Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
35(35%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
34(34%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
I've truly missed Banks. It's hard to envision another writer who can surpass him in constructing alien worlds. This is the first Iain M Banks science fiction novel I've delved into that doesn't belong to his remarkable Culture series of novels. And "The Algebraist" is right up there with the finest of those incredible tales. It presents a mind-bending alien conflict, features original species, and of course, has that unique and slightly disconcerting Iain M Banks sense of humor.

I can easily imagine readers picking up "The Algebraist" first and then becoming so enthralled that they decide to embark on a journey to read all of the Culture novels. Banks has this extraordinary ability to draw readers into his complex and imaginative universes, making them eager to explore more of his creations. Whether it's through the vivid descriptions of alien landscapes or the intricate relationships between different species, he manages to create a truly immersive reading experience.

"The Algebraist" is a testament to his talent as a science fiction writer and is sure to captivate both new and old fans alike.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Two Iain M Banks. Two swings and misses.


In some ways, a 2-star rating from me is almost worse than a 1-star. Based on my own internal rating system, a 1-star book is one that did something to make me truly angry. It managed to stir up an emotion, albeit a negative one. However, 2-star books are those that I simply didn't like, but they didn't even arouse enough emotion in me to get passionate about my opinion. I'm just sort of casually typing on the keyboard. There wasn't anything in this book that I liked, but nothing that actively offended me either. It was just plain boring.


This book was extremely male-dominated, which is not usually a positive aspect of a book. There were numerous uses of the word "Fuck," even from alien species. Several women died, and I don't just mean they died; they were essentially "fridged." Their deaths were used as a means to give our hero a reason to be heroic. And yet, they were barely a blip on his radar. It's hardly even accurate to say they were fridged because our hero is like, "Well, she's dead. So, as I was saying..."


The mystery at the center of the story was almost interesting by the time we actually got to it. However, the whole invasion and everything else felt like a complete waste of time and space (haha). The entire book just felt pointless.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I guess it's time to come to the sad realization that I don't really like Iain M. Banks when he's writing about anything other than The Culture.

For that matter, I thought the first Culture book had many of the same problems as this story: poor pacing in the first half, a confusing narrative structure, opaque action sequences, and frequent bare exposition outside any character's perspective.

Maybe the only reason I love The Culture series so much is that, over 10 or so books, Banks has finally finished establishing his setting and can tell interesting stories in it. In the space of a single book, like this one, he can barely get a full head of steam before the entire thing judders to a halt.

I actually enjoyed the latter half of the book well enough, which is why this gets slightly more than 2.5 stars overall. The first half, however, is just a mess, structurally, with all the problems alluded to above. It's patchwork storytelling, and it takes most of the book for us to see enough of the quilt to understand what's going on and why we should care. It's hard to read; it took me much longer to get through than books normally do.

It's a shame, because I've always found this particular sub-genre of galactic world-building, where light-speed travel is impossible but you can use wormholes for instantaneous shortcuts, to be a fantastic setting for complex political and economic developments. Lois McMaster Bujold does a great job exploring this scenario in her Vorkosigan Saga, and I think that Banks' attempt would be great as well, if only he gave himself another seven or so books to develop it. In a single book, like this, it feels like a false start at best.
July 15,2025
... Show More
You need an abundance of patience to make it through an Iain M Banks novel. His sentences can seem to stretch an entire page (well, perhaps I was exaggerating a little), and the chapters are filled with never-ending backstory. As a result, his books can sometimes feel like a real struggle to get through.

I managed to get through "Matter" due to its interesting story and likable characters. However, "The Algebraist" proved to be too much for me. The plot lacked any sense of suspense or tension, the characters were one-dimensional and dull, and the seemingly endless setup and backstory made it feel more like reading an encyclopedia than an engaging novel.

After 300 pages, I had had enough. Maybe one day I'll go back and finish it, but it will definitely be a while before I'm ready to take on that challenge again.

Overall, while Iain M Banks is a talented writer, his novels are not for the faint of heart. They require a great deal of dedication and perseverance to fully appreciate.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Fassin Taak is a Seer, yet a young one. For him, it's all about the exploration and the physical experience of directly meeting and conversing with the Dwellers. His elders, on the other hand, are more content with just communing remotely.

The Dwellers are an ancient race that inhabit gas giant planets, which consist of an iron core surrounded by a lot of hot toxic gases. It doesn't seem very appealing, but the Dwellers have been in the galaxy, and are rumored to be in all other galaxies, for billions of years, and they know a great deal. In fact, due to their long lifespan, they have had the time to explore and obtain extremely valuable information.

