Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
30(30%)
4 stars
32(32%)
3 stars
38(38%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I read "Quicksand", the first novella in this book, as part of the MA exam reading list.

At first, I was a little resistant, but it eventually won me over.

We follow Helga Crane as she escapes a prominent yet stifling faculty position at a southern all-black school and moves to Chicago, Harlem, Copenhagen, back to Harlem, and finally to rural Alabama.

With each new place, she experiences the same emotional cycle of elation, irritation, and then rejection as she moves on to a change of scenery and people.

Helga's search for authenticity lies at the core of her restlessness. As the daughter of a black man and a white mother from Denmark, her pursuit of identity, connection, and a sense of place is integral to her constant flight.

Moreover, the last few sentences of the novel are rather bleak, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

Overall, "Quicksand" offers a profound exploration of a woman's journey in search of herself in a complex and often unforgiving world.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Great learning experience for me as far as being in the head and heart of a bi-racial woman living in Harlem during the Renaissance (20s and 30s). Nella Larsen's novels offer a unique perspective into that era. However, though I fully appreciate the tenacity and talent it must have taken her to write such novels in those days and the sacrifices she had to endure later, dying in anonymity as a nurse in New York, I still found the books a little too forgettable for what I was expecting.


I disliked both narrators: Helga (Quicksand) and Irene (Passing), and for the same reasons. They both seemed to be much mentally divided and easily shaken or even so quick to despair. Their inner turmoil was palpable, but unfortunately, it wasn't countered by vivacity of spirit or bursts of courage or anything like that, which usually makes for memorable heroines. As I write this, I realize that maybe Nella Larsen did something very original. She allowed her black heroines to be complicated intellectuals with snobbish penchants. This is an interesting aspect that perhaps I didn't fully appreciate at first. Maybe that in itself is worth talking about.


Food for thought. As I grow older and wiser, I might return to this book and add another star. It's possible that my perspective will change, and I'll be able to see the true depth and value of Nella Larsen's work.

July 15,2025
... Show More
This read through was just passing.

It didn't really leave a lasting impression. The content seemed rather ordinary and lacking in excitement. There were no real highlights or moments that made me sit up and take notice.

It was as if I was simply going through the motions, reading the words without truly engaging with them.

Maybe with a bit more effort and creativity, this could have been a more interesting and enjoyable read. But as it stands, it's just average.

I hope that in the future, there will be more thought put into the writing to make it more captivating and memorable.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have an intense love for this book.

Ms. Larsen is extremely meticulous in her writing, not wasting a single word. She skillfully hides profound meanings within every inch of the texts.

The depth and complexity of the content make it a truly remarkable piece of work.

It is not just a book that can be read and forgotten; rather, it demands to be read more than once.

Each time you pick it up, you are likely to discover new layers of meaning and gain a deeper understanding of the story and the author's intentions.

This book is a literary gem that will surely leave a lasting impression on any reader who takes the time to explore its pages.

It is highly recommended for those who appreciate well-crafted literature and are willing to invest the time and effort to fully appreciate its beauty.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Two inspiring novels. A deep dive into the condition of the black woman in the late 1800s and early 1900s. The first one is more tragic. We recognize a pattern. Helga Crane has so much potential but she sinks until she loses every opportunity. "Passing" was more funny, lighter but just as poignant and disturbing. I adored this author. It's a pity that she wasn't published more.

These novels offer a unique perspective on a time when black women faced numerous challenges and limitations. The story of Helga Crane is a heart-wrenching one, as we watch her slowly spiral downwards despite her initial promise. On the other hand, "Passing" presents a more complex and nuanced exploration of identity and race, with its lighter tone adding an element of surprise and entertainment.

Overall, these novels are a testament to the power of literature to shed light on important social issues and to give voice to those who have been marginalized. It's a shame that the author didn't have more opportunities to share her work with the world, but hopefully, her legacy will continue to inspire future generations of writers and readers alike.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Nella Larsen is truly a remarkable writer. She has an extraordinary ability to capture inner feelings with such astonishing accuracy. It is indeed a great pity that she didn't produce any works beyond these two texts.

I found both of her stories to be equally enjoyable. In 'Passing', I couldn't help but wish that the story was longer. It would have been fascinating to explore in more detail the various ways in which Irene 'passed' as white. Additionally, the hypocrisy with which she condemns Clare is a complex and thought-provoking aspect that could have been delved into more deeply.

Larsen's writing style is engaging and her characters are well-developed. Her exploration of themes such as race, identity, and sexuality is both timely and relevant. It is a shame that her literary career was so short-lived, as she clearly had a great deal more to offer.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I’ve perused reviews of these two novels that zero in on the sexuality of the characters. The summary for Quicksand here on Goodreads states as such. However, I simply didn’t perceive it that way. I believe people are overanalyzing the language of the era.

Both novels significantly address race and the struggle to fit in, something Nella Larsen likely grappled with throughout her life. Her mother was a Danish immigrant and her father was black. Her mother remarried a white man, and Nella grew up in a white immigrant household. Her life experiences were completely distinct from those of most black Americans, granting her a unique perspective.

