I attempted to read this approximately a year ago. However, due to other captivating titles that I was engrossed in at that time, I unfortunately lost interest in this particular one. But, I am truly glad that I decided to give it another chance. As it turns out, I was handsomely rewarded with a deeply thoughtful story and excellent writing.
There are indeed moments within the narrative where one might wonder, "where is this going?" But, to my pleasant surprise, these uncertainties are resolved relatively quickly. Another aspect that I really appreciate about this story is the utilization of multiple perspectives. It ranges from the "fugitive" dogs, to the other diverse animals, and even to the wide array of humans involved.
This book is most definitely one that I will keep safely on my bookshelf. I fully intend to go back to it for a second reading, as I believe there is still much more to discover and appreciate within its pages.
Bit of a spoiler following as I am discussing the book, itself, not just the jacket. Also, much of the book resembles the animated film, but the ending is entirely different--the film stops while the novel keeps going.
This novel chronicles medical experimentation in horrific detail. It is depressing, as many have said. What makes it depressing is that it forces the reader to face profoundly shameful things that happen, or have happened, quite frequently. These are things that we allow or have allowed to happen to various animals. In fact, much of the book is a kind of propaganda, in the truest sense of the word. Adams shows us where our cosmetics, medicines, and many other things come from. He does this most effectively with blinded bunnies who act as a kind of symbolic Godhead, "watching" all that happens. He seems to want us to be horrified and ashamed, which makes much of the book difficult to read.
Towards the end, though, he does something really interesting. The book is progressing to a logical end, and Adams steps in with a nice postmodern trick. He adopts the voice of the reader addressing him, the author. "How can you end it like this?" the reader essentially says. (Aah, Adams may well be saying, how can YOU let it end like this?) Adams then introduces a pair of environmentalists who discuss his own work, not necessarily positively, and appear poised to miraculously change the tide. He also goes back and touches on certain characters, especially one of the scientists, and fleshes them out for the first time. This shows the reader a little bit of perspective, which raises the book from propaganda into the novel form.
However, since the reader has experienced 300 pages of animal torture previous, 15 pages of well-meaning hardly displaces the shame. It is an obviously false happy turn Adams is showing us. I found this fascinating and very well-done. Readers of Watership Down (and nothing else), I would think, would be lost and very disappointed with this book. I say this because I am considering WD as a sort of advanced YA or kids fiction book. This is definitely not that. This is a very complex novel, the sort of thing I wished I'd been able to read in college instead of having to read Beowolf 4 times. (Nothing against Beowolf, it's the 4 times that got me.) I can't say that I enjoyed this book, but the ending was very well-done. So I'll let it stand and say well done to Mr. Adams.
"It's a bad world for animals." This is the chorus and prevailing theme in The Plague Dogs. This book is truly heartbreaking and emotionally draining. I've always been a bit of a misanthrope with a heightened empathy for animals. When I see a homeless person lying under a bridge with a dog on a leash, my immediate thought is, "Oh, that poor dog." This is because animals have no voice and domesticated animals are entirely reliant on humans. The Plague Dogs gives voice to the plight of suffering and mistreated animals in a non-cartoonish Disney way. Although they did make a cartoon movie out of this book, much like Adams' other famous novel/cartoon movie Watership Down, I was traumatized by it as a child when my dad let me watch it. My sister and I were horrified throughout, and our dad, having read the book, encouraged us to stick it out because he thought there was a happy ending. But there wasn't. The movie's ending differed from the book's, and it was horrific. We cried for days, and my dad cursed under his breath. In short, don't mistake this book as being for kids just because it has talking animals. It's not. Besides the subject matter, it would be unreadable for younger readers due to cursing, violence, lyrical prose, and dialogue in thick "Geordie" accents/slang. I was almost on the verge of liking it better than Watership Down. It's more emotional and heartwrenching, but its flaw is having too many human characters who aren't as interesting. Reading this book might make you choke up, turn vegan, give your dog a big hug, or name your next puppy "Snitter". As for me, while reading it, I finally contacted my local wildlife rescue center about volunteering. I start in two weeks.