Community Reviews

Rating(4 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
33(33%)
4 stars
34(34%)
3 stars
33(33%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
Well, if you have not read this book, I strongly recommend it.

This book is truly a gem that offers a wealth of knowledge and entertainment.

The story is engaging from the very beginning, pulling you in and keeping you hooked until the very end.

The characters are well-developed and relatable, making it easy to become invested in their lives and experiences.

The author's writing style is流畅 and easy to follow, yet also manages to convey deep emotions and complex ideas.

Whether you are a fan of fiction or non-fiction, this book has something for everyone.

It will make you laugh, cry, and think, all at the same time.

So don't hesitate, pick up this book today and discover the magic for yourself.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I thought this book was truly wonderful, and it has firmly secured its place in my top 10 favorite books.

It is a captivating story that delves into the complex world of mental illness and its profound impact on a family. The main character and narrator, Frank, is an incredibly likable individual, despite his rather strange and homicidal tendencies. The author has crafted the story in a lovely style, making it an absolute pleasure to read.

This book explores a wide range of themes, including childhood, family, the age-old debate of nurture versus nature, secrets, violence, murder, mental illness, adaptability, being different, and thriving in the face of all odds. There are numerous unexpected plot twists that keep the story interesting and astounding at times.

I highly recommend this book as it is, quite simply, a great story. It has the power to engage readers on multiple levels, making them think deeply about the human condition and the various challenges that we face in life.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The only way to accurately describe this book is disturbing.

Very disturbing. It's an arduous task to give it a proper review without revealing what unfolds in the story, yet I'll take a stab at it.

The narrative revolves around a teenager named Frank and his life on a small island where he resides with his dad. Right from the outset of the story, it's evident that there's something amiss with Frank. He is, in fact, a teenage psychopath.

Frank is incredibly inventive and devotes a significant amount of time to creating peculiar inventions. In truth, a great deal of his behavior can be categorized as strange. There's a plethora of thoughts swirling in Frank's mind, and he has led a deeply unsettling life, marked by a history of bizarre conduct. In fact, there's something extremely eerie about everyone in his family and among his friends. The majority of the book consists of Frank reflecting in his mind on all the past incidents that have occurred in his life. These incidents are violent and terrifying.

I have a penchant for books that are odd and distinct, and this one was recommended to me by one of my favorite employees at my town's local bookstore. They know me well and frequently set aside books for me that they know I'll relish. If you have an aversion to disturbing stories, do not read this. Iain Banks was renowned for his science fiction writing, and while there are elements in this book that could be described as science fiction, for the most part, it's more of a tale about a severely dysfunctional family. Perhaps it could be classified as psychological horror. Iain Banks penned this book with the intention of making it more mainstream than science fiction, and despite its disturbing and violent nature, it has consistently been ranked as one of the top books of the 20th century.

It's one of my all-time favorites.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Banks indeed has some truly creative and ingenious murder fantasies. However, he got so caught up in writing this novel with an extremely serious tone. I really wish he had injected some fun into it. This is my very first novel by Banks, so perhaps I need to read a few more before I can form a more comprehensive opinion about his writing style and themes.

Told from the first person perspective, the novel unfolds rather slowly. The initial fifty pages or so were completely incomprehensible. But then, gradually, it all starts to make sense. The narrator is Frank, the dysfunctional son of hippies. He reveals quite early on that he has committed several murders. In fact, the descriptions of the murders were the best part of the novel.

I have a penchant for novels that are set in specific places. This one is set on a remote Scottish island, and it does have some very affecting passages about life on an island - the landscapes, the sea, and the view.

For example, the following excerpt:
I remembered once, in the middle of summer two years ago, when I was coming down the path in the late dusk after a day’s walking in the hills beyond the town, I saw in the gathering night strange lights, shifting in the air over and far beyond the island. They wavered and moved uncannily, glinting and shifting and burning in a heavy, solid way no thing should in the air. I stood and watched them for a while, training my binoculars on them and seeming, now and again in the shifting images of light, to discern structures around them. A chill passed through me then and my mind raced to reason out what I was seeing. I glanced quickly about in the gloom, and then back to those distant, utterly silent towers of flickering flame. They hung there in the sky like faces of fire looking down on the island, like something waiting.