The lead protagonists in both novels, Helga Crane and Irene Redfield, seem to be autobiographical. Helga Crane, the protagonist of “Quicksand,” shares Nella’s biracial background, constantly striving to fit in but never quite achieving it. She feels out of place in both white/Danish society and black society. This theme extends beyond race, as immigrants often experience a similar sense of not belonging.

Helga breaks off her first engagement as she doesn’t love him, declines another proposal for the same reason, and only realizes too late that she has passed up the man she truly loved. In a desperate act resulting from a mental breakdown, she marries an unlikely candidate. The novel concludes rather abruptly in a depressingly fitting way that clarifies the title. It is a masterful exploration of the concept of fitting in.

“Passing” commences with childhood friends Irene and Clare meeting by chance while both are passing as white women. Irene does so temporarily to enter a restaurant, and Clare as a permanent aspect of her life. The novel proceeds to examine the meaning of “passing” and its impact on the individual, serving as a backdrop to the story’s action.

Irene frets that Clare will be discovered by her racist husband and ponders the consequences. Additionally, Irene begins to suspect that her husband is cheating on her, a situation Nella Larsen also endured. I couldn’t help but wonder if the shocking ending was something Nella fervently desired. And the ending is delightfully open to interpretation regarding what actually transpired.

These two short novels succeed due to their profound depth and emotion. Both have distinct feminist undertones, as marriage and, by extension, motherhood, are depicted as limitations. Racial identity and, to a lesser extent, social class are prominent themes, prompting thoughtful reflection on both in society. These novellas would be excellent for book club discussions.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Someone shoot me if I ever express the desire to read this again. This statement reflects a rather extreme sentiment towards a particular piece of writing. It implies that the experience of reading it was so unpleasant or uninteresting that the person would rather face a drastic consequence than have to endure it again. It could be that the content was dull, the writing style was poor, or perhaps it simply didn't resonate with the individual's interests. Whatever the reason, this strong reaction shows just how important it is for writers to engage their readers and make their work captivating. After all, if a reader has such a negative attitude towards a piece of writing, it's unlikely that they will recommend it to others or bother to read anything else by the same author.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I'll be quite honest.

I didn't really care for the characters in Larsen's Quicksand & Passing. However, despite that initial feeling, I found myself loving the stories.

Larsen has this remarkable ability that allows the reader to still find empathy and understand the characters, even when they may not be immediately likable.

Both of these works explore duality from two distinct points of views.

In Passing, Larsen delves deep into the effects of passing, not only in the context of color but also in relation to identity and the struggle to fit into socially constructed concepts.

It makes the reader question the boundaries and the consequences of trying to pass as something or someone else.

In Quicksand, on the other hand, the focus is on the internal struggle of who you desire to be and who you actually become.

It shows the often painful journey of self-discovery and the realization that our ideals may not always align with reality.

Overall, Larsen's works are thought-provoking and offer a unique perspective on the human experience.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Nella Larsen's two short stories are period pieces set just before the 1928 stock crash.

They exquisitely detail the rich inner lives of black women during the Jim Crow era.

The stories present the impossible choices these women faced between wholeheartedly embracing Black life and womanhood, and striving for a good life and a fair chance in the United States of America.

It is truly sad to note how much has remained unchanged since then.

The struggles and dilemmas that Larsen's characters endured still resonate today, highlighting the persistent issues of race and gender inequality.

Her works serve as a powerful reminder of the long and arduous journey that black women have had to undertake in their pursuit of equality and a better life.

Despite the passage of time, the fight for justice and fairness continues, and Larsen's stories remain relevant and poignant.
July 15,2025
... Show More

I read this article during my first year of working for a school. It really caught my attention and I liked it a great deal. To my delight, the 11th graders also had a strong affinity for it.


The content of the article was engaging and thought-provoking. It presented ideas and perspectives that were both relevant and interesting to our students. As I shared it with the 11th graders, I could see their eyes light up with curiosity and excitement.


We had some great discussions based on the article. The students were able to express their own opinions and insights, and they learned from each other's perspectives. It was truly a rewarding experience to see them engage so actively with the material.


I believe that this article played an important role in enhancing the learning environment in our classroom. It sparked their interest and motivated them to think more deeply about the topics at hand. I will definitely look for more such articles in the future to share with my students.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The original article seems to be rather concise. Let's expand it to 300 words while maintaining the overall tone and adding the specified elements.


The product under review has received a rating of 3.5 stars. This score indicates that it has a fair share of positive aspects, yet also has some room for improvement. On one hand, it offers certain features that are quite useful and appealing. For example, its design is sleek and modern, which catches the eye. Additionally, it functions relatively well in most situations, providing a satisfactory user experience. However, it is not without its drawbacks. Some users have reported issues with its durability, suggesting that it may not withstand the test of time as well as expected. There are also a few minor glitches in its performance that could be addressed to enhance its overall quality. Overall, while the 3.5-star rating is a decent score, the product has the potential to be even better with some refinements.


3.5 stars
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.