Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
26(26%)
4 stars
39(39%)
3 stars
35(35%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This could have been so much shorter if everything that wasn't really relevant to the point was cut out.

Often, in our writing or communication, we tend to include a lot of details that might not be essential. These extraneous elements can make the message seem convoluted and difficult to understand.

By being more discerning and removing the unnecessary information, we can present our ideas more clearly and effectively. It requires a careful examination of each sentence and paragraph to determine if it truly contributes to the main point.

Doing so not only shortens the piece but also makes it more engaging and impactful. It forces us to focus on the core message and present it in a concise and straightforward manner.

In conclusion, cutting out the irrelevant details is a crucial step in improving the quality and clarity of our communication.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This remarkable book truly seized my attention and held it firmly.

We follow the story of an unstable single mom who drives to the mall and leaves her kids in the car. As the mall closes, she mysteriously vanishes. The kids, fully aware of the consequences, know that if they turn to the police, they will be separated and placed in different foster care homes.

With great determination and using every resource at their disposal, they embark on a journey to the one relative they believe might take them in, despite the fact that she is several states away.

The situation is desperate and gripping, and the spare yet elegant writing style makes it incredibly powerful. Although this book won a Newbery Honor, I firmly believe it is just as outstanding as Dicey's Song, which won the Medal. It is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a captivating and thought-provoking story.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I’ve never read anything by Cynthia Voigt before. However, after delving into Homecoming, I find myself completely hooked on the Tillerman Cycle. I simply can’t wait to get my hands on the next book in this captivating series.

This is a truly heartbreaking story that is specifically targeted at young people, with my book indicating an age range of 12 and up. It revolves around Dicey Tillerman and her three younger brothers and sisters. Their mother embarks on a car journey with them, intending to take them to their Great Aunt Cilla in Bridgeport, Connecticut. But then, she mysteriously disappears, leaving all the children abandoned in the parked car at a shopping mall in the middle of Connecticut.

After waiting anxiously for a day for her to return, the children have no choice but to set out on foot to reach their great aunt’s home. They are absolutely terrified of trusting the authorities because they firmly believe that they will be separated and sent to foster homes. Along their arduous journey, they encounter both kind people who offer them help and support, and cruel people who take advantage of their vulnerable situation.

The book is extremely well-written, and the story is completely believable. Although there is some degree of resolution at the end of the book, my curiosity is piqued, and I’m eager to discover what lies ahead for this brave and resilient family in the next installment.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Thirteen-year-old Dicey and her three younger siblings find themselves abandoned by their mother.

They embark on a search for a home where they can remain together. However, the pacing of this novel is disappointingly slow. At times, the story seems to drag on interminably. Both the plot and the writing itself suffer from a sense of repetitiveness.

On the other hand, the characterization in this novel is its undeniable strength. Dicey is a truly memorable protagonist and serves as a strong role model for middle grade readers. All four children possess distinctive and fully developed personalities, and they grow and evolve over the course of the story. Even the cousin and the grandmother are portrayed as fully realized individuals with their own flaws and human frailties.

Nevertheless, even after all the hardships the children endure, the ending doesn't quite feel deserved. The children are desperate to stay with their grandmother simply because they have no better options, not because they truly love her. The grandmother initially states that the children cannot stay with her permanently, but then changes her mind shortly afterwards without any clear catalyst. The happy ending feels rather abrupt, as if the author simply added it on to conclude what was already a overly long story.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I spent the majority of my 7th grade year constantly complaining about how incredibly boring this book was and how much I truly disliked it. Recently, I reread it for the SSR Podcast. The concept of the podcast is to reread books from your childhood and assess how well they hold up or don't hold up. I'm rather pleased to state that my 7th grade self was completely accurate. This book was torturously boring.

And then there are those truly bizarre scenes. For instance, the one where Dicey and her brother have a conversation about girls not wearing bras and having jiggly boobs. Or that other time when she describes her other brother's penis bobbing around as he runs. These moments were just so strange and out of place.

A book that is supposed to be about kids who have been abandoned by a mentally unstable mother and are trying to find their family should have been far more interesting. However, this one was a whole lot of telling rather than showing. Minus, of course, those rather uncomfortable jiggly bits. It really could have been a much better and more engaging read if only the author had taken a different approach.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Beautiful writing indeed!

The author's transitions between chapters are truly remarkable as they masterfully capture emotions through the vivid描绘 of nature and sounds.

