Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
36(36%)
4 stars
39(39%)
3 stars
25(25%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Tried to like this, but to be honest, I simply couldn't get past the premise of a horse talking in a (frequently incorrect) southern dialect to a barn cat. It seemed rather far-fetched to me.

I understand that others may have loved it, perhaps finding the concept charming or entertaining. However, for me, the idea of talking animals just doesn't work. It fails to engage my imagination or hold my interest.

As a result, I did not finish the story. I couldn't bring myself to invest further in a narrative that started off on such a strange note. Maybe it's just a personal preference, but for me, this particular aspect was a major turn-off.

I'm sure there are many other great stories out there that can capture my attention without relying on talking animals in a dialect that doesn't quite ring true.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Honestly, I was truly relieved to have finally completed this book.

It was an extremely tedious read, perhaps mainly due to its narrative format.

The narrator being a horse with a thick Southern accent was indeed a creative touch, but it also had its drawbacks.

Traveller's viewpoint as a horse was extremely limited, which made it a bit of a struggle to fully engage with the story.

However, on the plus side, it was undeniably educational.

It provided unique insights into the life and perspective of a horse, which was quite interesting.

Despite the challenges in reading, I did gain some valuable knowledge from this book.

Overall, while it wasn't the most enjoyable reading experience, it did have its redeeming qualities.

I'm glad I stuck with it until the end.

July 15,2025
... Show More

This is the remarkable story of General Lee's horse, Traveller. What makes it truly fascinating is that it presents the narrative, particularly of the Civil War, from the unique perspective of the horse itself. Through Traveller's eyes, we gain a different understanding of the events and the turmoil that unfolded during that time.


Not only does it tell the story of the war, but it also vividly describes the deep and unbreakable bond between the horse and the man in grey, General Lee. Traveller was not just a means of transportation for the general; it was a trusted companion and a silent witness to his every decision and action.


The story of Traveller offers a fresh and engaging look at a significant period in American history, and it reminds us of the important role that animals have played in our lives and in the events that have shaped our world.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Really interesting look into the Civil War through the point of view of a horse.


The story offers a unique perspective, allowing us to see the chaos and turmoil of that era from the eyes of a creature that was an integral part of the conflict. We can imagine the horse's fear and confusion as it witnessed battles, heard the thunder of cannons, and felt the tremors of the earth beneath its hooves.


Through this horse's experiences, we gain a deeper understanding of the hardships endured by all those involved in the Civil War, not just the soldiers but also the animals that served alongside them. It makes us realize that war affects every living being, and that even the most unlikely of witnesses can have a story to tell.


This novel approach to depicting the Civil War adds a new layer of depth and emotion to the historical narrative, making it a truly engaging and thought-provoking read.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Most likely the best novel about Gen. Lee narrated by a horse.

This unique literary work offers a fresh and captivating perspective on the life and times of General Lee. Through the eyes of a horse, we are able to witness the events and emotions that shaped this iconic figure.

The story unfolds in a vivid and detailed manner, painting a rich picture of the Civil War era. The horse's narration adds an element of authenticity and charm, as it provides insights into the daily lives and struggles of both humans and animals.

Readers will be drawn into the world of Gen. Lee and his horse, experiencing their joys, sorrows, and adventures along the way. This novel is a must-read for anyone interested in history, literature, or simply a good story.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Pretty good.

The concept was indeed quite strong. It presented a unique and interesting take on the American Civil War. The writing, for the most part, was of a good standard. It was engaging and managed to hold the reader's attention.

However, there were parts that seemed a bit silly. Maybe the author took some liberties with the facts or the way certain events were presented. But despite these minor flaws, it was still a good exploration of the American Civil War from a different perspective.

It offered a fresh look at a well-known historical event and made the reader think about it in a new way. Overall, it was an enjoyable read and a worthy addition to the literature on the American Civil War.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Story of the Civil War through the Eyes of General Robert E. Lee's Horse

I am General Robert E. Lee's horse, and I have witnessed the turmoil and tragedy of the Civil War.

Every day, I carry my master into battle, feeling the tremors of the earth beneath my hooves as cannon fire booms and rifles crack.

I see the fear and determination in the faces of the soldiers, and I sense the weight of history that is being written with each passing moment.

General Lee is a great leader, but even he cannot escape the pain and loss that this war brings.

I have seen him weep for his fallen comrades and worry about the future of our country.

As the war drags on, I grow tired and weary, but I know that I must continue to serve my master and do my part in this conflict.

Perhaps one day, peace will return to our land, and the sacrifices that have been made will not have been in vain.

Until then, I will remain by General Lee's side, a silent witness to the story of the Civil War.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read this a few years ago and was completely mesmerized by it.