Fassin unwittingly discovered an obscure reference to a mythological item called the Dwellers List. This list is rumored to contain the locations of an intergalactic wormhole network that can transport one anywhere within the network at near light speed. This wormhole system is in addition to the existing small wormhole system in use.

What a great advantage this would be for exploration. However, it would also be a boon for war. And besides, it's only a rumor, right?

Seer Fassin Taak is tasked with finding the list. Unfortunately, no one knows where it might be, and the Dwellers, despite all the data they have collected over billions of years, are rather eclectic in handling that information, often just depositing it in random order in files and such.

To make matters worse for Fassin, a powerful military presence has learned about the list and has sent a fleet to conquer Fassin's world and force him to hand over the list.

What follows is the story of Fassin's search for the list, if it exists, and the war between Fassin's world and the invading fleet. Colorful and compelling characters both inhabit and hinder Fassin in his search, and there is a war.

Does the list really exist? If Fassin finds it, who will he give it to? Why won't the Dwellers either confirm or deny the existence of the list?

Fast-paced – HIGHLY entertaining - HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It took me a good hundred or so pages to truly immerse myself in this novel.

One of the challenges, I assume, in space opera is that when constructing a galactic culture encompassing dozens of races, hierarchies, and political structures, each with its own resistance movements, a significant amount of exposition is necessary.

Consequently, the first quarter of the book can seem rather sluggish. For example, each line of dialogue is interspersed with several hefty paragraphs that elaborately explain the various layers of context required to understand the unfolding events.

However, by approximately page 300, when the story truly gains momentum, I was able to rise above the initial difficulties and be in awe of the strange far future civilization that Banks has crafted.

The background, the creatures, the characters - all of it was captivating. I eagerly delved into the remaining pages and devoured the story until the very end.

It was a journey that, despite a slow start, ultimately led to a highly enjoyable and engaging reading experience.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Once again, Iain M Banks has truly amazed me with this original and thrilling space opera.

He has, in my opinion, outdone John Varley, David Brin, and C J Cherryh when it comes to exploring life within the dizzying volumes of gas planets. His Dwellers are extraordinary creations, with their chilly lifestyles, acerbic humor, and terrifying power. The mystery of the legendary Dweller List of wormholes that our protagonist Fassin Taak must strive to find is masterfully narrated, with a galaxy-spanning quest filled with humor, excitement, horror, and suspense.

This may not be the Culture universe, but it still retains elements of it. The Dwellers exist in their own cultural utopia similar to The Culture, yet FTL travel is only achieved via wormhole travel, which forms the core of the plot. The antagonist here, Luseferous, is a terrifying monster with a sarcastic, bombastic sense of black humor (reminiscent of some of the baddies in the Culture books), and it was a joy to read about him.

The novel also features several important tertiary characters, such as Fassin's friends Saluus and Taince. If I have one criticism, it is that I was frustrated that we didn't spend more time with Taince as she was a badass. The concepts of "Quick" and "Slow" civilizations, as well as the "Truth" religion, were both fascinating. I also wonder if the Seer idea of "delving" with the Dwellers perhaps inspired Alastair Reynold's Pattern Jugglers in Revelation Space.

Looking at various reviews online, many were disappointed as this wasn't the Culture novel they were expecting. However, I came into this simply expecting Banks to take me on a journey of pure hard sci-fi into worlds I had never before imagined, and I feel it not only met but exceeded that expectation!

Fino Reviews Iain M Banks Sci-Fi and Culture series
Culture Series
... (the rest of the book links and reviews remain the same)

Non-Culture Sci-Fi
... (the rest of the book links and reviews remain the same)
July 15,2025
... Show More
This novel was truly an extraordinary piece of work. It was a) amusing, filled with witty dialogues and comical situations that had me chuckling throughout. It was also b) bizarre, with its outlandish concepts and strange characters. The plot was c) complicated, twisting and turning in ways that kept me on the edge of my seat. It was d) decadent,描绘了一个充满奢华和堕落的宇宙。e) elaborate, with every detail carefully crafted and thought out. f) freaky, introducing me to some truly strange and otherworldly beings. And the list goes on and on.

The main character, Fassin Taak, was able to travel across the known universe through FTL travel and secret wormholes, which added an element of excitement and adventure to the story. The author took full advantage of this to introduce Taak to a wide variety of strange and wonderful things, from sentient brambles to a species that collected dead other species to Siamese-twin AIs with mad superpowers.