We follow the journey of a family of 4 who are heartlessly abandoned by their mother as they strive to figure out the elusive definition of home.

The author does an outstanding job of delving deep into this profound theme, exploring the complex emotions and challenges that the family faces.

However, it must be noted that the beginning of the story does lose some of its pacing as the plot becomes a bit repetitive.

Nonetheless, the book as a whole is a captivating read that reminded me of other great works such as "Turtle in Paradise" and "Becoming Naomi Leon", which also depict unfit parents who are unable to take proper care of their children.

It is a poignant and thought-provoking exploration of family, love, and the search for a sense of belonging.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I really hated this book.

I'm truly sorry to all those who have a fondness for it. However, in my personal opinion, I felt that it was not written in a very good manner.

The plot seemed disjointed and lacked a clear flow. The characters were not well-developed, and it was difficult for me to form any sort of connection with them.

The writing style itself was rather平淡 and failed to engage me on an emotional level.

There were also several parts of the story that I found to be quite predictable, which further detracted from my enjoyment.

Overall, I cannot recommend this book to others.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Homecoming, by Cynthia Voigt, has truly transformed my perception of what a book should be like.

Typically, I am drawn to adventurous and mystery books. However, after delving into Homecoming, I came to realize that adventure and mystery are not the sole genres capable of crafting a fulfilling story for me. Homecoming is an outstanding book that I would unhesitatingly recommend to a friend.

The story revolves around a group of four children who have been abandoned by their mother. Armed with only a meager amount of money, they must find their way to Bridgeport. The children, namely Dicey, James, Maybeth, and Sammy, each possess unique qualities that have both positive and negative impacts.

Although the story evoked strong emotions in me, the beginning initially seemed rather improbable. I thought that four children wandering alone would be a highly conspicuous sight. Nevertheless, as I read about the children's search for a home, I was overcome with sentimentality.

Despite its excellent writing, the book is a bit wordy, which is the only drawback I can point out.

Each child has distinct characteristics. Dicey, a 13-year-old girl, has the heart of a leader. She is brave, cautious, and responsible. James, an 11-year-old boy, is intelligent and loves to learn and make his own decisions. Maybeth, a shy 9-year-old girl, is often thought to be retarded, but her family believes she can understand a great deal of knowledge. Sammy, the youngest at 6 years old, adores his mother and was heartbroken when she abandoned them. He is prone to fighting and sticking up for himself.

The four kids encounter numerous hardships on their journey to Bridgeport. They have to worry about money, the police, and finding a place to stay. At one point, Dicey runs out of money, and the children are hungry and tired. Just when I was losing hope for them, Windy and Stuart, college students, come to their aid and help take them to Bridgeport.

However, upon arrival, they discover that there is no Aunt Cilla. Instead, they meet a self-absorbed cousin named Eunice who treats Maybeth like a doll and comments on Sammy's behavior in school. Dicey realizes that Eunice's house is not a true home, and they set off to find their crazy grandmother.

I found this part of the story particularly appealing. It is inspiring to see the children give up a shelter in pursuit of a real home. When they finally meet their grandmother, initially their impression is not great, but as they get to know her, they become great friends. The grandmother, known as Gram, provides them with a loving home and becomes their new guardian.

Cynthia Voigt is an inspiring author who has created an engaging and realistic story. She has made me change the types of books I enjoy reading. I would highly recommend this book to a friend because of its outstanding writing. I absolutely love Homecoming and would be more than happy to read it again.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Not enough superlatives can truly do justice to this remarkable work.

I devoured the Tillerman cycle (consisting of seven books) several years ago, and ever since, I have been incessantly recommending them to others. My sister finally heeded my advice, and after reading two volumes, she wholeheartedly agrees that Voigt and her characters and stories are worthy of all the acclaim. However, she listened to 'Homecoming' and 'Dicey's Song' and was simply ecstatic about Barbara Caruso's narration.

Thanks to my sister, I have now had the wonderful opportunity to revisit a dear friend and also view (or rather hear) that friend from a fresh perspective. Caruso indeed does an outstanding job, and 'Homecoming,' if anything, was even more potent and captivating the second time around.

My sister pointed out that the basic premise of 'Homecoming' bears a striking resemblance to that of 'The Boxcar Children.' However, it is a 'Boxcar Children' with profound depth and character development. Its classification as a YA novel is far too confining. It is a book that is both about and for children, but it is equally a book for adults, and to a lesser extent, about adults. Voigt's writing is lyrical and evocative, and her characters are unique and authentic.

