Community Reviews

Rating(3.9 / 5.0, 17 votes)
5 stars
5(29%)
4 stars
5(29%)
3 stars
7(41%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
17 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
The experience I had was truly horrifying. It was so overwhelming that it made me want to slit my wrists.

Every moment felt like a never-ending torture. The pain and the stress were just too much to bear.

I found myself in a dark and desolate place, with no hope in sight. The world around me seemed to have turned its back on me.

I was completely alone, with only my thoughts and my pain for company.

I don't know how I managed to get through that difficult time, but somehow I did.

Looking back now, I realize how close I came to giving up. But I'm glad I didn't, because things have gotten better since then.

However, the memory of that experience still haunts me, and I know that it will always be a part of me.

It serves as a reminder of how strong I can be, even in the face of the most difficult challenges.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The book I recently picked up was, unfortunately, a major disappointment.

It was just too critical throughout, and to be completely honest, the writing style was extremely dry.

It lacked the engaging and captivating elements that would have kept me hooked from start to finish.

As a result, it quickly ended up in my list of DNFed (Did Not Finish) books.

I had high hopes for this particular read, but it failed to deliver on multiple fronts.

The overly critical tone made it feel more like a lecture than an enjoyable literary experience.

And the dry writing style simply made it a chore to get through each page.

I'm disappointed that I had to add this book to my DNF list, but sometimes you just have to admit that a book isn't for you.

Hopefully, my next literary adventure will be more fulfilling and engaging.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This is the very first biography that has been written about Plath. However, it should be noted that it doesn't consider the entirety of the Collected Journals. The reason for this is that they were not yet published at the time this biography was written.

Despite this limitation, this biography delves more deeply into her formative years than some other works. It explores the events, experiences, and people that shaped Plath's early life and had a significant impact on her development as a writer and a person.

By focusing on her formative years, the author is able to provide a more detailed and nuanced understanding of Plath's character, her creative process, and the factors that influenced her writing. This makes the biography a valuable addition to the existing body of work on Plath and offers readers a unique perspective on her life and work.

Overall, while this biography may not be comprehensive in its coverage of Plath's life and work, it does offer valuable insights into her formative years and is well worth reading for anyone interested in learning more about this influential writer.
July 15,2025
... Show More

There are loads of interesting and gossipy details. It's truly a captivating story. For example, consider these two representative sentences. The first one, "Surely such an important public figure should not have a vacuum foetus growing so hideously in her virgin cave." This sentence creates a vivid and almost grotesque image, making one wonder about the strange and perhaps scandalous situation.


The second sentence, "Her multiple selves had been exposed at last, at a very high cost to be sure; and now a courageous plunge into genuine catharsis might have released her imprisoned bitch goddess once and for all." It delves into the idea of a person having multiple aspects to their personality that have now been revealed, and the possibility of a cathartic release. It's a thought-provoking statement that adds depth to the overall narrative.


Together, these sentences offer a tantalizing glimpse into a world full of drama, mystery, and perhaps a touch of the macabre. They leave the reader eager to discover more about the story and the characters involved.

July 15,2025
... Show More
As a Plath completist, I was drawn to this particular work out of sheer curiosity.

However, I don't believe it was ever made available in the UK.

To be honest, it wasn't a very good read.

Instead, I would highly recommend reading "Red Comet."

By far, it is the best autobiography of Plath that I have come across.

Although it is quite long, it is extremely readable.

The author has managed to present Plath's life in a way that is engaging and accessible, without any unnecessary psychiatric biases or agendas.

It offers a comprehensive and nuanced view of Plath's life, from her early years to her tragic end.

Overall, "Red Comet" is a must-read for anyone interested in Sylvia Plath and her work.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was truly fascinating. It didn't just trace Plath's development as a writer, but also neatly matched it up to what was happening in her life. It was a remarkable exploration that delved deep into both aspects.

The way it was written was also excellent. The author had a great command of the language, presenting the information in a clear and engaging manner.

