Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 67 votes)
5 stars
22(33%)
4 stars
13(19%)
3 stars
32(48%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
67 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Blah blah blah.

This book is not my favorite one written by him.

Although the author has shown his unique writing style and certain literary skills in this work, for some reason, it just fails to capture my heart.

Maybe it's because the plot doesn't unfold in a way that interests me deeply, or perhaps the characters lack the complexity and charm that would make me truly engage with them.

Despite its flaws, I still recognize the efforts and talent that the author has put into creating this book.

However, in my personal opinion, there are other works of his that I find more captivating and enjoyable.

Nonetheless, everyone has their own preferences when it comes to literature, and what may not be my favorite could very well be a masterpiece in someone else's eyes.

So, while this particular book didn't resonate with me, I'm still looking forward to exploring more of the author's works in the hope of finding that one that will become my new favorite.
July 15,2025
... Show More

A truly interesting account of what it was like at the height of the McCarthy era in the U.S. can be quite revealing. The hunt for communists during this period was indeed a very dark time. It had an Orwellian nature, with a sense of paranoia弥漫 throughout the nation. People were constantly on edge, afraid of being accused or associated with communism.


The atmosphere was tense, and many innocent individuals had their lives disrupted and careers destroyed. The accusations were often baseless, but the fear was so great that it led to a witch hunt mentality. It was a time when suspicion reigned supreme, and civil liberties were often overlooked in the name of national security.


The McCarthy era serves as a reminder of the dangers of unfounded fear and the importance of protecting the rights and freedoms of all individuals. It is a cautionary tale that we should not forget, as we strive to build a more just and democratic society.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Silly, it contains nauseating details about Bolshevism and the effects of shock therapy and whiskey on crazies.

At certain points, it is boring and exasperating, while at others, it is fascinating.

The vivid portrayal of the characters almost makes the whole thing completely worthwhile.

However, as it stands now, it is only half done.

There is still room for improvement and further development to make it a truly outstanding piece.

Perhaps more in-depth exploration of the themes and a more refined narrative structure could enhance its overall quality.

Nonetheless, it has its moments of interest and potential, which gives hope for its future evolution.

With some additional effort and creativity, it could become a remarkable work that engages and captivates the reader from start to finish.
July 15,2025
... Show More

A unique blend of Kafka and Henry Miller, this captivating story delves into the life of an amnesiac veteran of World War II. He is like a semi-clean slate, vulnerable to the conflicting psyches of the diverse residents in the apartment building where he takes up residence. The characters here are anything but stereotypical. They are complex, fractured, and engaged in a fierce struggle within the post-World War Brooklyn setting. There is the failed Communist revolutionary, his alluring wife, and their precocious child. Then there is the libidinous government agent hot on the trail of the revolutionary. And let's not forget the self-hating woman, trapped in a cycle of inability to love or be loved, squandering her youth and beauty, and reacting to her own whims with warped insights into the surrounding universe. At times, the narrative may seem to move at a sluggish pace, but there are moments of absolute brilliance that more than make up for it.

July 15,2025
... Show More

McLeod's words cut through the air like a sharp knife. 'So you come to power,' he said quietly, his tone laced with a hint of sarcasm. 'But you have merely inherited the crisis, and yours is the profit of cancer.'


These words held a profound truth. The person who had just come to power was now faced with a difficult situation that was not of their making. The crisis was like a cancer that had been growing and spreading, and now it was their responsibility to deal with it.


Yet, McLeod's accusation of the new leader profiting from the crisis was a harsh one. It implied that the leader was taking advantage of the situation for their own gain, rather than working to solve the problem. This raised questions about the leader's motives and integrity.


As the words hung in the air, they left a sense of unease and uncertainty. What would the new leader do in the face of this crisis? Would they prove McLeod wrong and work towards a solution, or would they be consumed by the profit of cancer?

July 15,2025
... Show More

Not Mailer's finest. This simple statement holds a certain weight when it comes to evaluating the works of a renowned author like Mailer. While Mailer has had many remarkable literary achievements throughout his career, this particular piece or work fails to reach the same high standards. It may lack the depth, complexity, or the unique charm that is characteristic of his better-known works. Perhaps the writing style seems a bit off, or the plot doesn't engage the reader as strongly as expected. It could be that the themes explored are not as profound or original as those in his other masterpieces. However, it's important to note that even a writer of Mailer's caliber can have an off day or produce something that doesn't quite measure up. This doesn't overshadow his overall body of work, which has had a significant impact on the literary world.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Currently, I am rereading this one. I have read most of Mailer's work, but I wanted to revisit his sophomore outing.