Then it came to me, and I knew.

A mirage, a reflection of layers on air out to sea. I was watching the gas-flares of oil-rigs maybe hundreds of kilometres away, out in the North Sea. Looking again at those dim shapes around the flame, they did appear to be rigs, vaguely made out in their own gassy glare. I went on my way happy after that - indeed, happier than I had been before I had seen the strange apparitions - and it occurred to me that somebody both less logical and less imaginative would have jumped to the conclusion that what they had seen were UFOs.

I was informed about the big reveal at the end on another Book forum. I thought the ending was rather weak, especially the father's motivations. Anyway, Banks does not seem to hold a very favorable view of hippies. Especially when it comes to them having kids.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I haven't hauled out the brain bleach in many a moon,

but a goodly dose is most definitely in order after reading this.

The writing is truly captivating, and I loved the vivid images created by the author of bloodshot sunrises and the idea of a fierce thunderstorm that seems to move the sky itself.

However, as engaging as the words are, the thoughts and deeds of Frank take on a rather skewed bent, for he is a psychotic.

He lives with his father, who stretches the label of eccentricity to an uncomfortable level.

Oddly enough, it is his big brother Eric who is in a psychiatric institution.

It is Frank who tells the tale, and it becomes immediately obvious that his thinking is not normal.

Soon enough, you will come to understand that his insanity is profound.

He hums incessantly, and the word "crispy" has now been forever ruined for me.

I've simply had enough of this strange and disturbing narrative.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A Cry for Attention

I had expected the torture porn gimmick to be just the icing on the cake. However, alas, it turns out that the gimmick is the cake itself.


This book, which had a good idea at its core, is sadly underdeveloped. It relies solely on the power of its shock value. While it does contain some musings on gender, societal outcasts, and individual violence vs state violence, these feel rather weak when compared to the extremely graphic savagery that is on display. The violence is, confusingly, at times goofy and at times poignant, resulting in a bit of a mess.


It fails to engage me as a character study as well. The 17-year-old protagonist's sociopathy and ritualistic violence, along with that of other characters, are mostly explained away by a number of traumas he suffered as a child. This is a cheap psychological trick often used in literature and film, and I don't subscribe to it. I believe it perpetuates the notion that a traumatic experience necessarily ends a person's life as a sane individual, discouraging recovery. While it does happen in some cases, it is most definitely not the norm. One could argue that what these guys lived through was really traumatic, but it's still a form of romanticizing madness, seeing insanity as a form of transcendence and trauma as a gate to nirvana. This trend has led to scores of young and, dare I say, adult pop-consumers claiming to be damaged and having seen things as a way to stand out or make their point more valid.


But I digress. Banks also seems to think that the more psychological disorders he piles onto his protagonist, the more plausible his violent behavior will appear. This, again, is not doing any favors for mental health representation. We are told that not only is our hero a violent pyromaniac sociopath, but also one who obsessively ritualizes every single one of his everyday activities, from the way he gets dressed to the way he tortures animals. So, I guess he also suffers from OCD. Why not?


However, the most disappointing aspect is that I didn't find the writing to be all that good. Most of the book consists of long and droning descriptive passages, which, when written in average-at-best prose, make it a drag to read. The writing was so bland that it even detracted from the shock value of the torture porn. I found myself skimming over descriptions of child castration with the glazed-eyed interest of someone reading the business section of the morning paper.


I swear I'm not that jaded. I'm very sensitive to violence and usually can't stand it unless the plot has successfully convinced me that it is absolutely necessary for a certain passage. But here, the violence was so insistent and pervasive, so inextricably woven into the core of the book, that it didn't so much upset me as make me feel sad.


I'd be lying if I said it was all bad. The nightmare quality of the ending successfully escalated to a frenzied climax that was very satisfactory indeed. But even that was too little, too late.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Let's face it. The 16-year-old first-person narrator of this book, Frank, is an unadulterated and more essentially unrecognized psychopath! His older half-brother has escaped from a mental institution (for the dangerous) and is on his way to the Scottish island home that Frank and his dad live on.

