Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 15 votes)
5 stars
5(33%)
4 stars
4(27%)
3 stars
6(40%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
15 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Great story but horrible illustrations.

This statement sums up the experience of many readers who have come across a particular book or piece of literature. While the story may be engaging, captivating, and full of interesting characters and plot twists, the illustrations that accompany it can often be a disappointment.

Illustrations have the power to enhance the story and bring it to life in a whole new way. They can help readers visualize the settings, characters, and events described in the text, and add an extra layer of depth and detail to the reading experience. However, when the illustrations are poorly done, they can have the opposite effect and actually detract from the story.

Horrible illustrations can be distracting, unappealing, and inaccurate. They may not match the tone or style of the story, or they may fail to capture the essence of the characters and settings. This can make it difficult for readers to fully immerse themselves in the story and can even cause them to lose interest altogether.

In conclusion, while a great story is essential, it is also important to have high-quality illustrations that complement and enhance it. Publishers and authors should pay more attention to the illustrations in their books and ensure that they are of a high standard. This will not only improve the overall reading experience but also help to attract more readers and keep them engaged from start to finish.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I really liked the paper art aspect of this book.

The detailed and intricate paper cuttings added a unique charm and visual appeal to the pages.

However, the technicolor people in the book seemed a little strange to me.

Their overly bright and vivid colors, along with their somewhat distorted and exaggerated features, made them stand out in an odd way.

As for the story itself, it was not much to write home about for me.

It lacked depth and complexity, and failed to engage me on an emotional or intellectual level.

While it had its moments of interest, overall, it felt rather平淡 and forgettable.

I found myself more drawn to the paper art than to the actual narrative.

Perhaps with a stronger story and more believable characters, this book could have been a real winner.

But as it stands, it is a bit of a mixed bag for me.

July 15,2025
... Show More
The girls should have shared the coat. They could have taken turns wearing it. This would have been a fair and practical solution. Instead of one girl having to go without warmth, they could have both had the opportunity to benefit from the coat.

Sharing is an important value that teaches us to be considerate of others and to work together. In this situation, if the girls had shared the coat, they would have shown that they cared about each other's well-being.

Otherwise, the situation was almost perfect. The girls may have had a great time together, but the lack of sharing the coat was a small flaw. By learning from this experience, they can become better at sharing in the future and strengthen their relationship.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The pictures in this book are truly offbeat and charming. They are my absolute favorite part.

At the beginning, the story presented itself in a cute and funny manner, immediately capturing my attention. However, as the narrative progressed and started to wind down, it seemed to lose its enchanting quality for me.

Despite this, I firmly believe that young children are likely to thoroughly enjoy it. Their vivid imaginations and love for all things magical will make this book a hit among them.

Maybe it's just that as an adult, my perspective is a bit different. But I can still appreciate the effort that went into creating this unique and engaging book.

The combination of the charming pictures and the initially captivating story makes it a worthwhile addition to any child's bookshelf.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was a truly cute read. It had a touch of sassiness that made it quite engaging.

Moreover, it carried a nice little moral which was to be cautious about what one wishes for.

Michael, in particular, likes it a great deal. He found the story to be both entertaining and thought-provoking.

The sassy elements added a bit of fun and liveliness to the narrative, while the moral served as a gentle reminder.

Overall, it was a charming piece that managed to capture Michael's attention and leave a lasting impression.

It's the kind of read that one can enjoy again and again, picking up on new details and nuances each time.

Whether you're looking for a light-hearted story or something with a bit more depth, this one has something to offer.

Michael highly recommends it to anyone who enjoys a good read with a bit of character.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Rain is a truly magical phenomenon. It has the power to transform the world around us.

When raindrops fall from the sky, they create a symphony of sounds that can lull us into a state of relaxation or激发 our imagination.

The gentle patter on the roof, the splashing in puddles, and the trickling down windows all add to the enchanting atmosphere.

Rain can also bring out the beauty in nature. It washes away the dust and grime, revealing the vibrant colors of flowers, leaves, and grass.

The world seems to come alive after a rain shower, with a fresh and clean scent in the air.

Moreover, rain can inspire our imagination. We can imagine fairies dancing in the raindrops, or tiny boats sailing in the puddles.

It can transport us to different worlds and times, allowing us to explore our creativity.