He was a bestselling author at a young age. What was next? According to his personal account in "Advertisements For Myself", he had a choice. He could go out and glean from newer experiences or, by gum, sit down and write another. He chose the latter. This novel was the result. It exists solely on a cerebral basis, relying on what he sort of knew by then and what he had read about politics and fiction. He admits that a long dialogue on ideology wound up knocking his book out of whack and it never quite recovered toward the end.

I still don't know what amount of authority Hollingsworth genuinely possessed, or what planet his female characters came from. But I was in my early thirties when I finally read this and thought that twenty-year-old me would've had a completely different opinion of it. Well, it's an odd duck, I will give it that. And on that basis, I found it interesting when charting the development of Mailer into Mailer. Acerbic and erudite, sure, but after a few fingers of whiskey and a joint, then you saw some real mental acrobatics. As Vonnegut said, "So it goes."

July 15,2025
... Show More
The first book I ever read by Mailer was truly an eye-opening experience. It was one of his earlier works, and it had a certain charm that immediately drew me in.

It was a relatively quick read, which was great as it kept my attention throughout. What really blew my mind, however, was the twist that came near the end. It was like something straight out of the depths of hell, and it completely changed my perception of the story.

The book starts out as a typical coming of age story, following the protagonist through his early years and his journey towards self-discovery. But then, it takes a sharp turn and delves into the paranoia and fear that was prevalent during the mid-century.

Overall, I was extremely impressed with this book and it made me a fan of Mailer's work. I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a thought-provoking and engaging read.
July 15,2025
... Show More
In the tenant house of the McCarthy era, Norman Mailer laid his golden socialist egg.

His characters, who are like alley cats and misfit ideologues, play out their noir lives in a dilapidated apartment on Brooklyn's Barbary Shore.

Mailer's sophisticated diction serves as a counterpoint to the gritty and low-brow action of the story, creating an abstract impression that leaves the plot details somewhat open-ended.

At least for me, it did. It gives the feeling that something important and risky, something subversive, is being offered, but its subtlety makes the message slip through my interpretive fingers.

I'm not sure I understand what actually happened here. Still, because it feels representative of a literary time and place that is quickly seeping into a forgotten past, I cautiously recommend it.

It's a work that seems to hold hidden depths, waiting to be discovered by those willing to look beyond the surface and engage with its complex themes and unique style.

Perhaps with further study and reflection, the true meaning and significance of Mailer's work will become clearer.

Until then, it remains an enigma, a piece of literary history that both intrigues and challenges the reader.
July 15,2025
... Show More
All I could think about while reading this was Patrick Hamilton's The Slaves of Solitude and how much better that book is than this one.

Hamilton's work is a masterpiece that delves deep into the human psyche and the effects of isolation and loneliness. The characters are vividly drawn, and the story is both engaging and thought-provoking.

In contrast, this book seems to lack the depth and complexity that Hamilton achieved. The characters are one-dimensional, and the plot feels somewhat flat.

Perhaps it's unfair to compare the two books so directly, as they are different in many ways. However, after reading The Slaves of Solitude, it's hard not to be disappointed by this one.

Overall, while this book may have some redeeming qualities, it simply doesn't measure up to the standard set by Patrick Hamilton's classic.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Early Mailer, stark and lean, was a remarkable figure in the literary world.

He was writing about America in the immediate aftermath of World War II, a time when the nation was filled with a sense of paranoia and everyone seemed to see enemies everywhere.

Mailer's works during this period were characterized by their raw and unfiltered nature, as he delved deep into the psyche of the American people.

His writing captured the essence of the times, reflecting the fears, hopes, and uncertainties that prevailed.

With his stark and lean prose, he painted a vivid picture of a nation on edge, grappling with the challenges and changes brought about by the war.

Mailer's early works not only provided a powerful commentary on American society but also had a profound impact on the literary landscape of the time.

They set the stage for his later, more complex and ambitious works, and established him as one of the most important and influential writers of the 20th century.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is a truly strange book, and unfortunately, it is not that good.

What starts off as a rather captivating, Kafka-esque narrative filled with paranoia and amnesia gradually morphs into a poorly developed soap opera.

The story is plagued by stilted romantic encounters that lack authenticity, lectures on communism and socialism that seem out of place and make little sense, and dialogue that is completely nonsensical.

By the time I reached the last third of the book, it felt like an absolute chore to continue reading.

I found myself constantly frustrated with the lack of coherence and the overall disjointed nature of the story.

It's a shame because the initial premise had so much potential, but it was ultimately squandered.

I would not recommend this book to anyone looking for a well-written and engaging read.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.