This book exists within Frank's mind as he awaits the destination and fate of his half-brother, and the possibly life-shattering events that occur during that wait. Looking back at his extremely off-kilter childhood and his current life that includes his 'wasp factory' creation, which he believes can tell his future depending on which ritualized and unpleasant death any wasp he puts into it undergoes. So, I should mention huge triggers for child and animal cruelty!

I doubt if you will ever read a gothic horror like this one. With Frank's detached narration sharing experiences and feelings that would shock Satan, with so much pre-determined and calculated cruelty, with a complete loss of rational behaviors and yet a seemingly unerring assuredness from a very early age, this truly feels like the mind of a psychopath... one that could live among us!

Not like Frank we don't! Prior to this, Iain Banks had had only science fiction work published. And the beauty of this book from a literary perspective is that this is so obviously really a sci-fi read, with Frank being the alien and the island he and his father live on their alien planet where humanity is yet to reach! Add to all this a sublime twist at the end, that no matter how hard you try, you won't see coming. 8.5 out of 12.

2022 read
July 15,2025
... Show More
Frank Cauldhame's warped playground is a secluded Scottish isle. Here, childhood activities involve homemade explosives, ritualistic animal sacrifice, and murdering local kids - typical pastimes for a teen raised by a father whose scientific experiments verge on madness.

"I had been making the rounds of the Sacrifice Poles the day we heard my brother had escaped," Frank declares with a chilling nonchalance, setting the stage for what could be the strangest bildungsroman in literature since Holden Caulfield griped about phonies (Frank actually kills people, not just judges them).

Banks presents this pint-sized psychopath with such deadpan humor that you'll find yourself laughing at Frank's methodical insanity, only to remember moments later that this teenager has killed three people and showcases their artifacts like trophies from a deeply disturbing hunting expedition.

This novel turns grotesqueness into black comedy. Frank's "Wasp Factory" serves as both a death-clock and a prediction system ("the Factory is a place of pain; it teaches me"). His eccentric father measures urine output with scientific exactitude while keeping locked rooms filled with family secrets. His pyromaniac brother Eric escapes from an asylum with newfound obsessions for burning dogs and stuffing maggots into telephones. Frank enthusiastically recounts childhood murder techniques, similar to how someone might discuss their fantasy football strategy. His DIY bombs and bunker adventures read like "Lord of the Flies" but with fewer participants and a higher body count. And his observations, such as "Two years after I killed Blyth I murdered my young brother Paul, for quite different reasons than I'd disposed of Blyth, and then a year after that I did for my young cousin Esmerelda, more or less on a whim," arrive with all the emotional investment of someone reading a shopping list.

Banks, who later wrote mainstream fiction along with science fiction (as Iain M. Banks), published this explosive debut in 1984, creating something that shatters conventional coming-of-age stories. The novel wallows in perversity yet manages to transform its horrors into an exploration of identity that both engages and shocks readers.

"The grasshopper's legs," Frank explains, "were rubbed gently between finger and thumb until they were unable to move," which perfectly describes what Banks does to his audience - paralyzing us with horror while compelling us to empathize with someone whose moral compass points only towards destruction.

This darkly entertaining study of nature versus nurture gone awry belongs somewhere between "Flowers for Algernon" and "American Psycho" - philosophical depth masquerading as splatter. When the final twist hits with explosive force, you'll laugh at the cosmic joke while nursing the emotional wounds that come from realizing you've spent hours rooting for someone whose ethics handbook is entirely blank.

Rating: 4.5/5 stars - this hive of brilliant discomfort demonstrates how warped tales can sometimes reveal profound truths about existence.
July 15,2025
... Show More

Different, but entertaining.


In the world of entertainment, there are countless forms and styles that offer unique experiences. Some may prefer the excitement of action-packed movies, while others enjoy the charm of a romantic comedy. Music lovers might find themselves drawn to various genres, from the energetic beats of pop to the soulful melodies of jazz.


What makes entertainment so diverse and engaging is the ability to explore different perspectives and emotions. Each form has its own way of captivating an audience and transporting them to another world. Whether it's through the power of storytelling, the beauty of art, or the rhythm of music, entertainment has the potential to bring joy, inspiration, and a sense of escape.


