Being quite generous, it gets three stars. It didn't work for me and not just because 80% of the book is about American football games, trainings, and strategies. I wouldn't have minded if the allegory about the Cold War, a term that appears only once in the entire text, had been about chess, and it would also have been a valid metaphor for the era.
It's strange to analyze the book that I would have liked to read. The main problem is the proportion dedicated to American football versus that dedicated to other very brilliant matters that only appear as almost allusions without continuation. Verdict: the book is not guilty of the amount of ink spent on a story about football but of the ink not spent on developing ideas. Conclusion: the book lacks pages.
I would have liked to know more about:
- Gary's (the narrator, an American football player) concerns. All the synopses mention them, DeLillo exposes them but doesn't go into depth.
- The Mongolian science fiction author that DeLillo invents and for whom he even creates a story.
- The Jew who wants to de-Judaize himself (as if that were possible) and the phase in which Myna (the narrator's partner) and an overweight player resist the imposed canons just to preserve their identity.
- The sudden change of Myna.
- The process by which Taft, the most promising player on the team and the one who opens the book, goes through to stand up and challenge the conventions.
The book circles around themes such as identity, social integration, and the efforts to be worthy of it but doesn't quite land. There are passages of a cynical humor that draw on rather ingenious stereotypes. What a pity that lack of pages.