Community Reviews

Rating(4.2 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
43(43%)
4 stars
29(29%)
3 stars
28(28%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

Besides the beautiful prose, this remarkable book is highly topical. It delves deep into the exploration of the divide between the Islamic society and Western culture, uncovering its profound depths and origins. It offers a thought-provoking perspective that engages the reader on a deeper level.


However, there is one small aspect that I feel compelled to critique. That is the inception of the love between the protagonists. Bowles, who is otherwise meticulous in building and explaining every other emotion throughout the book, seems to have not put as much care into this particular moment. It leaves the reader with a slight sense of incompleteness or a lack of full understanding of how this crucial emotion came to be.


Nonetheless, this minor flaw does not overshadow the overall excellence of the book. It still manages to captivate the reader with its powerful prose and incisive exploration of complex themes.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Bowles’ writing is truly addictive. He is an absolute master of suspense, capable of creating beautifully crafted works that keep readers on the edge of their seats.

The intricacies within his writing are like puzzle pieces that, when you step back and take a wider look, form a much larger and more captivating picture.

This particular book was distinct from the ones of his that I had read previously. It had a slower start, with the story unfolding gradually through the tiniest details.

Nevertheless, the signature rising tension and ominous tone that is characteristic of his work were present, leaving you with an insatiable desire for more. But here's the thing - you don't even know exactly what it is that you're craving. It's that sense of anticipation and mystery that keeps you turning the pages, eager to discover what lies ahead in this captivating literary journey.

July 15,2025
... Show More

It is said that this novel is better than "Heaven", but I still adhere to my own opinion. Islam, told from the perspective of an Arab, generally this storyline, like an active vector, confident in its own righteousness, moving somewhere, is contrasted with the story of a passive Englishman in a dead end, staying in a hotel and in life itself. When it comes to the atmosphere of alienation, loss, and estrangement, it is very good, but when it comes to Islam/French, it is not so good.

Moreover, the portrayal of different cultures and characters in this novel seems a bit one-sided. The author may have intended to present a certain contrast and conflict, but in the process, some details and nuances may have been overlooked. For example, the description of the Arab character may be too stereotypical, lacking in-depth exploration and understanding of his inner world and cultural background.

However, it should also be admitted that this novel has its own unique charm and value. The author's writing style is vivid and engaging, which can easily arouse the reader's interest and sympathy. In addition, the theme of the novel, such as the exploration of human nature, the conflict between different cultures, is also very thought-provoking.

July 15,2025
... Show More

Typical Bowles Spectacular!


Bowles always manages to put on a show that is truly spectacular. Whether it's in the world of sports, entertainment, or any other field, Bowles has a unique ability to captivate and amaze. Their performances are filled with energy, skill, and a touch of magic that leaves audiences in awe. From the moment they step onto the stage or the field, you know you're in for a treat. The way they move, the way they interact with the crowd, it's all part of the Bowles experience. They have a natural charisma that draws people in and makes them want more. So, if you're looking for a truly unforgettable experience, look no further than a Bowles spectacular!

July 15,2025
... Show More
In 1955, Fez, Morocco was in the throes of the independence movement.

Bowles had a remarkable way of presenting the ambiguity and tension of the collective decolonizing mind, almost as if it were a thrilling mystery. The concept of identity and otherness, especially what it meant to be French, American, or Moroccan Arab, was constantly shifting, like a funhouse mirror.

Bowles seemed to pose the question repeatedly: Can anyone truly understand "the other"? And if not, what was the moral foundation for interacting with one another?

Furthermore, in "The Spider's House" just as in "The Sheltering Sky," place was a character. Bowles wrote with a precision and intensity that I had rarely seen in other writers, perhaps only equaled by Le Clezio in "Desert."

Who else could write so convincingly about the countless distinct sounds one hears while walking through the labyrinths of the medina? It was truly brilliant.

Bowles' female protagonists in both books were interesting and complex. They were adventurers and independent thinkers, showing no inclination to conform to the way men expected them to behave.

They went where they pleased and did as they wanted, even when others thought they were merely following along. Sadly, however, they were miserable, and in the case of Kit, she was even mentally ill.

But Bowles was writing in the early days, during the dark times before the second wave of feminism, yet seemingly anticipating it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Great read while in Marrakesh.

It was truly an enjoyable experience to immerse myself in this particular piece while in the vibrant city of Marrakesh. The unique atmosphere and charm of the place seemed to enhance the reading, making it even more engaging.

I'm not entirely certain if I would venture to explore more of Bowles’ work. There are so many other literary treasures out there waiting to be discovered. However, this particular read was fun nonetheless.

It offered a different perspective and a break from the ordinary. Maybe in the future, I'll give Bowles another chance and see if there are other hidden gems within his body of work.

For now, I'll cherish the memories of this great read in Marrakesh and look forward to my next literary adventure.
July 15,2025
... Show More
No man has the right to lament the arrival of the inevitable.

This statement holds a profound truth. The inevitable is something that is bound to happen, regardless of our wishes or efforts to prevent it.

Instead of lamenting, we should learn to accept and adapt to it.

When we face the inevitable, we can choose to view it as an opportunity for growth and change.

It may force us to step out of our comfort zones and discover new strengths and abilities within ourselves.

By embracing the inevitable, we can find peace and tranquility in the face of uncertainty.

We should not waste our energy on mourning what cannot be changed, but rather focus on making the most of the present moment and looking forward to the future with hope and optimism.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Bowles vividly depicts the situation in Morocco, laying bare the harsh reality of the French brutality and the profound misunderstanding of the Moslem population.

