Swim your heart out! What else do you have? This was the catchphrase that seemed to be forced upon the story. I haven't read a great deal of Joyce Carol Oates' work, but I was truly disappointed with the way this book was written.
Although it is categorized as a Young Adult (YA) book, I found that there was shockingly little depth to the story. The title felt contrived, and the writing itself was choppy and filled with fluff. We are meant to believe that Darren is torn, but I never really got the sense that he felt bad about anything. We don't witness him taking any steps to right the wrong, to fix the situation, or to show that he regrets his inaction. Instead, we are presented with a lot of one-word sentences and a very superficial teenage boy who undergoes no growth throughout the story. The only thing that changes is that a tragedy occurs.
Especially considering the serious themes of this book, such as pedophilia and homophobia, very little of it is actually addressed in a meaningful way. In fact, this book seems to imply that gay people are more likely to be pedophiles, which is completely absurd. I'm not entirely sure what I was expecting from this book, but what I got was a story with no resolution, no character growth, and no redeemable characters.
On Tuesday, June 22, 2021, I started my day with a reading that was both captivating and disorienting, and which plunged me into reflection once the book was closed: Sexy, by the great Joyce Carol Oates.
The story of Darren, a 16-year-old boy, the hope of his high school's swimming team. With a breathtaking beauty he is not aware of, Darren attracts everyone to him, girls... as well as boys. And this power he wields over others frightens and embarrasses him, as much as it pleases him for the sensation it gives him. But when his English teacher, Mr. Tracy, shows him a particular interest, things change for Darren. Especially when his friends one day send an anonymous letter to the principal accusing Tracy of pedophilia...
Joyce Carol Oates' writing is of a formidable effectiveness. She goes straight to the point, her chapters are energetic, nervous, physical or psychological violence is present on every page, and her hero, sometimes cowardly, sometimes brave, often disconcerts and proves to be disturbing.
Oates addresses male sexuality here in many forms and with great accuracy, which made me realize that I knew it poorly and that it is much more nuanced than one might think. She also addresses the subject of slander and its dramatic consequences, referring each one to his responsibility in the face of situations that exceed us, denouncing the silence that we sometimes observe for the sake of convenience, and not to upset our own existence. And if Darren, under the weight of guilt, finds a way to make amends, the novel ends on a bittersweet note, bringing us back to this brutal fact: we, human beings, are capable of the best as well as the worst. A very interesting book.
Hmm... There are a plethora of subtle, unnamed elements here. I truly liked the main character and the profound meditation on what it means to be a sexy boy - seriously. Consider what it's like to have the attention of both older men and women in addition to one's peers. Oates skillfully took the dreamy and attractive main character and really zeroed in on how uncomfortable it would actually be in reality. Darren was an interesting character, and I wouldn't mind delving deeper into his story - perhaps like if he ever managed to solve his entire gay dilemma. It makes one wonder and speculate about what might lie ahead for him. There's something captivating about his character that leaves the reader eager for more.