Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
37(37%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
32(32%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More

A departure from his other novels, this installment is truly magnificent and dreamlike. It takes place towards the end of the Korean War, a time filled with pathos, warfare, and a complex web of relationships involving women, men, children, enemies, soldiers, and citizens. The story delves into the nuances of human nature, exploring both benevolence and cruelty. With a deep look and a masterly insight, it examines the human condition from multiple perspectives. It is reminiscent of the profound writers who dare to stare into the absurdities and horrors that shape us all. In this narrative, a Korean man, a woman, and a boy are interposed with Americans, Koreans, Chinese, and Russians, creating a rich tapestry of cultures and experiences.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Set during the tumultuous Korean War, this is an incredibly moving and heartrending tale.

An elderly couple, in the midst of fleeing the danger that is sweeping across their war-torn country, comes across a dying orphan.

Despite their own precarious situation, they selflessly decide to rescue the child.

These three characters embody selfless love, the animistic fear that grips them in the face of war, and the instinctual drive for survival.

The title of the book, curiously, is derived from the refrain of a Christian hymn, "Have Thine own way Lord," which keeps repeating throughout the narrative.

Strangely, no one seems to fully understand its meaning.

Paradoxically, however, the common grace of God seems to abound over these lost travelers.

This is a book that is both sad and poignant, leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

It forces us to confront the harsh realities of war while also highlighting the power of love and the possibility of grace even in the most desperate of circumstances.

It is a story that will stay with you long after you have turned the final page.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Chaim Potok is a renowned author who frequently incorporates Jewish characters in his novels or delves into the daily life of Jews. In 'I am the Clay', he not only touches on the Korean War but also explores the experiences of three specific individuals and how the war impacts their lives.

The Korean War is vividly portrayed in all its devastating and horrific aspects through Potok's intense and detailed prose. What stands out is the unique perspective from which the story is told - through the eyes of a married couple and the boy they rescue from the brink of death.

While many of us have read about the Korean War from the American perspective, Potok offers a refreshing and poignant narrative through the eyes of actual Korean individuals who are striving to survive the horror and atrocities thrust upon them.

As is his trademark, Potok weaves spirituality and religious beliefs throughout the pages. These beliefs, which have been passed down through generations, play a significant role in the daily lives of the three main characters - the old man, the woman, and the boy. Each character has their own way of connecting with the spiritual realm and honoring their ancestors.

The old man, although a hardened soul, is spiritual in his own way. He carries a box containing the spirits of his ancestors wherever he goes. The woman, on the other hand, is kind and caring, treating the boy as if he were her own son. She demonstrates a deep sense of spirituality and a strong commitment to honoring and remembering her deceased relatives, often speaking with their spirits. The boy, too, is spiritual, believing in the power and influence of the deceased.

Chaim Potok's own experiences in the military during the Korean War, serving as a Chaplain in South Korea, add an extra layer of authenticity to the story. 'I Am the Clay' is a powerful tale that encompasses themes of loss and redemption, war and survival, spirituality and ancestral spirits, superstition and myths, traditions and beliefs. It is a story that showcases the resilience of the human spirit and the ability to overcome adversity through perseverance. I highly recommend this book to anyone looking for a thought-provoking and engaging read.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I'm gradually making my way through the reading of each and every one of Chaim Potok's books.

As I do so, I truly savor the time in between. I know that, in due course, I will pick up another one.

And I'm confident that it too, just like the ones before, will be a highly rewarding and beautifully written novel.

"I Am The Clay" was truly so different.

However, the haunting story of war varies little regardless of the different landscapes where it occurs.

Whether it's in Poland, France, Syria, Sarajevo, or Korea...

Potok has masterfully brought to life the daily struggle.

And by struggle, I mean it in a way that most of us can't even begin to fathom.

He presents it vividly, yet with a certain warmth.

This warmth has me eagerly turning the pages, hoping at every turn for the survival of the old man, the old woman, and the young boy.

They are strangers to the boy, but ultimately grow to deeply care for him, even though he is not their blood, in a land where caring can sometimes lead to death.

It's a story that grips you and makes you think about the power of human connection in the face of war and adversity.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Meh


"Meh" is a rather interesting and somewhat dismissive term. It's an expression that conveys a sense of indifference or mild dissatisfaction. When someone says "meh," it implies that they don't have a strong opinion one way or the other about something. It could be in response to a movie, a meal, or an idea. For example, if you ask someone how they liked a particular book and they reply with a simple "meh," it means they didn't find it overly exciting or engaging. It's a short and sweet way to express a lack of enthusiasm. Sometimes, "meh" can also be used in a more lighthearted or humorous way. It's a word that has gained popularity in recent years, especially in casual conversations and online communication. So, the next time you're feeling a bit lukewarm about something, don't be afraid to just say "meh."
July 15,2025
... Show More
There is an abundance of miserable cold and intense suffering, with death constantly lurking nearby.

The palpable tension holds the reader's attention firmly, making them wonder if anyone will manage to survive this harrowing ordeal.