So, embrace the differences and discover the entertainment that speaks to you. Whether it's a thrilling adventure, a heartwarming drama, or a side-splitting comedy, there's something out there for everyone to enjoy.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I sat on the terrace, my gaze fixed down the valley with the majestic Pic d’Anie in the Pyrenean mountain range as the backdrop.

As I reached the last sentence of The Wasp Factory, I gently closed my Kindle, a smile playing on my lips as I contemplated this extraordinary book.

If it hadn't been for Richard's excellent review a few days ago, I would never have purchased it.

Strangely enough, just from the title, I had a hunch that I would enjoy this book.

Something in my brain kept drumming that I had to read it.

This is not my usual genre at all. It's described as a Gothic horror, and yet, once I started reading, I couldn't put it down.

I really don't understand it. I can't stand torture and cruelty to animals, but through Frank Cauldhame's eyes, a rather unusual sixteen-year-old, I was able to enter his special world.

I immediately warmed to his strange ways and ideas and even felt sorry for this maladjusted adolescent.

I felt he was on the path of self-discovery.

Unfortunately, he was also a murderer.

"That's my score to date. Three. I haven't killed anybody for years and don't intend to ever again. It was just a stage I was going through."

Well, that's comforting to hear, don't you think?

Considering Frank's background, it's hard to blame him for the way he turned out.

He lives on a small island outside the remote Scottish village of Porteneil with his father Angus, who is known to everyone as his uncle.

Angus is decidedly odd but highly intelligent, has a measurement fetish, and tags all the furniture and throughout the house.

He takes a sly delight in asking unanswerable questions to his son, but then he has personally taken over Frank's education.

Frank soon realizes that his father lies a lot and starts going to the local library in Porteneil to check the truth of what his father tells him.

Then there are the manic telephone calls from Frank's highly intelligent but unfortunately insane brother Eric, who has escaped from the psychiatric hospital and is heading home.

Eric wants to give his father a surprise, and Frank knows he will make it even though the police are looking for him.

Eric seems more insane than ever, and although Frank wants to see his brother, he is rather worried about the idea.

Our "hero" is also a loner but still wishes to be accepted into the local community.

His only friend is a dwarf called Jamie.

Nevertheless, Frank hasn't had an easy life.

Firstly, he has a physical problem due to an unfortunate accident with a dog when he was three.

He also feels too fat and wants to look dark and menacing.

"…to look dark and menacing... the way I might have looked if I hadn't had my little accident. Looking at me, you'd never guess I'd killed three people. It isn't fair."

My eyes lit up when I read this.

Now, what's going on here?

When one of the three murders is committed by Frank, you can see his deductive reasoning.

But the author's idea of putting an adder in a child's prosthesis left me spellbound, and I even laughed, to my shame.

Secondly, he doesn't legally exist as his father never bothered to register his birth.

So Frank has to pretend that he doesn't live with his father, is an orphan, and just visits from time to time.

He also has to make sure he's never around when Diggs, the local policeman, calls.

The locals find him strange as his brother Eric went crazy, and they wonder if he will follow the same path.

Frank is very intelligent, a thinker, a dreamer, and also a plotter.

He often thinks about death and how it came to his relatives.

Leviticus Cauldhame, his uncle, had a sticky end in South Africa when a crazed homicidal black threw himself from the top storey and fatally injured him.

His last words in the hospital were: "My God, the buggers've learned to fly…"

Admittedly, Frank does some bizarre things.

He's a teenager, a hunter, a murderer, and seems to be living in a constant state of war or preparation for war.

There's the Bunker, his love of slings and catapults, especially "The Black Destroyer" catapult, bombs, an air rifle, and killing whatever comes his way.

The wasps and the Wasp Factory, however, I found this section fascinating and a tour de force.

This is the central part of the book and the most puzzling as it involves choice and the different experiences of the wasps that enter the factory.

As for the Rabbit Grounds, it's excellent although gruesome.

Frank sees a buck that he thinks is an avenging rabbit, and he's genuinely frightened.

Even though there's violence and cruelty in the book that I abhor, I felt hooked as the prose is both chilling and enthralling.

There are elements of secrecy and unfathomable aspects that gradually come to light.