It was as if one could see Plath's evolution as a writer unfold before their eyes, in sync with the events and emotions of her personal life.

This connection between her writing and her life added an extra layer of depth and interest to the entire narrative.

Overall, it was a captivating piece that offered valuable insights into the mind and work of Sylvia Plath.

July 15,2025
... Show More

A beautifully written harrowing tale unfolds, revealing the tragic story of a self-destructive life. The protagonist's actions have taken a heavy toll on her daughter. We witness the downward spiral of the mother, her choices leading to a series of events that have a profound impact on the innocent child. The daughter, caught in the middle, endures the consequences with a silent strength that is both heart-wrenching and inspiring. As the story progresses, we see the mother's self-destruction accelerate, and the daughter's world crumble around her. Yet, through it all, there is a glimmer of hope that perhaps, one day, they will both find a way to heal and move forward.

July 15,2025
... Show More
It was indeed a good read, yet it had a somewhat didactic tone. He appeared to be overly critical of the work she accomplished during her childhood. After all, who in their right mind would anticipate a young child's poetry to possess a professional quality? If you don't have an issue with a significant amount of academic language, then this is worth reading.





Blessed Be Comments



~Magickal Graphics~

This piece of writing had its merits, but the didactic nature detracted a little. The criticism of the child's work seemed rather harsh. It's important to remember that a child's creativity should be nurtured and not judged too severely. However, if you're interested in a text that employs academic language, then this might be suitable for you.

The accompanying images and links add an extra dimension to the overall presentation. The picture of "Blessed Be Comments" catches the eye and makes the reader curious to explore further. The link to "Magickal Graphics" provides an opportunity for those who want to know more about the source or the author's other works.

Overall, it's a piece that has its pros and cons, but it can still offer some value to the right reader.
July 15,2025
... Show More
What makes this biography so dreadfully boring is not that Edward Butscher is malicious or has some ulterior motive against Sylvia or anything of that sort.

The core problem lies in the fact that the life she led simply didn't possess the same level of drama and gut-wrenching emotion as the poetry she penned. The reader gradually gets the sense that the biographer is being insincere, hiding all the demonic fury and eccentricity beneath hundreds of pages filled with details about the lectures she attended and the places where she hunted for bargains.

However, the truth is that for most of her short life, Sylvia Plath was extremely high-functioning, not a jumble of jagged wires crackling with electricity. She dedicated a significant amount of time to mundane tasks and strived to meet other people's dull expectations of what a co-ed, poet, wife, and mother should be. Therefore, reading about all that becomes tediously uninteresting.

Here's another thought, and I truly do not intend this to be disrespectful. In Albert Goldman's caustic classic biography ELVIS, he makes a point about Elvis that is highly relevant. He describes Elvis in Vegas during the Seventies, completely doped out of his mind, sporting sunglasses and a sequined jumpsuit. And when the Colonel, his manager, comes to inspect him before the show, Goldman remarks, "like all junkies, Elvis is an expert at conning the squares that he's straight."

Now, I mean this in the most empathetic and admiring way possible. But poor Sylvia Plath was a great deal like Elvis. Because she was a genius, she transformed the world, and being extraordinary ultimately cost her life. But also because, similar to Elvis, she was a master at deceiving the ordinary folk into believing she was normal. All the activities she engaged in during college, all the Vogue fashion spreads, all the hustle and self-promotion as the perfect young American wife/writer/woman were really her means of masking all the terrifying, destructive energy that was only unleashed in her final twenty or thirty poems. The reason a narrative of her life is so lackluster is because it only captures the superficial facade that she constructed with such frantic energy. And the reader feels cheated.

On the other hand, in another aspect, Sylvia Plath was the polar opposite of Elvis. Because she never betrayed her talent and she left this world at the peak of her abilities. Her last poems were her finest, and she literally sacrificed her life to achieve her best as an artist.

I suspect Elvis took his own life to evade that kind of challenge.
July 15,2025
... Show More
DNFed at chapter 5. Do you even like her, Edward?

