Community Reviews

Rating(4.1 / 5.0, 100 votes)
5 stars
37(37%)
4 stars
31(31%)
3 stars
32(32%)
2 stars
0(0%)
1 stars
0(0%)
100 reviews
July 15,2025
... Show More
This meandering narrative of Korean War refugees earnestly endeavors to depict the hopelessness, self-preservation, and spiritual beliefs of three characters.

The author, Chaim Potok, abruptly switches from third-person to first-person points of view within paragraphs without any prior indication. At times, he devotes numerous pages to describing the setup of a primitive camp.

And then, without any transition, the story instantaneously shifts to a different circumstance in a different location. There appears to be an inequality in the attention given to various aspects of the journey, and the reason for this is not immediately clear.

The conclusion takes place during a significant life change, yet the meaningful analysis and character development had just begun. Interestingly, the causes of the war itself are never mentioned.

It is simply assumed that the reader already knows and understands how it affects the immediate environment. This lack of clarity regarding the war's causes may leave some readers feeling somewhat confused or unsatisfied.

However, despite these flaws, the narrative still manages to capture the essence of the refugees' experiences and the complex emotions they must have felt during this difficult time.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**Title: Gelezen april 1996**

In April 1996, a significant event took place.

It was a month filled with anticipation and excitement.

The air seemed to be charged with a sense of possibility.

People from all walks of life were looking forward to what the future held.

Perhaps it was a time of new beginnings, of starting fresh and pursuing dreams.

Maybe there were plans in the works, ideas that were about to come to fruition.

The events of that April would go on to shape the months and years that followed.

They would leave an indelible mark on the memories of those who experienced them.

Looking back on Gelezen april 1996, it is clear that it was a month of great significance.

It was a time when the world was on the cusp of change, and anything seemed possible.

July 15,2025
... Show More
I am truly surprised by the lackluster reviews that this book has received.

Although it deviated from Potok's typical exploration of Jewish social and historical issues, it was, without a doubt, an extremely powerful, riveting, and raw work in terms of emotion.

The story within its pages has the ability to grip the reader and draw them in, making it difficult to put down.

Despite not conforming to the expected norms of Potok's previous works, it still manages to stand out as a remarkable piece of literature.

For me, it remains firmly as one of my all-time favorite books, a testament to its enduring quality and the impact it has had on me.

I believe that those who have given it lackluster reviews may have missed the true essence and beauty of the story, perhaps due to their preconceived notions or expectations.

This book deserves a second chance, a chance to be read and appreciated for the masterpiece that it truly is.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I don't really know how to feel about this one.

It's the only Potok book not to feature Jewish characters.

This fact alone makes it stand out from the rest of his works.

However, when it comes to the characters, I have to say that they felt a bit stereotypical and empty to me.

They didn't seem to have the depth and complexity that I have come to expect from Potok's writing.

Perhaps it's because he was writing about a different culture and didn't have the same level of familiarity and understanding.

Or maybe it was a conscious choice on his part to present the characters in a more one-dimensional way.

Either way, it was a bit of a disappointment for me as a reader.

I still appreciate Potok's work as a whole, but this particular book didn't quite live up to my expectations.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The cold and emotionless feel that pervades (most of) the book is a perfect fit for the story. It effectively sets the stage for a truly meaningful conclusion.

While it may not be as compelling as some of Potok's other remarkable works, this one is still brilliant, albeit painful.

Potok has a unique approach in that he doesn't rely on overly dramatic showdowns to reach the climax of his stories. Instead, readers need to adjust their expectations and be prepared to follow a narrative that meanders through the impressionistic viewpoints of its characters.

This style allows for a deeper exploration of the characters' inner worlds and emotions, adding a layer of complexity and authenticity to the story.

Overall, despite its differences from his other works, this book依然 manages to captivate and engage readers, leaving them with a lasting impression.
July 15,2025
... Show More
This story is set during the Korean War.

An elderly Korean couple discovers a boy and decides to take care of him.

I had read one of Potok's books before and had expected this one to also be about Judaism. I had actually learned a significant amount about Judaism from the previous book. However, in this particular book, I didn't have the sense that I was learning anything novel about Korean culture or about the war.

It appears that the author is somewhat out of his element. He repeatedly emphasizes their hunger, the spirits, and whether the boy is bad luck or good luck, and so forth. It becomes extremely tedious! And, of course, there is the obligatory "boys are better than girls" trope. I don't get the impression that Potok has a comprehensive understanding of Korea beyond the common stereotypes.

