Once again, as I delved into the novels included in the collection, I found myself grappling with the age-old question of where the boundary lies between high and popular literature. Then I recalled a line from the movie "The Cloud Atlas" - all boundaries are just illusions. And King, in his own words, precisely in this book, is not a charlatan. He tells stories. Some of them I would (and have) thrown in the trash. Others remain in both the heart and the library. Because what is a good story if not good literature?
With great interest, I read how Uncle Stevie, in frustration, decided to take on his horror publisher with this relatively early collection of four different stories. Yes, publishers are a bad thing not only if they stick to you but also if you let yourself become attached to them.
"Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption" 5⭐️
For me, this is one of the two pearls in the collection. After reading it, although I knew the plot at least from the movie, which is also an excellent interpretation, I pondered over what I had read for a long time. What does the story actually tell? About the prison system in the US and the deep corruption and degradation, about the slum, considered far from the eyes of respectable society, where justice and redemption have not yet arrived and sometimes one wonders if the death penalty is not after all more humane in some cases? About the social stratifications themselves, which - neglected and deprived of possible losses for improvement - are doomed to reproduce the same waste human products on both sides of the fence, with the difference that some throw Bibles in their offices? About human dignity, and - yes, about the human spirit - which still exist and still cannot be stopped even in Shawshank? I think Emmer Tows was inspired here for his "A Gentleman in Moscow". And I think that "Shawshank" quite insidiously creeps towards that kind of literature that has a chance to fit the definition of "classic" - a book that everyone knows but no one reads...
"The Apt Pupil" 2.5⭐️
This was for me a standard, sharp-edged, and absolutely forgettable commercial mix of historical data, irony towards the Middle West, and a little sociopathy. The title could also be "A Meeting of Two Psychopaths". I expected much more from the niche of Nazism and was disappointed by the superficial look. No, the Nazis were not psychopaths. This is a complete and comforting delusion that Nazism is a deviation that is so rare and extreme that it cannot be repeated on a mass scale. But this story is about fans who are looking for a thrill without any known logic. This is the commercial King with the dollar-printing press.
"The Body" 5⭐️
It is an allusion to the good old Ray Bradbury and his "Dandelion Wine". King, however, leads for at least one length (or 15 kilometers that his heroes cover). The story of growing up in the poor, desolate, and ignorant Middle West is nothing new. But the presentation is with a lot of understanding, delicacy, and love for the four twelve-year-old heroes, who set off on a journey towards an apparently absurd and senseless goal. Every step and word of theirs outlines whole worlds - for the children, left to develop like weeds, without a drop of care, and ultimately turning into superfluous beings; for the US in the 60s, seen from the inside in a rather unusual perspective; for salvation and reconciliation; and again that human spirit that flickers even in the muddy twelve-year-old boys and clumsily and poorly seeks space. Something of Erich Kästner lives in these pages, as well as something deeply personal, dark, soulful, and still not lost hope.
"The Breathing Method" 2.5⭐️
A decent mystery, but not particularly impressive. It seems to draw attention to the history of obstetrics from the dawn of the 20th century, which has caused as much harm as no one dares to admit. And this mentality in science is still spreading with ease. The ending doesn't intrigue me at all.
In two words, the collection is wonderful, even if only because of two of the stories, and I will happily extract quotes from it.
***
Stephen King's collection of novellas is a remarkable one. Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption earns an 8 out of 12. It's a strong story that was adapted into a possibly even better movie. The tale of hope and redemption in a prison setting is truly captivating.
The chilling Apt Pupil also gets an 8 out of 12. When a petulant and cunning young man faces off against true darkness and greater cunning, it makes for a thrilling and disturbing read. The story takes unexpected turns as the young man believes he's uncovered a Nazi war criminal.
The Body, also known as the movie 'Stand By Me', receives a 9.5 out of 12. It's a truly remarkable and heartwarming coming-of-age novella. It's one of the author's best works and has even been used in American schools as part of the literature curriculum. It's that good!
Finally, The Breathing Method gets a 7.5 out of 12. While it may not be as compelling as the others, it still showcases King's talent. Overall, this collection is a must-read for any Stephen King fan or lover of great literature. It's contemporary writing at its finest.
Halfway Through
Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption*****
The Breathing Method****
The Body****
The Apt Pupil**
My first (serious) encounter with Stephen King. I had already read Gerald's Game, but I was told I had been rather unlucky with my first attempt. So, although I'm not a big fan of the genre, I asked for something more representative and not overly burdensome in terms of volume and content.
I must say that I already knew two of the four stories in their cinematic versions; I'm referring to two films that I really liked: The Shawshank Redemption and Stand by Me. At the moment, I've only read Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption, from which, as I said, the first of the two films I mentioned was made, and I'm two-thirds of the way through The Apt Pupil - there's also a cinematic adaptation of this one, but frankly, it doesn't seem to have been well-received by the public or critics.
Just one and a half stories, quite long in terms of pages, and I'm already at a crossroads; on the one hand, I really liked the first one, both in terms of plot and writing, while the second one is fully reflecting the negative impression I had when reading Gerald's Game. Anyway, I'll continue: to draw final conclusions, I'm waiting to read the other two stories.
After finishing reading, I have to say that the only story that I didn't really like is The Apt Pupil; even the last one, although revealing a supernatural twist that doesn't exactly match the kind of things I like to read, kept me glued to the last page. At a certain point, I thought I "discovered" a thread that connected the stories to each other - and in fact, it's partially true: one of the protagonists of Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption is called Andy Dufresne, and Andy Dufresne is also the financial consultant of Mr. Denker/Dussander in the second story; The Body, finally, is set just a few steps from the Shawshank prison that is indeed mentioned in the same story - but I haven't been able to find the connection with The Breathing Method: either I missed it or it wasn't there, but I'd like to be sure. Overall, however, I have to revise my half-judgment: let's say King is three-quarters good :-)