indeed a rather enjoyable sensation to experience this evolution of perception.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.