Unique to my knowledge, this work is truly remarkable. I would highly recommend it to anyone, especially those with an interest in American culture. The incredibly short and terse descriptions have a captivating effect, making you slow down and really soak in the details. It is very human in nature, with great storytelling that feels refreshingly real. There is no bias towards romanticism, instead, it presents the harsh reality of human failing in a brutally honest way. It teeters on the verge of being gloomy but manages to maintain a certain balance.
I think Carver's precision, which gradually lessens as we move through anthologies 1, 2, and 3, makes him seem less human as a storyteller. These stories are so direct that they almost feel objective. A human narrator would likely use more words and a human perspective would not have that same clarity. The lens through which Carver has us look is precise and clear, almost surgical in its accuracy.
Just as clear are the plots. There is typically only one turning point, and the themes are often familiar: men cheat, couples divorce, children fight, and the unemployed despair. However, as we progress through the stories, there is a noticeable brightening. The stories are not always as dark, and the style becomes less curt. Eventually, Carver comes closer to the midline, presenting characters that we believe still have hope and the potential to change. This evolution gives the collection a sense of growth and development that is both engaging and satisfying.
I have seen many comparisons to the artwork of Edward Hopper, with terms like simplicity and 'K-mart realism' being bandied about by those examining this work. Indeed, there is a certain similarity in the way that both Carver and Hopper expose the banal and humdrum lives of ordinary people, laying them bare for all of us to see. It is this ability to capture the essence of the human experience in all its simplicity and complexity that makes Carver's work so enduring and powerful.