The central character is Dicey Tillerman, a thirteen-year-old girl whose distraught and depressed mother abandons her, her sister, and two brothers in the parking lot of a shopping mall one summer afternoon in the 1980s. The Tillermans had been fleeing hard times on Cape Cod by driving to the home of an aunt the children had never met in Bridgeport, Connecticut.

Dicey is a self-assured girl with great common sense, extraordinary intelligence, stubborn willpower, and untapped reserves. She turns her family's bleak situation around in a journey as captivating as the 'Odyssey' - a journey filled with unlikely adventures, both good and bad fortune, kind strangers, evil strangers, strangers in between, relatives who attempt to care but don't really, and relatives who don't seem to care but actually do.

Those strangers and relatives, and especially Dicey's younger siblings, James, Maybeth, and Sammy, are deep and fully realized characters who have remained with me as I embark on my own inner journeys, reflecting on this magnificent book. At the end of 'Homecoming,' the Tillermans find themselves on the eastern shore of Maryland, but they will continue to travel through your mind and are likely to persuade you to explore more of the Tillerman cycle.

Highly recommended for sixth graders and upwards.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The plot of this story is truly engaging. After waiting endlessly in a parking lot for their mother, who likely won't return, Dicey, James, Maybeth, and Sammy make a bold decision. They leave the car and embark on a long journey to their Aunt Cilla's, whom they've never met but is their only hope.


As they travel from town to town, they keep a low profile, scrounging for food and shelter and doing odd jobs for change. My first impression of the book was that it seemed like a late-1970s version of the Boxcar children.


After reading Part 1, I have mixed feelings. The writing is so vivid that it makes you feel as if you're right there with the characters, or at least believe that the story is real, as if the writer had lived through it herself. Voigt does an excellent job of describing the setting, and the characters are believable.


However, I think there are a few too many details, which slows down the pace of the story. For instance, the excerpt of Dicey showering after a long journey includes a lot of unnecessary details. While it makes you feel the exhaustion of the characters, it also risks losing the reader's attention. I found myself putting the book down often, which was a bit disappointing considering the interesting premise and the author's palpable talent.


On the other hand, I'm impressed by her ability to convey a character's thoughts without explicitly stating them. The context and realistic characters make it easy to understand the unspoken meanings.


My impression of Part 2 was much better. There was plenty of action, story, character development, and drama to keep me hooked. The ending even made me cry, which is quite rare for a book. The relationships are beautifully complex, making you believe that this could be a true story.


Overall, I'd rate Part 1 three stars and Part 2 five stars. Averaging it out, I give the book 4 stars. It's a story that has its flaws but also many strengths, and I'm glad I read it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I finished it today and it was truly a dreadful experience.

The whole thing was so boring and terrible that I would rather spend the entire day eating onions.

It felt like a waste of time and energy.

There was no excitement or engagement throughout the process.

I found myself constantly looking at the clock, hoping it would end soon.

Even the thought of onions, which are not my favorite food, seemed more appealing than what I had to endure today.

I really hope that in the future, I won't have to go through such a无趣 and糟糕的事情 again.

Maybe there are better ways to spend my time and efforts that would bring more satisfaction and enjoyment.

Until then, I'll just have to remember this unpleasant experience and try to avoid similar situations.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I truly had a great fondness for this book. To be frank, I liked the overall concept of it. I really managed to understand the personalities of the characters.

However, I do believe that it could have been written in a better way. I didn't have the impression that Dicey was a 13-year-old girl. This is because she made choices as if she were an adult, and she was usually so certain of herself when it came to making decisions. I think a girl of that age would be extremely frightened when their mother abandons them and when she realizes that she is now responsible for her siblings.

You might assume that finding food, money, and places to sleep would be a huge challenge for a 13-year-old girl, but it wasn't really the case for Dicey. I felt as if everything was pre-planned, as Dicey was so calm when thinking about all the problems. You could say that she was a strong girl, but she wasn't an adult.

Also, everything seemed to be so effortless for the children after they were left on their own. They easily found places to sleep, they were never hungry, they located food, and they even found money. All the problems were resolved with ease. I didn't feel excited while reading the book, as there were hardly any surprises. The ending of the book was blatantly obvious after reading just half of it.

Apart from that, I did come across some really good descriptions (at times I felt they were unnecessary, but still), and I did enjoy reading this book.
 1 2 3 4 5 下一页 尾页
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.