Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
41(41%)
4 stars
25(25%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

Despite the fact that I was required to read this book for school, I still derived great enjoyment from it. To a certain extent, it was fairly entertaining. There were, without a doubt, sections in the book that appeared much slower and perhaps "less significant" (for want of a better expression) compared to others. However, I discovered that the overall plot, when combined with the rich symbolism and the underlying morals and messages, made the book not only quite enjoyable but also challenging enough. It put me and my classmates in a position where we could engage in seemingly endless discussions and debates about perpetually controversial topics. And we all learned a great deal, all thanks to Nathaniel Hawthorne and his remarkable talent.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I must say that I did enjoy it to a certain extent.

However, as I delved deeper into it, I couldn't help but notice that it felt very repetitive.

The same ideas and themes seemed to be presented over and over again, which made it a bit tiresome after a while.

It would have been nice if there was more variety and creativity in the content.

Perhaps some new perspectives or unique angles could have been added to make it more engaging and interesting.

Despite this drawback, there were still some aspects that I found enjoyable.

The overall concept had potential, and with a bit more effort and innovation, it could have been a truly great piece.

Nonetheless, as it stands, the repetitiveness detracted from the overall experience for me.

July 15,2025
... Show More

While there is still an abundance of content to peruse, what remains is criticism and analysis. I have completed "The Scarlet Letter." In theory, I was supposed to have read this in high school (HS), but in reality, I likely didn't progress beyond 10 pages. All I recall is that I detested the book and loathed Hawthorne. Recently, I read a compilation of Hawthorne's short stories and took a liking to them. So, after an incredibly long time, many, many, many years to be precise, I resolved to go back and finally read "The Scarlet Letter." This time around, I finished the book and found it enjoyable.


The "Custom House" served as an engaging introduction with a lighter tone compared to the book itself. Hawthorne paints a vivid image of the custom house and its inhabitants. It does require a bit of effort to become accustomed to the language of the era and Hawthorne's writing style. This is perhaps the reason (alongside the slow pace) why I disliked the book in HS (and also due to my general lack of interest in literature at that time). However, what I disliked about the book in HS are actually some of its strengths. The pace isn't slow; rather, Hawthorne utilizes the pace to develop the characters and the story. By the end, I couldn't put the book down as I was eager to see what transpired. Hawthorne does an excellent job of immersing you in Puritan Boston, allowing you to envision the streets, the people, and even the forest. My only criticism is that I wish we could have gotten to know the main characters a little better.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The Scarlet Letter is an absolute classic that has the power to grip you tightly from the very beginning.

As the plot gradually unfolds, it transforms into a truly dramatic tale of two lovers and their concealed secrets, all while they navigate their daily lives.

The story is set in the seventeenth century within a small Puritan society in Boston. Here, we witness the struggle of a young adulterous woman, Hester. She has to face the judgmental eyes of the townspeople while also attempting to raise a feisty child, Pearl, on her own in an isolated cabin on the outskirts of town life.

Meanwhile, the dark secrets of a young pastor, Mr. Dimmesdale, lurk quietly in the shadows of his broken heart.

Although it might not initially seem so, this book is highly relatable due to its use of symbolism. Not everything is as it first appears, and almost everyone can find a connection with a particular character.

Perhaps it's Hester, dealing with the depression of her past yet still possessing a piece of peace in her heart. Or maybe it's Mr. Dimmesdale, burdened by his constant self-guilt. Even Pearl, who finds herself helplessly caught in the middle of a big mess, can resonate with readers.

In the end, this book leaves you with a sense of peace in your heart and a settled understanding that, ultimately, all are equal.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I've been delving deep into the world of classics lately.

This particular read was truly remarkable and it unearthed a plethora of wonderful memories from my high school days, especially from my 11th grade English class.

As I was reading Hawthorne's vivid description of Pearl, all that came to my mind was my friend Kenya's reaction to her behavior. We were all simultaneously appalled and bewitched by it!

And let's not forget the descriptions of Roger Chillingsworth! EGADS!! They were truly captivating.

Of course, while perusing this literary masterpiece, I was constantly on the lookout for all the different meanings of the letter "A" within the story, effectively putting my skills as an English major to good use.

Moreover, it was an absolute delight to decipher the hypocrisy that lurked within the Puritanical culture.

I'm fortunate to have a great copy of this edition which includes "The Custom House".

Can I get a resounding hooray for the classics? This was indeed an outstanding read that left a lasting impression on me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I felt that this book was truly filled with irony and confusion.

Hester hails from a European country and has a so-called wonderful husband. Then, she makes her way to America all by herself, completely alone. Surprisingly, she ends up having an affair with a reverend! And they even have a child together. All the while, Hester's husband remains back in Europe.

It is always a sad experience to read a story about someone committing adultery, especially when we know that such things occur so frequently in real life. However, Hester was a bit inspiring. By being in America alone, isolated and lonely, she gained a certain degree of independence and managed to raise a daughter all by herself.

At one point in the novel, she decides to give up caring about what society thinks of her and her actions. She creates a scarlet letter in the shape of an A, which shows her bravery, how she overcame her insecurities, and how she became strong, along with her lover, Dimesdale.

Although Pearl, Hester's daughter, doesn't feel entirely comfortable with Dimesdale being her father because she is ashamed of him and the actions he had taken in the past, actions that Dimesdale had to flee from society to lead a semi-normal life.