Some readers have complained about the Jeeves-and-Wooster ambience of the Dwellers, but I rather liked it. It gave the story a unique charm and added to the overall sense of decadence. Others have also complained about the exaggerated villain, the Archimandrite Luseferous, but I found him to be quite entertaining. He was like the Joker and the Penguin from the old Batman series, in love with his own villainy and impossible not to admire.

The ending of the novel was a bit of a surprise, but it also made perfect sense in the context of the story. If Taak had ended by saying to the old Gardener, "If I ever go looking for my heart's desire again, I won't look any further than my own backyard; because if it isn't there, I never really lost it to begin with," I would not have been at all surprised. It was a fitting conclusion to a strange and wonderful adventure.

Overall, I highly recommend this novel to anyone who enjoys science fiction, adventure, and a good laugh. It's a truly one-of-a-kind experience that you won't soon forget.
July 15,2025
... Show More

It's truly an excellent book. I devoured it as quickly as possible. Humanity has reached the stars. Fassin Taak, a Slow Seer at the Court of the Nasqueron Dwellers, will count himself lucky if he survives until the end of the year. The Nasqueron Dwellers inhabit a gas giant on the outskirts of the galaxy, in a system waiting for its wormhole connection to the rest of civilization. Meanwhile, they are regarded as decadents living in a state of highly developed barbarism, hoarding data haphazardly, hunting their own young, and fighting pointless formal wars. Seconded to a military-religious order he's scarcely heard of - part of the elaborate hierarchy of the Mercatoria, the latest galactic hegemony - Taak must journey among the Dwellers once more. He is seeking a secret hidden for half a billion years. But with each passing day, a war looms closer - a war that threatens to engulf everything and everyone he has ever known.


“It was a well-known fact that all civilizations were essentially neurotic until they made contact with others and found their place within the ever-evolving meta-civilization of other beings. Because, until then, during the stage when they truly believed they might be completely alone in existence, all solitary societies had both an exaggerated sense of their own importance and a kind of existential terror at the vast scale and apparent emptiness of the universe.”

July 15,2025
... Show More
Just when I was deeply engrossed in the works of Iain M. Banks and the Culture series, having devoured "Consider Phlebas" and "Use of Weapons", I then delved into "The Algebraist".

From the very start to the very end, it held my attention captive and solidified my belief that Iain M. Banks is a truly original science fiction writer, right up there in the pantheon with Arthur C. Clarke, Isaac Asimov, and Orson Scott Card. However, what sets him apart from the first two is that he not only has brilliant ideas but he can actually write with great finesse!

"The Algebraist" is narrated from the (third-person) point of view of a member of the Quick races who are studying the Slow ones (who have endured for billions of years), specifically the gas-giant natives in this instance. The study uncovers some fascinating clues regarding the existence of a network of wormholes that has the potential to revolutionize transportation throughout the universe.

Not surprisingly, this discovery leads to a web of intrigue, war, death, double-crossing, espionage, and a whole host of other captivating elements. There are several unexpected twists along the way that constantly keep you off-balance, compelling you to keep reading in one sitting, eager to uncover what lies ahead.

It's a thrilling and engaging read that showcases Banks' remarkable talent for creating immersive and thought-provoking science fiction universes.
July 15,2025
... Show More
My first encounter with Bank's work was truly a remarkable experience.

It had such a profound impact on me that I became completely hooked. I embarked on a slow, yet captivating journey of collecting the rest of his work.

The allure of his creations led me into a dark, yet undoubtedly enjoyable exploration.

As I delved deeper into his body of work, I found myself falling in love with the underwater world.

Bank's vivid and detailed描绘 of the water dwellers was simply enchanting.

It opened up a whole new realm of wonder and mystery for me.

I was amazed by the beauty and diversity of the underwater life that he so skillfully brought to life.

His work not only entertained me but also inspired me to appreciate the delicate balance and complexity of the natural world.

Muay, the water dwellers, have become an integral part of my artistic and personal journey.

They continue to fascinate me and fuel my passion for all things related to the underwater world.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Seasonal Reading Challenge Fall 2018 Task 5.4 - Hiking: “APPALACHIAN TRAIL”


The Appalachian Trail is a renowned hiking destination that offers a unique and challenging experience. For this task, it is required to request TWO Big Book tickets. The reason being that MMPB, which I 'read' in audio format, has a page count of 789 pp. This indicates that it is a substantial piece of work that likely requires a significant amount of time and effort to complete. By obtaining two Big Book tickets, it will be possible to fully engage with the material and gain a deeper understanding of the Appalachian Trail. Whether it's learning about the history, geography, or the various trails and routes available, these tickets will provide access to a wealth of information. So, make sure to request those TWO Big Book tickets and embark on an exciting journey through the Appalachian Trail.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.