Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 54 votes)
5 stars
17(31%)
4 stars
19(35%)
3 stars
18(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
54 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

I first delved into this remarkable 3-work set by Dillard nearly 30 years ago. Even after all this time, some of the imagery she presents is so vivid and powerful that it has remained etched in my memory to this very day. I must admit, with a touch of embarrassment, that it took me a full 5 months to read it this time around. It wasn't because I lacked interest; quite the contrary. I simply felt that the subject matter was of such great weight and significance that it warranted a slow and deliberate read, one that would allow me to fully savor every word and every nuance.


The first time I read these essays, I was in my late teens or early 20s. At that stage of my life, "Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" was my absolute favorite among the three. However, this time, "An American Childhood" truly struck a chord within me, and "The Writing Life" has served as a great source of inspiration. Currently, I reside on a hobby farm, and I found that "Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" left me with a slightly fatalistic feeling. Having witnessed the harsher side of Nature on multiple occasions myself, I'm not entirely sure if I welcomed the reminder, no matter how beautifully and eloquently it was portrayed.


"An American Childhood" and "The Writing Life", on the other hand, spoke more directly to my heart in the present moment. They were more upbeat, filled with a sense of nostalgia that tugged at my emotions. These essays also provided a brief but captivating glimpse into the introspective and brilliant mind of Dillard. It's truly a privilege to experience her works and be touched by her unique perspective on life, nature, and the art of writing.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I really liked these three when I read them years ago.


It was a time when my perspective and understanding were perhaps different from what they are now.


I remember being captivated by their stories, characters, and the emotions they evoked within me.


However, I am not certain how I might assess them if I were to read them today.


So much has changed in my life, and my literary tastes may have evolved as well.


Maybe I would still find the same charm and appeal in them, or perhaps my newfound knowledge and experiences would give me a different perspective.


It's an interesting thought, and I sometimes wonder if I should revisit these works to see how they hold up in my current state of mind.


Would I be able to recapture the magic I felt all those years ago, or would they seem different to me now? Only time will tell.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Dillard is widely regarded as one of the most outstanding contemporary American writers. Her works are a testament to her remarkable talent and unique perspective.

Her writing style is both engaging and profound, captivating readers from the very first sentence. Whether she is exploring nature, human nature, or the mysteries of the universe, Dillard's words have the power to move and inspire.

If you have a passion for good writing, then Annie Dillard is definitely the author for you. Her books are a treasure trove of beautiful prose, thought-provoking ideas, and unforgettable characters.

So, if you're looking for a writer who can transport you to another world and make you see things in a whole new light, look no further than Annie Dillard. You won't be disappointed!
July 15,2025
... Show More
I just completed "Pilgrim at Tinker Creek", and I believe it is time to take a hiatus from Annie Dillard and return to the remainder later.

"Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" is a magnificent book. It demands slow reading, as it is a book about seeing, curiosity, and learning from the minutiae of nature.

It has caused me to pay greater attention to the world of tiny things surrounding me. I am in awe of all of nature's vivid contradictions and possibilities, as well as the extraordinary strangeness of insects.

I also think Eudora Welty expressed it perfectly in her 1974 NYT review of this book. There are moments when "I truly do not know what she is talking about." Oh well!

This book has opened my eyes to a whole new world of natural wonders. It has made me realize how much there is to discover and appreciate in the smallest of things.

I look forward to coming back to it at a later time and delving deeper into its pages.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Annie Dillard's voice truly echoes that of Thoreau's.

Her writing in "Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" is a remarkable feat.

I have a deep love for the way she transports her readers.

With her vivid descriptions and keen observations, she invites us into a world of seeing and being.

It's as if we are right there with her, experiencing the beauty and wonder of Tinker Creek.

She makes us notice the tiniest details, like the way a leaf flutters in the wind or the patterns on a butterfly's wings.

Through her words, we gain a new appreciation for the natural world and our place within it.

Dillard's writing is not only captivating but also thought-provoking, making us question our own perceptions and values.

"Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" is a literary masterpiece that continues to inspire and delight readers to this day.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**"Three by Annie Dillard: A Comprehensive Review"**


"Three by Annie Dillard" is a remarkable collection consisting of three distinct books: "Pilgrim At Tinker Creek", "An American Childhood", and "The Writing Life". Each of these works offers unique insights into Dillard's world, thoughts, and experiences.



"Pilgrim At Tinker Creek" is a captivating account of Dillard's wanderings and observations around Tinker Creek. Spanning a year, yet with encounters from many years, the book is a meandering exploration of nature and life. Dillard's beautiful prose weaves together descriptions of the creek, its inhabitants, and broader themes such as living in the present and the intricacies of nature. Her ability to transition seamlessly from ordinary encounters to profound questions is truly impressive.



"An American Childhood" takes us back to Dillard's childhood in the 1950s in Pittsburgh. It is not just a collection of memories but a reflection on her interior life, her love of reading, and her struggle to fit into the expected role of a girl at that time. The book also touches on broader topics like the history of Pittsburgh and racism. Filled with small anecdotes and stories, it offers a charming and engaging look at growing up in America.



"The Writing Life" is the final and shortest book in the collection. It focuses on Dillard's thoughts and experiences related to the writing process. She shares stories about the places she has written, how she gets inspiration, and her views on literature and art. While the book has its strengths, such as the beautiful writing and interesting insights into the writing process, some of the tangents and allegories can be a bit distracting.