It seems rather strange to stop reading at chapter 5. One might wonder what exactly led to this decision. Was it something in the story that didn't quite click? Or perhaps there was a lack of connection with the characters.

The question "Do you even like her, Edward?" adds an element of mystery. Is this a reference to a specific female character in the story? Maybe the reader is questioning Edward's feelings towards her.

It could be that the writing style wasn't to the reader's taste, or the plot wasn't developing in a way that held their interest. There could be many reasons for DNFing at this point.

Without further context, it's difficult to say for sure. However, it does make one curious about what might have happened if the reader had continued reading. Would their opinion of the story and the characters have changed?

In any case, DNFing is a personal choice, and everyone has different preferences when it comes to reading. Maybe this particular story just wasn't the right fit for this reader.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A writer's tragic story of suicide is a deeply saddening and thought-provoking event.

This individual, perhaps burdened by inner demons, the pressures of society, or personal hardships, chose to end their life.

The act of suicide not only extinguishes a life but also leaves a void in the hearts of those who knew and loved the writer.

It serves as a reminder of the importance of mental health awareness and the need for support systems to be in place.

We should strive to create a more understanding and empathetic society, where individuals feel comfortable reaching out for help when they are struggling.

The tragic story of this writer should also prompt us to reflect on the power of words and the impact they can have on our lives.

As readers, we should appreciate the talent and creativity of writers, and offer them the respect and support they deserve.

May the memory of this writer serve as a catalyst for positive change and a reminder that we are all in this together.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I registered a book at BookCrossing.com!

http://www.BookCrossing.com/journal/5178667

I had a great passion for The Bell Jar and desired to know more about Sylvia Plath. This is the very first biography of her life and work. Since then, several others have been penned, which I haven't had the chance to read yet.

The title, Sylvia Plath: Method and Madness, indicates that the book delves deeper than just her life. It closely tracks the development of her poetry. Butscher, a highly respected poet in his own right, makes it logical that he would analyze Plath's poetry. He commences by reviewing the poetry she composed in her teens, then progresses to how it evolved at Smith, and how it transformed dramatically after her marriage to Ted Hughes and the birth of her children. From the outset, he searches for signs that she is uncovering her true self and discovers it only intermittently until near her death.

Plath was born to a strong yet distant father and a mother overly concerned with appearances. Sylvia learned early on how to don a happy face and play the role of the all-American girl. Certainly, she seemed like one. She was attractive, energetic, dressed modestly and tastefully. Her approach to the world as a person was mirrored in her poetry.

Butscher claims she had different selves, with one of those selves - what he terms the "bitch goddess" - being hidden away most of the time. I had a bit of trouble discerning what the definition of "bitch goddess" was for Butscher. It holds a distinct meaning for different individuals. I think Butscher's definition is that of a woman transcending the cultural limitations of womanhood, an angry yet perceptive woman.

The book presumes that the reader already has knowledge of Plath's life. References are frequently made to future events in a casual manner. We know the end, of course, but many of us are not privy to all the details in between. Thus, there is a certain distance between the writer and the subject. I found it challenging to get to know Sylvia. That, of course, is what Butscher asserts was true for most, if not all, the people she encountered.

Butscher also focuses on Sylvia's "madness." In his Afterword, he states that she was likely bi-polar and, of course, lived with depression for much of the time. I believe such categories are best left aside, as I don't have a great affinity for psychiatric definitions. Clearly, she was profoundly depressed at the end. Due to an accident, she never received a referral to a therapist who might have saved her life in that final week, but who can say?

I wondered what her voice sounded like, so I have searched for recordings. Fortunately for us, we can find them easily. I like her voice. It is educated, clear, and distinct. These recordings provide me with a more comprehensive sense of her. I wanted more.

The book offers a good understanding of who she was, how she wrote, and how she ultimately broke through to revealing her inner self. I continue to find her fascinating and may seek out other biographies and read more of her poetry.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.