Overall, this story presents a complex web of emotions, relationships, and the consequences of one's actions.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was a high school assignment, yet I still held a certain fondness for it and would not mind reading it again.

One day, on a whim, when my husband expressed his desire to read some classics and recalled having liked this particular one, I grabbed it from the library. Oh, what a bad, bad move that was! I have no idea why I had it firmly implanted in my mind that this was a great piece of work. In reality, it was a whopping 500 pages longer than it should have been.

The story seemed to go nowhere as the same uneventful things kept happening over and over and over again. It was an extremely difficult read and so incredibly boring. I found myself constantly struggling to get through the pages, longing for something interesting to occur.

Overall, this experience has taught me that sometimes our memories can be deceiving, and what we thought was a good book might turn out to be a real disappointment.
July 15,2025
... Show More
2.5 stars.

This is an early American novel that delves deep into the profound question of what it truly means to belong to a budding country. It also explores the complex issue of how one can be individualistic within a strict Puritan society.

I found the symbolism associated with the letter A to be quite fascinating. It added an extra layer of depth and meaning to the story, making me constantly思考 about its various interpretations. Additionally, Pearl's witty remarks were a delight to read. They brought a touch of humor and liveliness to the otherwise严肃的 narrative.

However, it must be noted that the novel did have some dry moments. There were certain passages that seemed to drag on, making it a bit of a struggle to stay engaged. Nevertheless, despite these flaws, the novel was okay overall. It offered valuable insights into the social and cultural context of early America, and its exploration of themes such as identity, belonging, and individualism still resonate today.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly enjoyed this book a great deal more than I initially anticipated.

When I embarked on reading this book, I had the impression that it was going to bore me to the point of death. However, to my pleasant surprise, it did not.

After reading this book as part of a class I had in high school, I was so captivated that I immediately went out and purchased a copy for myself.

I wholeheartedly suggest that others should also read this book. It offers unique perspectives and engaging storylines that can truly enrich one's reading experience.

Whether you are a student looking for an interesting read for a class assignment or simply an avid reader in search of a good book, this one is definitely worth your time and attention.

Give it a try and see for yourself how wonderful it can be.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm truly glad that I decided to reread this particular work. It has been a few years since my last encounter with it.

Although I have always held a certain fondness for it, this time around, my focus shifted to different elements. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that the love story between Hester and Dimmesdale was far more passionate than I had recalled. (Well, as passionate as Puritans could manage, that is.)

In fact, I had completely forgotten that they had hatched a plan to flee together on a ship. Additionally, this time through, I developed a much deeper appreciation for the language.

It becomes evident that this is a classic for a very good reason. I simply cannot fathom why some people dread the idea of reading it. Perhaps they are intimidated by its reputation or the archaic language. But once one delves into its pages, they will be rewarded with a rich and engaging story that explores themes of love, guilt, and redemption.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Once upon a time, I had the opportunity to take a Hawthorne class, and it was truly a life-changing experience. I became thoroughly hooked on his works from that moment on.

Although I haven't had the chance to read all of his short stories, I have devoured all of his novels, and I firmly believe that they are some of the greatest pieces of literature ever written.

Perhaps the stories themselves may lack a faster plot or pace, but the writing is simply flawless. Hawthorne's ability to create vivid and atmospheric worlds is truly remarkable.

"The Scarlet Letter," "The House of the Seven Gables," "The Blithedale Romance," and "The Marble Faun" are all part of the literary canon for a reason. Mr. Hawthorne seems to have an uncanny ability to touch upon very dark and mysterious elements, such as sprites and devils, magical fauns, and haunted houses.

His use of suggestion is masterful, and it works perfectly not only for horror films but also for these semi-horror tableaux. "The Scarlet Letter" is a relatively quick read, but it is a very interesting exercise in symbolism and mood. It is both a romance and a classic, as it relates to Salem's trials and early colonial tribulations, which are so relevant to U.S. history.

Above all, it is one of the best documents of the importance of being true to oneself. Sometimes, sins can have a life of their own, and Hawthorne explores this theme with great depth and sensitivity.

I must also add that the moments of deus ex machina in "The Scarlet Letter," such as the enormous "A" ablaze in the middle of the sky and the searing of Dimmsdale's chest, add an element of magic and mystery to the story. These may-have-beens, bordering on the impossible, make this work truly unforgettable.

I feel a great sense of accomplishment in having come to know Hawthorne's works so well, and yet I am still left wholly dizzy in awe of his talent.

PS: This book is totally appropriate for the autumn or winter, when the nights are long and the atmosphere is ripe for a good dose of mystery and romance.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly wanted to love The Scarlet Letter, but as hard as I tried, I simply couldn't.

I am typically a big fan of flowery language and vivid imagery. However, in this case, it felt like it was way too overdone.

Every single chapter seemed to be just one solitary plot point buried within pages and pages of what felt like fluff.

That being said, I did find that closely reading certain paragraphs was actually quite intriguing and surprisingly revealing.

I ended up learning a great deal that I otherwise would never have even considered.

I really appreciated the understanding goals that Ms. Selvin provided us with, as they applied to the book in a rather interesting manner.

There is just such an insanely large amount of symbolism in the book that I can't fathom Hawthorne having been thinking about it all when he was writing it.

The Scarlet Letter was indeed an interesting story, but it could have been condensed to a much greater extent while still maintaining its symbolic meaning and beautiful language.

Overall, it was a bit of a mixed bag for me.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.