Carol Oates' collection of short stories spanning 40 years, from 1966 to 2006, is an extremely readable and often striking one. With a collection of this length, there are bound to be some hits and misses. However, the hits far outnumber the misses. Some stories are okay, while others are stunning and memorable. For example, in one story, an unhappy woman in her early 20s has a messy, unstopped period while speaking with a priest at a seminary. In another, a young man kills himself in his car and an object in the glove compartment may insinuate he would have killed someone else. The collection contains 11 new stories as of 2006, including the title story which is perhaps the best of the bunch. Despite having been writing for over 50 years, Oates shows no sign of losing her touch.
The stories in this collection are diverse and cover a wide range of themes. Some, like "Spider Boy," are chilling and short, exploring the unknown side of someone's personality. Others, like "The Cousins," are award-winning. "The Gathering Squall" has a nice metaphor tying a painting in with the story's theme, while "The Lost Brother" is a good story about the hopelessness of having hope for a lost soul in your family. "High Lonesome" motivated the reviewer to start their own story, and "Upon the Sweeping Flood" is good and memorable, with a recurring image of children suffering at the hands of insane adults.
The collection is broken down into decades, and the stories from the 1970s are all good, though representative of John Updike and maybe Cheever. "The Hair" is a very good, very John Cheever expose of suburban couples, while "Life After High School" is interesting and reminds the reviewer of someone they know. "Mark of Satan" was a story the reviewer was critical of on their blog a long time ago, but now realizes it's not as bad as they thought. Overall, this collection is highly recommended, especially for fans of Oates' gothic stories, although none of those are included here.