Overall, this book was a disappointment compared to what I had anticipated based on his previous work.
July 15,2025
... Show More
It was truly a remarkable experience to read this particular book from this writer.

Unlike the typical works we are accustomed to seeing from him or her, this one was entirely character driven.

The characters were so vividly portrayed that they seemed to leap off the pages and into our hearts.

The story was not only poignant, tugging at our emotions and making us feel deeply for the characters' plights, but it was also historically accurate.

It provided a fascinating glimpse into a particular era, with all its details and nuances.

Moreover, the psychological power of the book was truly astounding.

It delved deep into the minds and souls of the characters, exploring their fears, desires, and motivations in a way that was both profound and thought-provoking.

Overall, this was a book that will stay with us long after we have turned the final page.
July 15,2025
... Show More
A cross between The Road and The Good Earth, I Am the Clay is a captivating novel that tells the poignant story of three refugees during the Korean War.

Displaced by the horrors of battle from their villages, the Old Man, the Old Woman, and the Boy find themselves unlikely allies.

They form an ersatz family unit as they struggle to survive an intense winter and the grueling geography.

Amidst the chaos of war, they embark on a seemingly unending quest to find some days of peace.

The question lingers: when it's all finally over, will their bond remain?

I clearly loved this book. It reminded me so much of the two other titles listed above.

Moreover, it was a different Potok experience for me, as he usually writes about New York Judaism circa 1945.

This ambitious undertaking truly paid off, making I Am the Clay a must-read for fans of historical fiction.
July 15,2025
... Show More
The Korean War brought deep and profound suffering to the civilians of Korea. This is vividly illustrated when we follow the fortunes of an elderly couple and the child they rescue.

Their story is one of great courage and remarkable resilience. In the face of the chaos and destruction of war, they show unwavering determination.

The elderly couple, despite their own hardships, open their hearts and home to the rescued child. They provide a glimmer of hope in the midst of the darkness.

As they navigate through the war-torn landscape, they encounter numerous challenges and obstacles. But their courage and love for one another and the child keep them going.

Their story serves as a powerful reminder of the human spirit's ability to endure and overcome even the most difficult of circumstances. It is a story that should be remembered and honored.
July 15,2025
... Show More
Tedium reigns for the first 100 pages as Korean peasant refugees struggle day after day after day.

They endure hardships and face countless difficulties in their desperate attempt to survive. But that's kinda the point: The Korean War as seen from the ground up by "little," "unimportant" people.

John Updike's Henry Bech once said, speaking of literature, "Importance isn't important." Goes double for people, yes?

These ordinary individuals, often overlooked in the grand narrative of war, have their own stories to tell.

Not the most compelling of Potok's nine novels, perhaps, but his only one not dealing directly with Judaism.

It offers a unique perspective on a different aspect of human experience.

And not to be missed by those who are interested in understanding the true nature of war and its impact on the lives of the common people.

Those who seek to look beyond the headlines and discover the hidden voices and emotions.

Those who shouldn't miss it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
I enjoyed this probably 2*.

It is definitely not my sort of story or writing. The writing is, I think deliberately, very choppy.

What intrigued me more than most of the story was Potok's topic choice.

What made him choose this?

It is well written, of course, and definitely more appealing to the mainstream masculine audience.

Still, it is a good story - just not one of my favorites.

Strangely enough, just before I picked this up, I quit reading Zusak's Bridge of Clay.

This book is written in the same style - just modern-day and with tons of profanity in it.

I found the choppy writing style a bit off-putting at first, but as I got into the story, I could see the purpose behind it.

Potok's topic choice was also quite interesting, and it made me wonder what inspired him to write about it.

Overall, while this story wasn't a personal favorite, I can appreciate the skill and thought that went into it.
July 15,2025
... Show More
**Title: I Am the Clay**

In the digital age, we are constantly bombarded with information and experiences.

One such thought-provoking piece can be found at https://vramonline.in/2021/05/03/i-am....

The concept of being like clay is an interesting one. We are malleable, constantly being shaped by our surroundings, experiences, and the people we interact with.

Just as a potter molds clay into a beautiful vessel, life molds us into the individuals we become.

We have the power to choose how we respond to the forces that act upon us. We can either resist and become hard and brittle, or we can yield and allow ourselves to be transformed.

The idea of being the clay also implies that we have the potential to be something great. We can be molded into works of art, each with our own unique beauty and purpose.

So, let us embrace our role as the clay and allow life to shape us into the best versions of ourselves.
Leave a Review
You must be logged in to rate and post a review. Register an account to get started.