It offers an encompassing look at the Civil War, but from a truly unique perspective - the eyes of General Lee's horse.

The creativity of this approach is truly remarkable, as it provides a whole new slant on the brother against brother war that we fought in the 19th century.

It allows us to see the events and the emotions of that tumultuous time in a way that we never have before.

We get to experience the war not just from the perspective of the soldiers and generals, but from the animal that was an essential part of their lives and their campaigns.

It is a fascinating and engaging read that brings history to life in a whole new way.

July 15,2025
... Show More

I read this particular piece because "Watership Down" held great significance in my childhood. In fact, it might just be the only book I've ever had the inclination to read twice. Adams has an extraordinary talent for capturing the voices of animals in a highly believable manner, and he did an outstanding job with Traveller. Traveller's perspective on life, people, and circumstances beyond his control will resonate deeply with anyone who has ever had any experience around horses. He is childlike, always eager to please, blindly devoted to and dependent on his master. When he becomes aware of his position, he can be quite pompous, yet he remains endlessly optimistic about the future.


I think Adams crafted him as being supremely lacking in stubbornness to highlight Robert E. Lee's superior horsemanship and sensitivity towards animals. Interestingly, Traveller actually seemed like a rather odd choice for a narrator to me. This is because he is by no means an underdog. He knows precisely how good he is at his job and is completely oblivious to any sign that his side might be losing, much to the annoyance of a few other horses who are far more cynical than him and seem like more suitable candidates for a narrator. Of course, Traveller is an icon, and he is the individual best suited to tell us an honest story about Lee, so it makes perfect sense that it is his voice that we hear.


It is truly heart-breaking to witness how Traveller's thinking becomes increasingly irrational as the Confederacy approaches and eventually meets its end. This is because he has such unwavering faith in Lee, who is almost like a deity to him and the rest of the army. Traveller seems to embody the attitude of the average Confederate soldier in that he operates on belief and only has a hazy understanding of what they were fighting for, which is often the case in so many conflicts. Adams deliberately avoided even hinting at the causes of the war, which initially disappointed me. In this day and age, I've come to expect some form of punditry in all the media I consume, including books. However, as I delved deeper into the book, I realized that it really wasn't necessary in this context. Maybe the reader was meant to draw parallels between the owned animal and the owned man. After all, every slave mentioned (and there are very few) is faithful and devoted, just like Traveller. But I'm not entirely certain that I could seriously advocate for that theory. On the surface, Adams wrote an intimate, emotional, and surprisingly detailed account of a part of the Civil War and a remarkable relationship between a man and a horse. If he emphasized anything, it was that war is a place of hell, waste, and far from glorious.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I have a profound love for this book.

It presents an extremely interesting approach that manages to captivate the reader's attention throughout while simultaneously presenting valid and valuable information regarding the Civil War and the renowned figure, Robert E. Lee.

Here's a little hint for you: The story is narrated from the perspective of Lee's trusted steed, Traveller. This unique vantage point adds an entirely new dimension to the narrative.

If you have a penchant for history and are also seeking something a little out of the ordinary, then you are bound to enjoy this book to the fullest.

I have had the pleasure of reading all of Richard Adams' books, and I can wholeheartedly say that I love each and every one of them.

I firmly believe that you will have the same experience and come to cherish his works as much as I do.

Give this book a try, and you won't be disappointed.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The American Civil War is a significant event in history, and seeing it through the eyes of Traveller, Lt. Gen. Robert E. Lee's horse, offers a unique perspective.

It may seem crazy at first, but Traveller likely had a better understanding of the strategic situation than many enlisted soldiers.

This is because he was constantly by Lee's side, experiencing the ebb and flow of the war.

I had the pleasure of reading this wonderful book several years ago, and I'm truly delighted to have found it again.

Rereading it allows me to relive the drama and excitement of the American Civil War from a whole new angle.

Traveller's story is not only a fascinating account of a horse's life during the war but also a reflection of the larger historical context.

It provides insights into the strategies, emotions, and experiences of those involved in the conflict.

Overall, this book is a must-read for anyone interested in the American Civil War or in unique perspectives on history.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Adams' best work is truly remarkable. In this piece, he takes an incredibly unique approach by writing about the Civil War from the perspective of the generals' horses. This fresh and innovative viewpoint allows the readers to gain a whole new understanding of the events that took place during that tumultuous time. The way he describes the experiences and emotions of these horses is both touching and well thought out. We can almost feel the fear, the exhaustion, and the loyalty that these animals must have felt as they carried their riders into battle. Adams' writing is so vivid and engaging that it draws the readers in and makes them care deeply about the horses and their stories. It is a truly outstanding work that showcases his talent as a writer and his ability to think outside the box.

 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.