After listening to a new recording of the opera "Elmer Gantry" by Robert Aldridge with a libretto by Herschel Garfein, I was compelled to read the famous 1927 novel by Sinclair Lewis on which it was based. The opera, composed in 2007, received an excellent performance from the Milwaukee Symphony Orchestra, the Florentine Opera Company, and a cast of distinguished singers.
The story of Elmer Gantry is familiar from the novel and its movie adaptation. Set in the American Midwest in the early 20th century, Gantry is a football-playing, hard-drinking young man who becomes a minister due to his speaking voice. He is an evangelist before becoming the pastor of increasingly larger churches. Gantry is crude, a scoundrel, and a hypocrite. He has affairs while crusading against vice and narrowly escapes blackmail. He has become a stock hypocritical figure in American literature.
Comparing the novel to the opera was valuable. The novel is lengthy and prolix, while the opera's libretto is a remarkable example of compression. The opera ends with the death of Sharon Falconer, the most fascinating character in both the opera and the novel. In the opera, she is a more complex character than in the book. The opera also shows sympathy for the Midwest rural people, which is absent in Lewis' novel.
In some ways, the opera improves upon the novel, but it is no substitute for reading the book. The book has substantial strengths, such as its detailed portrayal of harsh life in the Midwest. It takes its time to develop the story, from 1902 to the mid-1920s. The key section involves the portrayal of Sharon Falconer and Gantry's relationship with her. After her death, Gantry becomes involved in New Thought and has a series of affairs.
The book has been criticized for its one-sided portrayal of religion, but it is not a total anti-religious screed. It includes some thoughtful discussions of religion and includes two good, thoughtful characters. Despite its flaws, "Elmer Gantry" is a powerful novel that held my interest and inspired thought. I also enjoyed the operatic version, which realized the book's potential for an artistic rendition in music. I was glad to have the opportunity to read the classic American novel and think more about Elmer Gantry and American religion.
Robin Friedman
Sinclair Lewis's "Elmer Gantry," first published in 1927, is a captivating work of fiction that offers a detailed character study of a corrupt Protestant Christian evangelist. Elmer Gantry is the type of preacher that people despise, with his slippery and conniving ways. He combines the worst qualities of infamous televangelists like Jim and Tammy Bakker, Jimmy Swaggert, Peter Popoff, and Jerry Falwell. The novel shows how Gantry leaves a trail of destruction as he ruins lives in his quest for power and personal gain.
Despite the rather unappealing subject matter, Lewis tells the story masterfully. The book is not only a scathing critique of religious hypocrisy but also a commentary on the human lust for power. In the original review, the reader gave it a rating of 7/10. However, upon rereading in 2023, the reviewer was struck by the humor in the story. Living through a period with a detestable figure in the White House, the humor in Lewis's tale became more evident.
The power of Lewis's writing is also remarkable. Even with a few outdated words from the early 20th century, his dialogue and prose sound contemporary to a 21st-century reader. This updated review raises the rating to 7.5/10 and four stars, highlighting the enduring relevance and quality of "Elmer Gantry."