In conclusion, rain is not just water falling from the sky. It is a magical force that has the ability to touch our hearts, stimulate our imagination, and make us appreciate the beauty of the world around us.

Let us embrace the rain and allow its magic to work its charm on us.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is an outstanding book that would achieve widespread popularity during story time. It is filled with absolute absurdity and offers great fun.

It is truly wonderful for story times that revolve around themes such as rain, clothes, or magic.

The unique and imaginative content of this book has the power to engage children's minds and spark their creativity.

During story time, children will be captivated by the strange and exciting events that unfold within the pages.

The vivid illustrations and engaging narrative make it a perfect choice for any story time session.

Whether it's a rainy day, a discussion about different types of clothes, or a magical adventure, this book has something to offer.

It will surely become a favorite among both children and adults alike.

So, don't miss out on the opportunity to share this amazing book during story time.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have a deep affection for the pictures in this. They are truly captivating and full of charm.

These pictures have the potential to make an outstanding gift for a little girl named Emily. Just imagine her face lighting up with joy and excitement when she receives this wonderful present.

It would be a perfect way to show her how much she is loved and cared for. The colors, the details, and the overall beauty of the pictures would surely bring a smile to her face and create lasting memories.

I can already picture Emily sitting down, eagerly looking through the pictures, and getting lost in their magical world. It would be a gift that she would cherish for a long time. ;o)
July 15,2025
... Show More
I almost liked this book. However, considering it has "magic" in its title, it came across as rather ordinary.

The only significant consequence for Emily when her dad lost his job was that she had to have plain pasta and burnt cookies for dinner. (I'm not entirely sure why the cookies were burnt. Surely, burning the cookies wouldn't have any impact on saving money.)

The illustrations in the book were more captivating than the text. Regrettably, this made them seem a bit odd in comparison.

It's a shame because the concept of a book with magic in the title had so much potential. But perhaps the author was aiming for a more down-to-earth story.

Despite its flaws, there were still some redeeming qualities. The illustrations, for example, added a touch of charm to the overall experience.

Maybe with a bit more creativity and a stronger connection between the magic in the title and the events in the story, this book could have been truly special.

As it stands, it's an average read that might appeal to some, but it didn't quite live up to my expectations.

July 15,2025
... Show More
No award.


This story is about a child in the preschool to Grade 2 age group.


Emily's mom bought her a brand new raincoat. However, Emily didn't like it because it was orange instead of yellow. She started making a series of unrealistic wishes, and to her surprise, they all came true instantly. But then she realized the power of her magical raincoat. She understood that while making wishes can be fun, they aren't always good. So, she learned that she needs to be cautious.


I really enjoyed reading this book about a magical raincoat. It's different from the common magical items like a lamp or a cupcake. The illustrator's artwork is very unique. There's a combination of drawings and realistic textures. I like the clear message it gives about being careful with our words and wishes, which readers can definitely learn from.


This book would be great to use in the classroom as a fun read and a lesson about wishes. Students can think of an item that could be magical and write about it. It would spark their creativity and imagination.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The artwork is truly one-of-a-kind. It has a certain charm and complexity that makes it stand out from the rest.

However, it may pose a bit of a challenge for a toddler to understand and appreciate. Toddlers are still in the process of developing their cognitive and perceptual skills, and it might take them some time to figure out the intricacies of the artwork.

They may need to explore it, touch it, and observe it from different angles to truly grasp its meaning and beauty.

But this process of discovery can be a valuable learning experience for them. It can激发 their curiosity, enhance their creativity, and help them develop a sense of aesthetics.

So, even though it may take a toddler some time to figure out the artwork, it is well worth the wait.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Ryan David's first children's book is truly charming.

It takes young readers on a magical journey filled with wonder and imagination.

The illustrations by Sibylla Benatova are simply beautiful, adding an extra layer of charm to the story.

Each page is a work of art, bringing the characters and settings to life in the most vivid way.

The book is not only entertaining but also educational, teaching children valuable lessons about friendship, kindness, and perseverance.

It is a must-read for any child who loves a good story and beautiful illustrations.

Parents and teachers alike will appreciate the quality and depth of this wonderful book.

Ryan David and Sibylla Benatova have truly created a masterpiece that will be cherished for years to come.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.