By presenting the story from the perspectives of both a Western and a Middle-eastern protagonist, he makes it highly relevant in today's politically chaotic world.

As you read it for yourself, you'll be compelled to consider which side, if any, you align with.

Bowles' writing is marked by a remarkable proficiency and dexterity. His words flow seamlessly, making every page a sheer pleasure to read.

His ability to paint a detailed and engaging picture of Morocco and its complex dynamics is truly impressive.

Whether you're interested in history, politics, or simply a good story, this work is sure to captivate you.

So, pick up the book and embark on this literary journey to discover the truth about Morocco and form your own opinions.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Reading the book, you could vividly envision the author within its characters. His profound thoughts were intricately woven into their ways of life, and his awe and disgust were palpable in the vividly described vistas. It is as if you were peering into Morocco through the unique lens of "Paul Bowles" - through his acute senses of scent, taste, touch, hearing, and vision, as well as through the complex constructs of his mind and the rich layers of his upbringing and diverse cultural experiences.

That's precisely what I find so captivating in this novel (even more so than in the two other novels of his that I've perused - Sheltering Sky and Let it Come Down). It is highly subjective, for Bowles presents us with the Morocco that he intimately knew. Yet, at the same time, it maintains an objective stance in its loose connection with the facts. After all, it is a work of fiction.

And surely, as an atmospheric travelogue, it is truly marvelous. It is like a beautiful music piece, where one must first allow oneself to feel and imagine rather than meticulously pore over the facts. It is a fascinating journey into a past that no longer exists, led by a highly subjective and deeply humane guide.

This novel offers a unique and immersive experience that combines the best of both subjectivity and objectivity, transporting the reader to a world that is both familiar and foreign, all while captivating the senses and the imagination.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I was in Morocco and I read this article, probably twice.

It takes place in Fés, a city that is rich in history and culture.

The story seems to unfold in a vibrant and colorful setting, with the unique charm of Fés adding an extra layer of authenticity to the narrative.

The author has done a great job of creating a vivid and engaging world that draws the reader in from the very beginning.

As I read, I could almost picture the scenes in my mind, the narrow streets, the bustling markets, and the beautiful architecture.

It was truly a pleasure to read this article and I would highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in Morocco or simply enjoys a good story.

I can't wait to read more from this author and explore the other stories that are waiting to be discovered.

Overall, it was a great reading experience that left me with a sense of satisfaction and a desire to learn more about this fascinating country.
July 15,2025
... Show More
3.5. The way the Westerners interact with the Moroccans is quite jarring indeed.

Lee embodies the typical coloniser's perspective. She desires to bring 'civilisation' to the locals, yet she is equally apathetic and invested in the conflict. She encourages gratuitous violence for her own entertainment, which shows a complete lack of respect for the Moroccans.

Stenham's view is perhaps even more troubling. On the surface, he supports the Moroccans and wants them to be left alone. However, this is only as long as they don't seek any social change on their own and continue to exist in a way that pleases him. This is a form of paternalism that is just as harmful as Lee's colonising mindset.

The ending of the story sums up the way these Westerners ultimately do not care for anyone beyond themselves. Despite not having a particularly well-resolved plot, the story is thought-provoking as it forces us to examine the complex power dynamics between the colonisers and the colonised.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Bowles is truly remarkable when it comes to creating atmosphere and building tension. However, he falls short in providing truly satisfying resolutions to the tension he has masterfully constructed, especially in his novels. I firmly believe that he is a far superior short story writer compared to a novelist, yet I am still glad that I have read his novels.


This particular book, similar to his other works, is set in North Africa. It is Morocco on the eve of an uprising against the French Colonials. One fascinating aspect here is that although the French are central to all that is happening, there are essentially no French characters in the book. They have no voice. Instead, we follow three main characters.


First, there is an Arab teenager who ultimately becomes the main character of the book. He appears naive, yet he has an uncanny knowledge of things. He is a devout Muslim and views the world from a perspective that the Nazarines (Americans) cannot fathom. As it turns out, neither can the revolutionary Arabs attempting to overthrow the French. Thus, aside from his father who beats him mercilessly, he stands apart from everyone else in the book. He represents the old ways, which are both incomprehensible and pure.


Then there is the expatriate American novelist. He loves the Arab world for its stasis and dislikes how the French occupation has corrupted it. However, he fails to recognize that without colonization, there might be no opportunity or place for him in that world. Nevertheless, he wishes to hold onto the old ways, simply to observe them.


Finally, there is an American woman who is a traveler. She is likely a member of the Communist party, but it is unclear how deeply involved she is. Her sympathies lie with her ideas of progress and the people, yet she has almost no understanding of either. She believes that everything should change to fit her view of the world, even though she has no clear understanding of the world as it truly is.


The writer and the woman have an unusual romance. It is evident from the beginning that he has strong feelings for her and is very gentlemanly about it. She, on the other hand, loathes him, yet she keeps his company. Her loathing intensifies, but like everything else about her, it is based on a misperception of him and even of herself.


From this description, it might seem that she is a shallow character, but I actually thought her development was excellent, and she was a more fully rounded character than the writer. Moreover, the characterization of the teen is quite remarkable.


Based on all of the above, I should have liked the book more than I did. Unfortunately, I found the structure a bit odd, and I thought the resolution was unsatisfying. It did not have the harrowing ending of The Sheltering Sky, which was horrible yet inevitable and oddly beautiful. Instead, it simply ended, and while the major character conflicts came to a halt, I was left with the impression that they were only set aside and not truly resolved. (I cannot go into more detail without revealing major spoilers, which would still only express my opinion.)

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.