I read this many years ago when I was in Girl Scouts of all things and had not yet heard of the Scarlet Letter. I knew a bit about the Puritans because, like most other young girls, I was fascinated by the Salem Witch Trials. This time around, I liked this book as much, or maybe even more than I did the first time. It is one of those YA novels that, despite the lead being a young person, encompasses so much history, family, and relationships that it crosses over to the adult audience very well.
Just as I did back then, I admire Kit and her spunkiness. However, the one thing that I realized that I never even thought of the first time I read this was just how hypocritical the Puritans really were. They left England to pursue freedom of religion and then came here and judged harshly anyone who was different than they were, those who did not see things the way they wanted them to. It's quite eye-opening to see this aspect of their behavior.
I'm glad I had a chance to read this again. It has given me a new perspective on both the story and the historical context in which it is set. It's a reminder that history is full of complex characters and events, and that we can always learn something new from revisiting the past.