In conclusion, each book in "Three by Annie Dillard" is well worth reading. They offer a diverse range of perspectives and themes, all presented in Dillard's unique and beautiful writing style. Whether you are interested in nature, childhood, or the writing process, there is something for everyone in this collection.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The world's spiritual geniuses seem to have made a universal discovery. They realize that the mind is like a muddy river, constantly flowing with trivia and trash. This ceaseless flow cannot be blocked or dammed. In fact, trying to do so is a waste of effort and may even lead to madness.

Instead, one must allow the muddy river to flow unheeded in the dim channels of consciousness. One should raise one's sights and look along the river, mildly acknowledging its presence without much interest. Then, gaze beyond it into the realm of the real. In this realm, subjects and objects interact and rest purely, without the need for utterance.

This understanding seems to be a key insight for those seeking a deeper connection with the spiritual and the real. It reminds us to not get too caught up in the distractions and chaos of the mind, but rather to look beyond and find the true essence of things.
July 15,2025
... Show More
There are three books in this collection. The first one is "A Pilgrim at Tinker Creek", and that is the one which I've read.


I purchased this because J.D. Jespersen recommended it. Both professors Carl and Colpitts read from it and other works of Annie Dillard while we were engaged in our art classes. I began reading it not really certain what the point was, and I finished with the same feeling. However, whatever drove her to write all of this down, I am extremely grateful for it because I was completely fascinated from beginning to end. Essentially, she provides a description of her surroundings, but not in a general sense (I'm not sure she even mentions what state, let alone what town she is in) nor in a specific one (she never clearly lays out a map of her exact surroundings), but rather in a tangential way. She mentions something from the nature around her and then embarks on wonderful tangents, imparting all kinds of knowledge she has gathered about or related to whatever it was she encountered that day. I found it somewhat similar to "Nature" and other science magazine articles, but as if it were the "Nature" issue focused solely on Tinker Creek, yet also incorporating reflection, narrative, wisdom, and other related secondary and tertiary thoughts presented in a more captivating manner.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I am not overly fond of nature when it comes to literature or even poetry.

However, it truly says a great deal in my opinion that Annie Dillard is able to discuss nature in such a way that it becomes extremely interesting to me.

Her writing has a unique charm that draws me in and makes me see nature from a different perspective.

She seems to have a deep understanding and appreciation for the natural world, which she conveys through her words with great skill and passion.

It is quite remarkable how she can take something that I might otherwise overlook or not be particularly interested in and make it come alive in a way that engages and intrigues me.

Annie Dillard's ability to write about nature in an interesting and captivating manner is truly a talent that I admire.

Her work has opened my eyes to the beauty and wonder of the natural world, and I am grateful for the opportunity to experience it through her words.
July 15,2025
... Show More
What else can I say other than I love Annie Dillard?

Her writing is truly phenomenal. It has the power to transport readers to different worlds, to make them see the beauty and wonder in the simplest of things.

Annie Dillard's words are like a gentle breeze that caresses the soul, or a bright light that illuminates the darkest corners of our hearts.

She has a unique way of describing nature, people, and emotions that makes her stories come alive on the page.

Whether she is writing about a walk in the woods or a moment of profound spiritual awakening, Annie Dillard's writing always leaves a lasting impression.

It makes us think, feel, and appreciate the world around us in a whole new way.

I am truly in awe of her talent and will continue to devour everything she writes.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I am truly awed by what I am currently reading.

Ligrim at Tinker Creek seems to mirror precisely the lessons that I have been painstakingly honing over the past few years.

It is like a reflection of what I tasted on the Camino when I walked it in the spring of 2009.

This work speaks directly to my heart and my mind, captivating me in a way that few things have.

I find myself hungry for more, eager to delve deeper into its pages and uncover the hidden gems and profound insights that it holds.

Each word seems to resonate within me, awakening a sense of curiosity and a desire for further exploration.

I am eager to see where this literary journey will take me and how it will continue to shape my understanding of the world and myself.

July 15,2025
... Show More
A republication took place in 1990, bringing together three remarkable books by Annie Dillard.

First, there is "Pilgrim at Tinker Creek" (1974). It chronicles a year of her observations and musings near her home in Virginia's Blue Ridge. The book is filled with vivid descriptions, like those of a praying mantis laying eggs, a muskrat swimming beneath a bridge, or the microscopic world of plankton in pond water. Some parts are truly beautiful, while others might seem a bit excessive. However, there is also unexpected humor, as when she writes about forgetting the "Law of the Wild" and not carrying Kleenex. Dillard was still in her 20s when she penned this, and it went on to win a Pulitzer.

"An American Childhood" (1987) consists of essays about growing up in Pittsburgh in the 1950s, presented more or less chronologically. It details her adventures of roaming freely around the neighborhood, spending summers at her grandparents' Ohio summer house on Lake Erie, and learning to identify rocks and birds. The times were marked by events like the polio epidemic and the Salk vaccine, as well as books about World War II and the fear of the Bomb. One of the highlights was when Annie got her own microscope and managed to find an amoeba in pond water, which she describes in great detail. It's amazing that she had such a passion for exploration at a young age. Dillard was in her 40s when this was published, and one wonders if she had kept a journal all those years to remember these events so vividly.

Finally, "The Writing Life" (1989) is a collection of small essays on Dillard's experience of writing and her process. She shares her thoughts on the places where she writes, stating that she prefers a room with no view so that her imagination can meet memory in the dark. This shows how different writers have different needs. Dillard also confesses that she hates writing, yet she continues to do it. She ends the book with the story of stunt pilot Dave Rahm, who, like her, may not always enjoy what he does but is focused on the art he is creating for others to see. This seems to be the driving force behind Annie Dillard's writing as well.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.