The spirit world seems to be all around, apparently content with meager yet precious food offerings and certain hand signs that are vertical and horizontal, resembling a cross.

The woman sings a line from a foreign song. Although she has no idea of its meaning, she knows that it gives her hope. It is the English hymn, “Have Thine own way, Lord.”

This isn't a light or enjoyable read, but it does succeed in evoking a deep sense of compassion for the plight of the poor who are caught in the crosshairs of war.

And within this rough and painful path of suffering, the power of love is gradually revealed, shining a glimmer of light in the darkness.

July 15,2025
... Show More
Have I read an excessive number of books about war, to the extent that I am unable to appreciate yet another one? Perhaps. Did I initially anticipate reading about Korea, only to later realize that the author was American? Perhaps. In the first few chapters, it was interesting enough. However, it irritated me that the characters were nameless. I found myself debating with myself about how old "the old woman" and "the old man" were, whether by Korean or American calculation.

Nevertheless, I soon lost interest. By the time the old woman passed away, I simply did not care. While she was alive, at least she was experiencing emotions, whereas the old man seemed to have enough bitterness within him to last a lifetime.

That being said, I have since looked up the author and watched the film "The Chosen" which was made from his novel. As a result, I may give another one of his books a try.

I am still curious to see if his other works can capture my attention and engage me in a more profound way. Maybe I will discover a new perspective on war or a story that truly touches my heart. Only time will tell.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Chaim Potok, a renowned Jewish rabbi, has once again delved into the realm of Christian themes to craft this captivating story.

His ability to seamlessly incorporate elements from different religious traditions adds a unique layer of depth and complexity to the narrative.

The story unfolds in a way that keeps the reader engaged from start to finish, with its rich characters and thought-provoking plot.

It offers a fresh perspective on familiar themes, challenging the reader to think beyond their own beliefs and preconceptions.

Overall, it is a great read that not only entertains but also启迪 the mind and spirit.

Whether you are a fan of Potok's previous works or new to his writing, this story is sure to leave a lasting impression.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I have long been a fan of Chaim Potok's works and have derived great pleasure from reading them.

However, when it comes to this specific book, I must admit that I was a bit let down.

For me, it seemed to lack the necessary depth in character development. The characters didn't quite come alive on the page, and I struggled to form an emotional connection with them.

It's a shame because I know Potok is capable of creating rich and complex characters that draw the reader in and make them care deeply about their fates.

If you're looking to experience the true genius of Chaim Potok, I would highly recommend reading some of his other books.

There are many gems in his oeuvre that are sure to satisfy your literary cravings and leave you with a profound appreciation for his writing.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was interesting enough to keep my attention.

Just like the previous Potok work I read, "The Chosen", the author spends numerous pages delving into subjects that fascinate him.

Mostly, it is the meandering inner thoughts of the characters as they strive not to freeze to death during the night.

Surprisingly, he then allocates very little space to relatively important subsequent life events.

And the story wraps up in what appears to be a sequel-needing haste.

Content advisory: There are several explicit mentions of anatomy and sexual thoughts.

This unique style of writing makes the reading experience both engaging and a bit frustrating at times.

On one hand, the detailed exploration of the characters' inner worlds adds depth and authenticity.

On the other hand, the lack of proper attention to major life events leaves the reader longing for more.

Overall, it is a thought-provoking piece that leaves a lasting impression.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Chaim Potok is indeed attempting to convey a profound meaning, or at the very least, a deep interrogation of meaning.

Yet, he also expends great efforts in depicting the sights, sounds, and smells - the overall sensation of the chaos and helplessness endured by civilians during war. This results in a succession of dreary pictures, one after another.

It is analogous to a painting where you can understand what the artist is attempting to express, but you would not desire to have it in your home.

Another significant drawback for me is Potok's frequent utilization of my least favored literary device, stream of consciousness (thus the similarity to Faulkner).

A reread might potentially be necessary to fathom what Potok is striving to convey, but the dreariness will likely deter me from undertaking that.

Overall, while there are aspects of Potok's work that hold interest, the combination of the overly dreary portrayal and the use of a less favored literary device makes it a less appealing read for me.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This was a truly tough read due to the subject matter. It contains heartwrenching descriptions of the deprivations and degradations that war brings.

I absolutely loved the character of the old woman. She had the remarkable ability to see and feel the power of love, even in the midst of such chaos and destruction.

The book beautifully portrays the resilience of the human spirit. It shows how, despite the ugliness of human frailty and the sometimes inhuman inclinations of people, there is still a glimmer of beauty and hope.

It also emphasizes the importance of family and the love that binds family members together. This aspect of the book really made me think about the significance of family in our lives.

Furthermore, the book provided good food for thought on the commonalities of religious beliefs. It showed how men of different beliefs sometimes grapple with their religious convictions in similar ways.

I really like the title of the book. It was what initially caught my eye at the library. The meanings and analogies connected with the title in relation to the story added an extra layer of depth and interest.

Overall, I would probably give this book 3 1/2 stars. It was a thought-provoking and engaging read that left a lasting impression on me.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.