For example, Angus has a study that he always locks, and Frank is determined to get in as he's sure there's a secret.

Also, Frank's love of water and making dams, then changing them.

The themes of water and fire run throughout the book.

He's a very energetic and active lad both mentally and physically.

I could also relate to Frank's liking for bombs as my elder brother Ken made a bomb when he was about fourteen and blew up the pond in our garden.

I was also intrigued by Frank's statement: "My greatest enemies are Women and the Sea. These things I hate. Women because they are weak and stupid and live in the shadow of men and are nothing compared to them, and the Sea because it has always frustrated me, destroying what I have built, washing away what I have left, wiping clean the marks I have made. And I'm not all that sure the Wind is blameless either."

This is understandable considering his mother left him shortly after he was born, and his brother Eric's mother died in childbirth.

The journeys of Angus, Frank, and Eric finally come together in the most unexpected denouement.

In conclusion, this mind-blowing book is ghoulish with unfortunate descriptions of torture and cruelty, but it must be read.

It's captivating, funny in parts, full of black humour, philosophical, and I could even empathize with the "murderer" at times.

This is an excellent book by the late Iain Banks that requires in-depth digestion.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**The Wasp Factory: A Thought-Provoking and Disturbing Novel**

The question of whether violence and cruelty are innate to human nature or if man is inherently civilized is a profound one, and it is explored in the controversial and captivating novel, The Wasp Factory. Iain Banks invites us into the mind of Frank Cauldhame, a seriously disturbed teenager. With a reclusive scientist father, an absent mother, and a crazy elder brother, Frank's life is far from ordinary. His birth has never been registered, and he has had a traumatic "accident" that has left him without a penis.

As the story unfolds, Eric, Frank's elder brother, escapes from the asylum and makes his way home. Against this backdrop, the novel takes the form of an interior monologue of the protagonist. Frank's callousness and lack of empathy, combined with his astute brain and technological bent of mind, make him an extremely interesting, yet not likeable, character. He kills animals and conducts strange rituals, and his greatest achievement is the creation of the Wasp Factory, a contraption for killing wasps.

The pluses of the novel include the narrative tone and the disturbing and nightmarish world created by the author. Banks uses wild and fantastic elements to distance us from the horror and focus on the absurd. He also uses Frank's crazed brain to mock the sacred cows of the modern world, such as religion, technology, and politics. However, the ending of the novel was a letdown for the reviewer. The "big" secret was pointless and did not seem to convey a clear message. Despite this, the novel is still recommended for readers who are not easily queasy, as it is a powerful and thought-provoking read that will stay with you long after you have finished.

Question: Are violence and cruelty innate to human nature – or is man inherently civilised? This question lies at the heart of The Wasp Factory, and it is one that will continue to haunt readers long after they have turned the final page.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm fairly neutral about my feelings towards this book.

On one hand, I've noticed many people love it, while on the other hand, they hate it. I think I can understand both sides. This was my first encounter with Iain Banks' work. To be honest, I'd probably give one of his other works a chance later on.

The narrator of the story is Frank Cauldhame, a seriously unhinged teenager. His family members each have their own personal demons. I would say he has more to deal with than most teenagers his age, especially considering the accident that essentially eradicated his penis.

From the beginning, we learn about Frank's older brother Eric, who was living in a mental asylum until he escaped. So the story kind of revolves around the waiting and the arrival of Eric back home. I would think psychological illness runs in the family, as the pitiful cruelty to animals is quite prominent in this book. I doubt some of it was even necessary.

Frank is an interesting character. I say this because he completely lacks empathy for the world and anything around him, and his distinct enjoyment of violence poses a great threat to anyone who gets remotely close to him.

I thought the plot dragged a little as I got closer to the end, despite Eric getting closer to finding Frank. Unfortunately, even after discovering the big secret at the end, which I hadn't guessed already, I found it didn't really blow me away. (But it was horrid, and I think it answers a lot of questions.)

This book was disturbing in parts, especially when describing particular deaths. However, I found that Banks used almost flowery descriptions here. I believe this was done in order to put some distance between the reader and the character, and also to remind us that this novel has no normality within it at all.

Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.